5 ms·
Time to Say Goodbye to the BMI?
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/i7aSK https://archive.ph/i7aSK
- yawpitch 2y agoAbout two hundred years past time.
- bell-cot 2y agoWow - I thought "two hundred years" was figurative. But: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_mass_index#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_mass_index#History And Wikipedia version of things is pretty damn damning: > History > Obesity and BMI > Adolphe Quetelet, a Belgian astronomer, mathematician, statistician, and sociologist, devised the basis of the BMI between 1830 and 1850 as he developed what he called "social physics".[3] Quetelet himself never intended for the index, then called the Quetelet Index, to be used as a means of medical assessment. Instead, it was a component of his study of l'homme moyen, or the average man. Quetelet thought of the average man as a social ideal, and developed the body mass index as a means of discovering the socially ideal human person.[4] According to Lars Grue and Arvid Heiberg in the Scandinavian Journal of Disability Research, Quetelet's idealization of the average man would be elaborated upon by Francis Galton a decade later in the development of Eugenics.[5] > The modern term "body mass index" (BMI) for the ratio of human body weight to squared height was coined in a paper published in the July 1972 edition of the Journal of Chronic Diseases by Ancel Keys and others. In this paper, Keys argued that what he termed the BMI was "if not fully satisfactory, at least as good as any other relative weight index as an indicator of relative obesity".[6][7][8] > The interest in an index that measures body fat came with observed increasing obesity in prosperous Western societies. Keys explicitly judged BMI as appropriate for population studies and inappropriate for individual evaluation. Nevertheless, due to its simplicity, it has come to be widely used for preliminary diagnoses.[9] Additional metrics, such as waist circumference, can be more useful.[10]
- yawpitch 2y agoOh how I wish it was figurative. Well done for reading up on the ridiculous history of one of the most ridiculous measures. Now try to not go down the rabbit hole of the calorie.
- chiefalchemist 2y agoBMI might not be 100% ideal 100% of the time. Understandable. But as a quick bavk of the envelope guide, it's worth a look. That aside, BMI is not the problem. The problem is we need it in the first place. Replace BMI and we still too many people on unhealthy diets living unhealthy lifestyles. We can point fingers at the metrics (BMI, calories,etc) but life in The West will remain the same. Deadly. Premature death deadly.
- yawpitch 2y agoFor any given individual BMI is useless; it was only ever intended for use in population-level studies, and should only ever be used in that fashion, precisely because it’s simply too back of the envelope. For example consider two people of exactly the same height with exactly the same current health and precisely the same girth, adipose load, etc, but the one with two legs has an overweight BMI and the one with one leg has an underweight BMI. Now you might think the higher BMI one still has a useful metric, but now let’s assume they’ve both got no extra adipose load but extremely well developed skeletal muscle systems; now it’s the one with the low BMI who has a useful metric, only not because of body mass but because of pushing that much blood through a smaller and more compromised circulatory system. BMI is, and always has been, effectively useless as anything but a cudgel when used against individual patients.
- chiefalchemist 2y agoLook around, most people need an envelope, back, front or otherwise. It's not meant to be a cure and/or a be all and end all. It's simply, if you're this... you might have a problem. See a doctor. But instead of seeing a doctor most people are super-sizing their meal + soda. That's not BMI's fault.
- yawpitch 2y agoNo, that is McDonald’s fault, but knowing their BMI doesn’t actually help them in any way. BMI is, again, useless as a reliable measure of anything below population scales, hence why the article discusses an alternative that isn’t actually utterly useless.
- mharig 2y ago[dead]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]