3 ms·
B(i)ased as fuck. I think this post from the other day adds some important context[0]. In that study kids with access to GPT did way more practice problems but
by godelski 2y ago
B(i)ased as fuck.
I think this post from the other day adds some important context[0]. In that study kids with access to GPT did way more practice problems but worse on the test. But the most important part was that they found that while GPT usually got the final answer right that the logic was wrong, meaning that the answer is wrong. This is true for math and code.
There's the joke: there's two types of 10x devs, those that do 10x work and those who finish 10x jira tickets. The problem with this study is the assumptions that it makes, which is quite common and naive in our industry. They assume that PRs and commits are measures of productivity and they assume passing review is a good quality metric. These are so variable between teams. Plenty are just "lgtm" reviews.
The issue here is that there's no real solid metric for things like good code. Meeting the goals of a ticket doesn't mean you haven't solved the problem so poorly you are the reason 10 new tickets will be created. This is the real issue here and the only real way to measure it is using Justice Potter's test (I know it when I see it), and requires an expert evaluator. In other words, tech debt. Which is something we're seeing a growing rise in, all the fucking enshitification.
So I don't think that study here contradicts [0], in fact I think they're aligned. But I suspect people who are poor programmers (or non programmers) will use this at evidence for what they want to see. Believing naive things like lines of code, number of commits/PRs, etc are measures of productivity rather than hints of measure. I'm all for "move fast and break things" as long as there's time set aside to clean up the fucking mess you left behind. But there never is. It's like we have businesses ADHD. There's so much lost productivity because so much focus is placed on short term measurements and thinking. I know medium and long term thinking are hard, but humans do hard shit every day. We can do a lot better than a shoddy study like this.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41453300 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41453300