3 ms·
Will humans ever become conscious?
- musicale 2y agoThe Chinese Room argument convinced me that John Searle is likely a non-intelligent imitation of a philosophy professor.
- tim333 2y agoHe's probably smart but I agree the argument is a bit duff.
- Kim_Bruning 2y agoIs there a good counter-paper to the chinese room experiment ? I'd think there might be one, but I'm not sure where to look.
- Rhapso 2y agoNo point in refuting the truth, but we can re-evaluate what we think it implies about the world or each other. it really boils down to how "special" we want to keep the voice in our head that tells itself a story about what the body has already done.
- Kim_Bruning 2y agoWhat do you think the truth is in this case?
- Rhapso 2y agoThe truth is that any internal state of finite complexity can be emulated by an equally complex or more complex system. Worse, the state we wish to evaluate "consciousness" is different than the probably lower complexity state of the system that we ARE testing for, which is the ability to converse. It isn't even about consciousness really, that's just a poorly defined state we can't observe directly and wish we could. I recommend asking "what CAN'T consciousness do" and be filtering for that instead. That way maybe we can show some things aren't conscious, which is the first hurdle we haven't jumped.
- musicale 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room https://philpapers.org/browse/the-chinese-room https://philpapers.org/browse/the-chinese-room
- musicale 2y agovia wikipedia: "If a program behaves as if it were multiplying, most of us would say that it is, in fact, multiplying. For all I know, Searle may only be behaving as if he were thinking deeply about these matters. But, even though I disagree with him, his simulation is pretty good, so I’m willing to credit him with real thought."[1] [1] A Short Rebuttal to Searle, https://ai.stanford.edu/%7Enilsson/OnlinePubs-Nils/General%20Essays/OtherEssays-Nils/searle.pdf https://ai.stanford.edu/%7Enilsson/OnlinePubs-Nils/General%2... I like this quite a bit, and I also wish that Prof. Nilsson were still with us to comment on current LLMs and other systems.
- Kim_Bruning 2y agoThat's awesome, and lead me to more. Thanks!
- rramadass 2y agoOne good framework to think about the problem of "Consciousness" in Humans vs. AI/AGI is the Samkhya School of Hindu Philosophy - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samkhya https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samkhya See my past comments here for some background - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40479388 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40479388 This is how i work it out; 1) "Consciousness" defined as attribute-less pure awareness/witness and immutable "Self" (aka Purusha in Samkhya) will never be possible in AI/AGI. 2) All other human mental states which are mutable and considered as evolutes of Prakriti in Samkhya are possible in AI/AGI. A simple mapping would be; 2.1) Buddhi in Samkhya ~ Metacognition - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metacognition https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metacognition 2.2) Manas in Samkhya ~ Phenomenology - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phenomenology_(psychology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phenomenology_(psychology) 2.3) Ahamkara in Samkhya ~ Emergent property from above due to "I Think therefore I am". Now realize that (1) is purely experiential/internal and only (2) is observable from an external pov and you get the idea why AI/AGI may seem "Conscious" (in the common usage of the word) to external observers.
- Rhapso 2y agoFrom an empirical view, 1 is an untestable internal state. It may as well not exist. Believe anything you need to, set policy based on things you can observe.
- rramadass 2y ago> 1 is an untestable internal state. Not quite; it is testable through experience by following any number of practices, prescribed in detail in various texts. There is also empirical evidence in the form of changes in physiological and mental parameters in somebody who has attained that state.
- Rhapso 2y agoAh so assuming this isn't nonsense, if you can't define a set of such parameters that generalize to a non-human it still isn't useful to test non-humans.
- tim333 2y ago>...worried that an insufficiently cultivated mind ... would be perfectly imitable and thus replaceable by computers and other machines I'm not sure cultivating our minds will buy much time there. But they will never be an exact replacement in the same way humans are not an exact replacement for cats and dogs in spite of being smarter.