3 ms·
> You can always prove the immaterial “I think therefore I am”. But due to the uncertainty of matter, nothing physical can be truly known. In other words you co
by TeMPOraL 2y ago
> You can always prove the immaterial “I think therefore I am”. But due to the uncertainty of matter, nothing physical can be truly known. In other words you could always be wrong in your perception.
Sure, you can prove that "I think therefore I am" for yourself. So how about we just accept it's true and put it behind us and continue to the more interesting stuff?
What you or I call external world, or our perception of it, has some kind of structure. There are patterns to it, and each of us seem to have some control over details of our respective perceptions. Long story short, so far it seems that materialism is the simplest framework you can use to accurately predict and control those perceptions. You and I both seem to be getting most mileage out of assuming that we're similar entities inhabiting and perceiving a shared universe that's external to us, and that that universe follows some universal patterns.
That's not materialism[0] yet, especially not in the sense relevant to AI/AGI. To get there, one has to learn about the existence of fields of study like medicine, or neuroscience, and some of the practical results they yielded. Things like, you poke someone's brain with a stick, watch what happens, and talk to the person afterwards. We've done that enough times to be fairly confident that a) brain is the substrate in which mind exists, and b) mind is a computational phenomenon.
I mean, you could maybe question materialism 100 years ago, back when people had the basics of science down but not much data to go on. It's weird to do in time and age when you can literally circuit-bend a brain like you'd do with an electronic toy, and get the same kind of result from the process.
--
[0] - Or physicalism or whatever you call the "materialism, but updated to current state of physics textbooks" philosophy.