3 ms·
Not to pick on this author in particular, but I wish I had an easy way to filter out everything said about startups by people who haven't personally done it suc
by gruseom 18y ago
Not to pick on this author in particular, but I wish I had an easy way to filter out everything said about startups by people who haven't personally done it successfully.
- fallentimes 18y agoAgreed. Though a blog post isn't as bad as writing a book about it [Guy Kawasaki] :).
- trapper 18y agoAutomated ad-hominem ftw. Of course only people who have [define success here] can say smart things about startups and business :)
- gruseom 18y agoIs it ad hominem if I don't want to take guitar lessons from someone who can't play guitar?
- trapper 18y agoPlaying guitar, just like business success are subjective. I consider 37signals, youtube and balsamiq successful and they contain few common elements (except making things people want). When listening to business advice I listen to those that have failed often; one of the best talks I have ever had was with a taxi driver who once owned an entire fleet of tourist buses but went under. Failure is often more useful to listen to than success.
- fallentimes 18y agoI agree, but listening to someone who has failed is different than listening to someone who has never even tried, which is what I think the OP was getting at.
- gruseom 18y agoI want to hear people talk of experiences they've actually had. In the case of someone who has failed, I'm interested in hearing their reflections on how and why they failed. That's not the same as them telling me how to succeed at the thing.
- trapper 18y agoI agree. I didn't get that from your original post
- graemep 18y agoNo, but if they listen to a lot of music you might value their opinions on who plays well, and even what the common characteristics of good players are.
- thomasmallen 18y agoI wouldn't mind a filter for awful typography either...Firebug to the rescue.
- mlinsey 18y agoThis doesn't strike me as a good idea at all. You're deliberately inducing an enormous selection bias in your knowledge. Or put another way, if a successful founder says "doing X is a good idea and made a big difference", but there were ten other unsuccessful founders who also tried doing X and had it backfire, isn't the experience of those ten other founders useful information? Taleb discusses this phenomena in "Fooled by Randomness" in the context of the financial industry, and it's a good recipe for bandwagoning and cargo-cult thinking. Now I agree that I would prefer to only hear advice about startups by people who have tried doing it at all.
- gruseom 18y agoAs Putin said to Sarkozy, you have a point there :)