5 ms·
This is happening across the board, not just to IT workers, and I suspect it's the major factor as for why the expected productivity improvements from technolog
by TeMPOraL 2y ago
This is happening across the board, not just to IT workers, and I suspect it's the major factor as for why the expected productivity improvements from technology didn't materialize.
Think of your "DevSecOps" people doing 3x the work they should. Do you know what else are they doing? Booking their own business travels. Reconciling and reporting their own expenses. Reporting their own hours, broken down by business categories. Managing their own vacation days. Managing their own meetings. Creating presentations on their own, with graphics they made on their own. Possibly even doing 80% of work on lining up purchases from third parties. And a bunch of other stuff like that.
None of these are part of their job descriptions - in fact, all of these are actively distracting and disproportionally compromise the workers' ability to do their actual jobs. All of these also used to have dedicated specialists, that could do it 10x as efficiently, for fraction of the price.
My hypothesis is this: those specialists like secretaries, internal graphics departments, financial staff, etc. they all were visible on the balance sheet. Eliminating those roles does not eliminate the need for their work to be done - just distributes it to everyone in pieces (in big part thanks to self-serve office software "improving" productivity). That slows everyone down across the board disproportionally, but the beancounters only see the money saved on salaries of the eliminated roles - the slowdown only manifests as a fuzzy, generic sense of loss of productivity, a mysterious costs disease that everyone seems to suffer from.
I say it's not mysterious; I say that there is no productivity gain, but rather productivity loss - but because it turns the costs from legible, overt, into diffuse and hard to count, it's easy to get fooled that money is being saved.
- sgt101 2y agoAnd yet we are told that competition will determine that capital and talent will flow towards that most efficient organisations over time. Thus, surely organisations that eschewed this practice would emerge and dominate? So, either capitalism doesn't work, or your thesis isn't quite right... I have two other counters to offer, first we have seen GDP per capita gradually increasing in major economies for the last 50 years (while the IT revolution has played out). There have been other technical innovations over this time, but I believe that GDP per capita has more than quadrupled in G8 economies. The USA and Canada have, at the same time, enjoyed a clear extra boost from fracking and shale extraction, and the USA has arguably enjoyed an extra extra boost from world dominance - but arguably. The second one is simple anecdote. Hour for hour I now can do far more in terms of development than I did when I was a hard core techie in the 90's and 2000's. In addition I can manage and administer systems that are far more complex than those it took teams of people to run at that time (try running a 10gb size db under load on oracle 7 sitting on top of spinning rust and 64mb ram store for fun) I can also manage a team of 30's expenses, timesheets, travel requests and so on that again would have taken a person to do. I can just do these things and my job as well and I do it mostly in about 50 hrs a week. If I wasn't involved in my people's lives and happy to argue with customers to get things better I could do it in 40 hrs regularally, for sure. But I put some discretion in. My point is - we are just more productive. It is hard to measure, and anecdote / "lived experience" is a bad type of evidence, but I think it's clearly there. This is why then accountants have been able to reorganise modern business organisations to use fewer people to do more. Have they destroyed value while doing this - totally - but they have managed to get away with it because 7/10 they have been right. Personally I've suffered from the 3/10 errors. I know many of us on here have, but we shouldn't shut our eyes because of that.
- Retric 2y ago> And yet we are told that competition will determine that capital and talent will flow towards that most efficient organisations over time. Thus, surely organisations that eschewed this practice would emerge and dominate? That’s really not how competition works in practice. Verizon and AT&T are a mess internally but their competitors where worse. GDP per capita has a lot more to do with automation than individual worker productivity. Software ate the world, but it didn’t need to be great software to be better than no software. At large banks you often find thousands of largely redundant systems from past mergers all chugging along at the same time. Meanwhile economies of scale still favor the larger bank because smaller banks have more systems per customer. So sure you’re working with more complex systems, but how much of that complexity is actually inherently beneficial and how much is legacy of suboptimal solutions? HTML and JavaScript are unbelievably terrible in just about every way except ubiquity thus tools / familiarity. When we talk about how efficient things are, it’s not on some absolute scale it’s all about the tools built to cope with what’s going on. AI may legitimately be the only way programmers in 2070 deal with ever more layers of crap.
- Viliam1234 2y agoAs long as you have the economies of scale and huge barriers to entry, companies can stay deeply dysfunctional without getting outcompeted. Especially when the same managers rotate between them all and introduce the "best practices" everywhere.
- ang_cire 2y ago> So, either capitalism doesn't work Yes, it's definitely this.
- Viliam1234 2y ago> Think of your "DevSecOps" people doing 3x the work they should. Do you know what else are they doing? Booking their own business travels. Reconciling and reporting their own expenses. Reporting their own hours, broken down by business categories. Managing their own vacation days. Managing their own meetings. Creating presentations on their own, with graphics they made on their own. Possibly even doing 80% of work on lining up purchases from third parties. And a bunch of other stuff like that. It feels like you are working at the same company as me. Companies complain all the time about how difficult it is to find competent developers, which is their excuse for keeping most of the teams understaffed. Okay, then how about increasing the developers' productivity by letting them focus on, you know, development? Why does the paperwork I need to do after visiting a dentist during the lunch break take more time than the visit itself? It's not enough just to bring the receipt to HR; I need to scan the paper, print the scan, get it signed by a manager, start a new process in a web application, ask the manager to also sign it in the web application, etc. I need to check my notes every time I am doing it, because the web application asks me a lot of information that in theory it should already know, and the attached scan needs to have a properly formatted file name, and I need to figure out the name of the person I should forward this process to, rather than the application figuring it out itself. Why??? The business travels were even worse, luckily my current company doesn't do those frequently. My work is defined by Jira tickets that mostly contain a short description like "implement XY for Z", and it's my job to figure out wtf is "Z", who is the person in our company responsible for "Z", what exactly they meant by "XY", where is any specification, when is the deadline, who am I supposed to coordinate with, and who will test my work. I miss the good old days when we had some kind of task description and the definition of done, but those were the days when we had multiple developers in a team, and now it's mostly just me. I get invitations to meetings that do not concern me or any of my projects, but it's my job to figure that out, not the job of the person who sent the invitations. Don't get me started on e-mails, because my inbox only became manageable after I wrote dozen rules that put various junk in the spam folder. No, I don't need a notification every time someone in the company made an edit on any Confluence page. No, I don't need notifications about people committing code to projects I am not working on. The remaining notifications often come in triplicate, because first I get a message in Teams, then an e-mail saying that I got a message in Teams, and finally a Windows notification saying that I got a new e-mail. When I return from a vacation, I spend my first day or two just sorting out the flood in my e-mails. On some days, it is lunchtime before I had an opportunity to write my first line of code. So it's the combination of being Agile-Full-Stack-Dev-Sec-Ops-Cloud-Whatever and the fact that everything around me seems designed to make my work harder that is killing me. This is a system that slows down 10x developers to 1x developers, and us lesser mortals to mere 0.1x developers.
- weweweoo 2y agoI agree with the hypothesis. My country has a significant shortage of doctors, and guess what the few doctors spend a large amount of their day on? Paperwork that used to be done by secretaries, whose salary would be maybe 1/3 or the doctor's. It's a massive waste of both money and doctor's potential, but somehow that's what the free market prefers.