4 ms·
The article includes the interesting comment that a fairly eminent geometrician had little number sense of the kind described in the article. One of the wonderf
by tokenadult 18y ago
The article includes the interesting comment that a fairly eminent geometrician had little number sense of the kind described in the article. One of the wonderful things about mathematics is that it combines reasoning about discrete, countable things, that is numbers, with reasoning about shapes, that is geometry. An especially good book about both aspects of mathematics is John Stillwell's Numbers and Geometry.
http://www.amazon.com/Numbers-Geometry-John-Stillwell/dp/0387982892/ http://www.amazon.com/Numbers-Geometry-John-Stillwell/dp/038...
I'll quote a bit of Stillwell's preface to give the flavor of the book:
"What should every aspiring mathematician know? The answer for most of the 20th century has been: calculus. . . . Mathematics today is . . . much more than calculus; and the calculus now taught is, sadly, much less than it used to be. Little by little, calculus has been deprived of the algebra, geometry, and logic it needs to sustain it, until many institutions have had to put it on high-tech life-support systems. A subject struggling to survive is hardly a good introduction to the vigor of real mathematics.
". . . . In the current situation, we need to revive not only calculus, but also algebra, geometry, and the whole idea that mathematics is a rigorous, cumulative discipline in which each mathematician stands on the shoulders of giants.
"The best way to teach real mathematics, I believe, is to start deeper down, with the elementary ideas of number and space. Everyone concedes that these are fundamental, but they have been scandalously neglected, perhaps in the naive belief that anyone learning calculus has outgrown them. In fact, arithmetic, algebra, and geometry can never be outgrown, and the most rewarding path to higher mathematics sustains their development alongside the 'advanced' branches such as calculus. Also, by maintaining ties between these disciplines, it is possible to present a more unified view of mathematics, yet at the same time to include more spice and variety."
A more controversial, and plenty spicy, comment on the algebraic approach to mathematics as contrasted with the geometric approach to mathematics is Paul Halmos's article, "Applied Mathematics Is Bad Mathematics,"
http://books.google.com/books?id=rQ6FAAAAIAAJ&q=Halmos+Applied+Mathematics+Is+Bad+Mathematics&dq=Halmos+Applied+Mathematics+Is+Bad+Mathematics&ei=DKJaSZT8F5GoM8mguN8B&client=firefox-a&pgis=1 http://books.google.com/books?id=rQ6FAAAAIAAJ&q=Halmos+A...
(that's not a full-text view of the article)
which I disagree with, as maybe Halmos intended his provocative title to be disagreed with.
- wensing 18y agoMeta-comment: Could we please fix the quoted-text-not-wrapping 'problem' on this site? I hate having to scroll x,000 pixels to read a comment just because someone is using <pre> or whatever it is. FF3 on OS X.
- icey 18y agoIt's intentional; people just abuse it (myself included). Indented text is intended to display code, which should not be wrapped by the browser's width. It's up to the poster to format their text accordingly.
- tokenadult 18y agoYep, I just read the formatting help and fixed it. Different defaults on different forums lead to users being surprised. Sorry about that.
- Raphael 18y agoIn that case, we need overflow: auto;
- rms 18y agoI think it's there but doesn't work with FF3.
- jerf 18y agoDoesn't seem to be: http://ycombinator.com/news.css http://ycombinator.com/news.css Although if they're serving a custom .css file to my Firefox 3 that doesn't include that precisely because it doesn't work, I wouldn't know. wget got the same pre stuff in the last two lines, though.
- ks 18y agoYes. It would be nice if <blockquote> was supported.
- 18y ago