4 ms·
College Grades Have Become a Charade. It's Time to Abolish Them.
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://www.wsj.com/us-news/education/college-grades-have-become-acharade-its-time-to-abolish-them-ee4eb3fe?st=fiu5kajcz8b5za8&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink https://www.wsj.com/us-news/education/college-grades-have-be...
- HideousKojima 2y agoGiven that they used to be meaningful, I don't see how abolishing them is better than just figuring out how to make them work like they used to.
- caesil 2y agoWould be a very difficult transition for the first generation to live under the new normal where an A is now a C. Would employers accept that and consider it fairly when judging against their grade-inflated predecessors? I doubt it.
- HideousKojima 2y agoNone of my employers have ever cared about my college GPA, just the degree.
- thrill 2y agoMine have. I've not gotten selective jobs (that I really wanted) and they were blunt about that being the reason.
- MaxBarraclough 2y agoWas about to post the same point. As an example, a notation change of this kind was done recently for England's GCSE qualifications. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GCSE#Grades_and_tiering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GCSE#Grades_and_tiering
- viraptor 2y agoI've been through a change is grade range, others have too. Some countries moved from letters to numbers or to percentages to break with the previous system. It's not a difficult transition really - not compared to almost everything else happening at college level school. And if the employers actually care about the grades, they'll learn about the change too. (But that's a minority)
- knallfrosch 2y ago> Would be a very difficult transition for the first generation to live under the new normal where an A is now a C. In 2019 Germany, tens of thousands of pupils protested against what they thought were hard math tests on the "Abitur" – the last exam in school before university. Bad grades there would worsen their chances to secure a spot on a prestigious university or a desireable subject of study against pupils who got good grades from the old regime. (Or, if the next exam was easier, even against the next age cohort!)
- Kamq 2y ago> Given that they used to be meaningful That's the thing. They weren't for most professions. Even for the professions that do require abstract theoretical knowledge, it's debatable how much of the degree itself was actually meaningful vs it just being easier to use as a long weed-out process than a set of exams. They were mostly a status marker. Pre-WWII, colleges were almost entirely finishing schools for the rich and networking opportunities. And they also ran research because being a patron of the sciences has been high status for ~700 years. There's also an argument about universities being useful for society, as they create well-rounded citizens. That argument may have some validity, but it's unclear why that was put in as a prerequisite for having a generic corporate job. They were also excellent proxies for IQ, which employers aren't allowed to discriminate based on this side of the 70s. My guess is that companies dropping degree requirements means this correlation is breaking down. The only way to make the degrees meaningful in that sense again would be to stop granting degrees to low IQ people.
- Ekaros 2y ago>There's also an argument about universities being useful for society, as they create well-rounded citizens. That argument may have some validity, but it's unclear why that was put in as a prerequisite for having a generic corporate job. And really opens the question of why this should not be part of education every citizen gets? Surely what 10 to 12 years should be enough time to get everyone capable to this point. It is pretty sure that degrees simply were filters. At least outside some degrees where there was job specific knowledge that saved lot on training that could potentially fail. I actually wonder with AI and LLMs and such will we soon see every application contain some type of generated test that applicant will have to fill when sending job application. Just so they can filter people and possibly even ignore oversaturated degrees in process.
- mc32 2y agoIt’s ridiculous. A Florida teacher was apparently fired because she graded missing assignments with a zero. Apparently the lowest score, even for missing an assignment, not completing a test, etc is 50%. How can nothing equal half of something? It’s goddam nuts. Even elite institutions don’t calibrate the average score to a C grade. It all starts with idiotic participation trophies and gets worse.
- juanani1 2y agoiono, i got a 0 because i didnt go back and correct a 1 line answer out of 84, it was marked incomplete therefore a 0 out of 100. some teachers are just too far up their programming to give a damn. also woth the past cold war programming and the recent cold war programming, anyone trying to make it in the US college system has to deal with anti-intellectual programming. i didnt mind until some actual instructors had to show their feathers. imagine being a hs freshman and a teacher had automatic beef with you cus of your name. thats why the US is a failing state. you can throw all the fresh printed money at it, shits gna be shit plastered everywhere. the media can only do so much. gl
- DaSHacka 2y agoNo offense, based off your grammar in this comment something tells me you likely had other issues in your submission than just "missing one line" that netted you the zero. I also fail to see how teachers grading assignments unfairly makes the US a 'failed state'. This isn't a problem unique to the United States by a long shot.
- dangus 2y agoI actually think there’s a really good rationale for that. If F is a 50%, why is the lowest score a 0? What is the significance of all the numbers between 0 and 50% if all of those numbers mean the same thing? If I have 10 assignments and I don’t show up for 5 of them and got a perfect score on the other 5, in a system where my score is 0% for the 5 missed assignments I average out to getting the exact same final grade (F) as someone who didn’t show up for a single test. That doesn’t really make much sense, either. Put another way, every other letter grade has somewhere close to 10 points in the grade range but then F has 50 points in its grade range.
- doctorpangloss 2y agoThis isn’t at all what’s going on. Teaching assistants / teaching fellows are the ones issuing the grades for the most part, meaning other students. Okay, what is a Math grad student or senior trying to tell a freshman when he gets a B? “Don’t major in math.” It’s that simple. So you sort yourself into somewhere where you thrive. Is that bad? No. And compounded with a smaller compulsory curriculum and more options for majors / concentrations generally, students sort themselves better. This also explains why universities with compulsory 1st year premed like Caltech - which by the way lets students cheat, if they really want to - have worse grades. It’s not really about standards per se, but at the highest levels everyone has enough cognitive gifts, even the sons and daughters of rich and powerful CCP members, to be good at something. I don’t know. I feel like these opinion authors aren’t really paying attention to the very most basic mechanics and dynamics of what is going on. It’s always about “DEI” as the antagonist for them.
- TacticalCoder 2y agoThat's "Modern Educayshun", sunshine: https://youtu.be/iKcWu0tsiZM https://youtu.be/iKcWu0tsiZM
- digitaltrees 2y agoStudents perform better than in the past. One could argue that grades aren’t about comparing the peers in a class but individual performance. Put another way, if I am hiring a student for writing, physics or engineering I don’t necessarily care if they are better than their peers as much as I care if they can write well, solve the math or engineering problems to get the write answer. Finally, take law school as an example. LSAT scores, which are considered a reasonable proxy for IQ testing, are significantly hiring now for top schools than they were 30-40 years ago. That supports the thesis that law students today have a higher aptitude than previously so if grading is an objective measure of performance rather than a comparative measure of class rank it’s expected for average grades to increase.
- gjsman-1000 2y agoNo; there’s just been grade inflation combined with greater awareness on what will be on the tests. Objectively, our students are coming out of high school and college with the lowest preparedness for jobs than almost anytime prior, as ranked by employer surveys. Also, the LSAT is not static. It has changed over the years as instruction methods have also changed and as demographics have changed; so it is not a reliable measure of aptitude in any way.
- outop 2y agoHow do we know that employer attitudes and expectations have remained the same?
- gjsman-1000 2y agoConsidering 1 in 3 companies have reached the point where they are dropping the need for college altogether for most roles offered; despite the percentage of college graduates having never been higher, should be enough of a sign that college is slowly becoming a training charade. https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2024/03/22/1-in-3-companies-are-ditching-college-degree-requirements-for-salaried-jobs.html https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2024/03/22/1-in-3-companies-are-dit... Meanwhile, we’re also at the point where 52% of graduates are underemployed within a year of graduation, and 45% still are after a decade. Employers don’t care nearly as much anymore. Tell your children their odds of it working out are literally flip a coin, and it changes the conversation.
- hermannj314 2y agoA right-skew distribution allows you to differentiate high peforming students, and a left skew distribution (most people get an A allows you to differentiate poor performing students.
- orange_joe 2y agoTruthfully, colleges have a larger, higher quality pool of applicants. Moreover lots of tedious mechanical work within colleges has been automated (grammar, spelling, arithmetic), and research has become dramatically easier. It would stand to reason that grades would rise even if standards were kept the steady. Anecdotally, my father and I went to Ivy League schools. I saw his application and his school work. His writing was substantially worse than mine despite his focus on the humanities and mine in programming. I simply don’t believe that the increase in GPA has meaningfully eroded the quality or ambition of work.
- epolanski 2y ago> and research has become dramatically easier Scientific one? Absolutely not. Also, imho your view is very US centric where quality of education seems very low even in allegedly good colleges. I have been an exchange student at OSU (some other friends went to more ivy league for their ones) and we all found the exams just...insanely easy. I couldn't believe people would not pass exams, not only it was overwhelmingly multi choice exams, but professors would even grade you based on assignments and would post "example exams" days before the tests. I really lost a lot of respect for US universities based on my and my colleagues experience. I know and I hope some places have it tougher, but even people at MIT or UCLA told me similar stories. In Italy for comparison you needed to know from A to Z and would have to do exams again if you didn't know anything. Which is obvious!? How can you build bridges if you can barely scrap Calculus 1 or 2. Insane.
- freitzkriesler2 2y ago[dead]
- Unearned5161 2y agoYou sound easily impressionable... Please remember a few things whenever you talk about the quality of education in the United States (if you care to sound informed and thorough): - The United States is a very large country, with many states (50!) - Education quality is not federally organized (there are guidelines, but states make most of the rules) - Education quality depends on many factors, including but not limited to, the state, the county, the demographics of surrounding areas, the property value of surrounding areas, etc There is no need for rash and poorly informed takes on the quality of education when there is so much room to criticize on more legitimate grounds.
- aeternum 2y agoPerhaps it's time to rename colleges to social clubs since there is very little academic rigor now.
- throwaway918299 2y agoeither make grading more rigorous again or just stop wasting everyone’s time and abolish college completely - what a joke
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- scythe 2y ago>Now that the most common grade at most four-year colleges is an A, the stakes for each individual course are much higher. A single negative outlier takes on outsize weight. To get a stellar GPA, a student doesn’t have to be exceptionally good at any one thing; they have to manage risk in every course they take over four years. One possible way to mitigate this slightly is to calculate grading averages as a root-mean-square, similar to finding the length of a vector where each course represents a different "dimension". This will tend to deëmphasize the occasional poor performance. Its utility is limited when practically everyone gets an A at everything, but it does help the student with one bad semester mount a comeback. I have previously argued for root-mean-square grading within courses, but the same principle applies when used to calculate averages among multiple courses.
- freitzkriesler2 2y ago[dead]
- jmyeet 2y agoThis touches on a bunch of issues. And there are a bunch of competing intrests. And almost nobody is interested in actual education. 1. There is a significant interest in the US in destroying the public school system. The current iteration of this is "school choice", "school vouchers" or "charter schools". These schemes are all expensive ways to drain government coffers into private hands. This ball really got rolling when the Supreme Court decides that segregated schools couldn't get tax exempt status [1]. I'll just add that any supposed savings of charter schools are a lie. They're selective in students and don't have to deal with disabled children or children who otherwise need more attention. 2. Cutting public school funding to push "school choice" also serves the purpose of dismantling the government, the so-called "starving the beast" strategy of cutting funding and then using the resulting failures to justify further cuts; 3. The No Child Left Bhind Act under GW Bush is surprisingly not mentioned in this article but it greatly exacerbated this thin veneer of accountability. Fun fact: the NCLBA also provides the contact information of all graduating students to military recruiters; 4. The supposd meritocracy of grades (mentioned in the article) is a lie. Schools in wealtheri districts are better because they have more of a property tax base eg [2]. There's a reason people say explicit racial segregation was simply replaced by economic segregation. Addtionally, if you come from a more affluent background, you simply have more opportunities for extracurriculars, tutoring, SAT prep and so on. We have a useful example here. I've learned a little about how US medical education works and it's really interesting. To become a doctor you have to do a bunch of things that start with an undergraduate degree, do the MCATs, go to a 4 year medical school and then do a residency of some kind. Interspersed with this is the US Medical Licensing Exam ("USMLE") that takes place in several steps. USMLE has 3 Steps. Step 1 in 2nd year med school. Step 2 in 4th year and Step 3 typically in the intern (first) year of residency. Some years ago Step 1 went pass/fail instead of being actually graded. There were several arguments for this. A bad Step 1 score could be an issue with the residency match process and it's not necessarily indicative of how well you will do in residency or as a doctor. Anyway, what's the effect of this? It looks like the Step 1 score has been replaced by the prestige of your particular medical school. It's more social proof. The problem with this is the ranking of your medical school further exacerbates existing socioeconomic issues. It can be more expensive. Admission is harder and so your extracurriculars and, say, MCAT prep matters. In short, a well-intentioned effort to make something pass/fail has seemingly just baked in existing inequity. This is a difficult problem. [1]: https://scholarship.law.columbia.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3527&context=faculty_scholarship https://scholarship.law.columbia.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?art... [2]: https://www.tiktok.com/@carmeldeca/video/7197937009938156842?lang=en https://www.tiktok.com/@carmeldeca/video/7197937009938156842...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- knallfrosch 2y ago> “poisoned Oreo cookie.” Shit sandwich.
- johnea 2y agoThe Wall Street Journal has become a charade...
- Balgair 2y agoSo, UC Santa Cruz has gone be through an evolution on this. They used to be good little hippies and had no grades whatsoever. Then students got angry that grad schools and law schools wouldn't accept them because they didn't want to read 80 pages detailing the student. So they had both grades and evals for a while. They now just have grades. But, it sure was nice to get the evals too. Sure, most professors just put in your midterm grades and that was about it. And sure, most post secondary education isn't going to ever read past that first page that was GPA. But some professors did write an honest eval, and some med schools did read the 80 or so pages of evals. And it was rough, yeah, but really nice too. You're getting real feedback sometimes for the student and the admissions office. I really liked it and wished more professors would have bothered to, you know, give a shit about the students. And the admins offices that got the 80 page transcript and read it, well that made me want to actually go to those schools. Eval transcripts are hard, so I doubt they'll ever come back. But I really treasure mine
- aguaviva 2y agoA profile in courage, and way ahead of its time, that school. Back then, anyways.