5 ms·
That's cool but dogs remembering names is more insightful in an exciting way, let me elucidate on why it's pretty fascinating! We know how place memories work
by authorfly 2y ago
That's cool but dogs remembering names is more insightful in an exciting way, let me elucidate on why it's pretty fascinating!
We know how place memories work quite well, Place and Grid cells specifically. There is a natural and almost physical level of 1:1 mapping at various scales[1] from location (based on different tracking systems - point integration, landmarks, your own steps) to activating cells in your brain. Simple co-activation alongside reward, like a literal map, sets down "good stuff here" signs in your brain.
Once attenuated and activated by Dopamine, the place cells to triangulate (at different "distances") that position have basically fewer mechanims and binding opportunities for neurotransmitters to change upon other interaction(they have little input beside place + pleasure + pain), so they do not result in loss of their attenuation or association (part of why place stays longest in Alhzeimers patients association).
Memory of sounds however, isn't so clearly mappable, there is no obvious grid/comparable formulation of sound memories in any kind of "order" like there is with location and places in Place Cells. And clearly we humans forget many of the sounds we have heard (e.g. songs, lyrics). That's why it's quite interesting that dogs remember toys names for a long time. It makes you ask questions like "If we had less sounds/named things to remember, could we remember the ones we do remember for much longer, with less forgetting?". "What is the difference between permanent, event and temporal memories?", "Could we resolve neurodegenerative diseases by modifying neurons to be longer lasting or impervious to future modification in strategic areas of the brain? Could be retain some learning?"
[1] http://www.rsb.org.uk/images/biologist/Features/Grid_mouse_diagram_large.jpg http://www.rsb.org.uk/images/biologist/Features/Grid_mouse_d...
- csallen 2y agoThis is all fascinating stuff. I love the idea behind memory palaces, and this stuff about place/grid cells sounds like the explanatory science behind it. Any reading you'd recommend? > And clearly we humans forget many of the sounds we have heard (e.g. songs, lyrics).> It's true we forget many sounds, but songs and lyrics is a curious example. I'd guess those were high on the list of things humans are good at remembering… maybe #4 behind places, faces, and language in general? I've had pop lyrics and commercial jingles and theme songs rattling around in my head for decades, and I can easily sing them word for word. Something about a sequence of words put to a beat and a melody just seems to stick.
- blinkeer 2y agoDominic OBrien is a memory champion. He's got some good material on it. https://artofmemory.com/blog/how-to-build-a-memory-palace/ https://artofmemory.com/blog/how-to-build-a-memory-palace/ https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dominic_O%27Brien https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dominic_O%27Brien https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9684328-you-can-have-an-amazing-memory https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/9684328-you-can-have-an-...
- 082349872349872 2y ago> we humans forget many of the sounds we have heard I could probably make better use of my neurons than storing all the obsolete advertising jingles that still come to mind half a century later. Lagniappe: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=djMjYgqFrrQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=djMjYgqFrrQ