5 ms·
Parkinson's may begin in the gut, study says, adding to growing evidence
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://wapo.st/3XxWvVt https://wapo.st/3XxWvVt
- CrzyLngPwd 2y agohttps://archive.is/YOGAn https://archive.is/YOGAn
- mobilejdral 2y agoActual paper: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39235810/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39235810/ > Conclusions and relevance: In this cohort study, a history of upper gastrointestinal MD was associated with elevated risk of developing a clinical PD diagnosis. Increased vigilance among patients with MD for future PD risk may be warranted. Associated is the key word. The washington post sensationalizes it to "may begin in the gut"
- throwaway920102 2y ago> MD mucosal damage
- m463 2y agoI was curious so I searched. I wonder if other conditions set up parkinsons? (Also disorders might != damage) Causes and Diagnoses of Mucosal Disorders The causes of mucosal disorders are generally bacteria, viruses or fungi, such as yeast. A weakened immune system, stress or dietary deficiencies can make you more prone to a mucosal disorder. Mucosal disorders can develop in a variety of ways: - Candidiasis is often caused by humid conditions, damaged skin or a depressed immune system. - Canker sores are the result of a condition called aphthous stomatitis, and brought on by a weakened immune system, food allergies, viruses, bacteria and poor nutrition. - Herpes is spread through skin-to-skin contact such as kissing and sexual intercourse. It can also be passed via a glass or lip balm of someone who has the herpes simplex virus. It can be contagious even when no lesions are present. https://www.nm.org/conditions-and-care-areas/dermatology/mucosal-disorders/causes-and-diagnoses https://www.nm.org/conditions-and-care-areas/dermatology/muc...
- Mistletoe 2y agoThe paper is about the gut-first hypothesis of Parkinson disease (PD), I don’t think the Washington Post sensationalized it that much. And the p-values they find are pretty amazing. P<.001 and still P=.01 after covariate adjustment.
- cpncrunch 2y agoIt doesnt show direction of causality. Dopamine is also an important gut neurotransmitter.
- yieldcrv 2y agoand neither will the proposed treatments, and neither will the clinical trials, and neither will the approved drugs
- cpncrunch 2y agoMy point is that its plausible there is no direction. It could be dopamine causing both effects.
- FollowingTheDao 2y agoI agree. They know dopamine makes things worse for PD pateints. My Theory: The reason that Dopamine fails is because they do not have low dopamine, but low energy for the dopamine receptor. The dopamine receptors are G Coupled Protein receptors that need GTP to function. So if you are low in the purine GTP then it does not matter how much dopamine you make. Giving these patients dopamine works, but then fails, because it depletes the cells of GTP.
- jxntb73 2y agospeculative.
- FollowingTheDao 2y agoMy work is not based on conjecture, it’s based on knowledge. So it’s not speculative, it’s a hypothesis. This is how science works.
- ninetyninenine 2y agoThat is not a sensationalization. association indicates possibility of causation. The washington post used the right wording here. While association does not imply causation, you very much need an association in order to establish causation. You actually need establish two associations in order to verify causation, so the existence of one type of association is already an indicator for "may begin in the gut".
- quonn 2y agoYou can‘t verify causation with two associations either.
- ninetyninenine 2y agoTechnically causation can never be verified. But practically you need to associate cause and effect and lack of cause and lack of effect. That is two associations, and in one association the experimenter himself must deliberately influence the experiment. This verifies cause from a practical perspective. From a technical perspective causation was not verified. Because technically you need to verify both effect and lack of effect from one population on the same event and the only way to do that is time travel. We influenced the experiment by creating the causation but by doing that we can no longer know what would’ve happened if we didn’t create the causative precursor and thus we can never truly know if the event actually caused the effect.
- tim333 2y agoTechnically sometimes causation can be verified. Say you break your arm in a car crash - it's pretty clear what caused what. I'll give you that with things like gut problems and Parkinson's it's tricker.
- OutOfHere 2y ago> it's pretty clear what caused what. It really isn't. Maybe your arm was osteoporotic or weak from a prior incident, and it broke due to a trivial pressure injury when the ambulance workers were loading you into the ambulance. The point is that it's pretty clear only when it can be mathematically proven, and at all other times it's based on some idea of probability. In the case of this article, a causal association seems quite probable to me.
- baxtr 2y agoI mean it could be either of these three: (1) MD induces PD (2) PD induces MD (3) some other underlying condition causes both MD and PD
- arcticbull 2y agoOr (4) two unrelated things that just so happen to be coincident. https://www.tylervigen.com/spurious-correlations https://www.tylervigen.com/spurious-correlations
- apwell23 2y ago> Constipation, dysphagia, older age, and higher Charlson-Deyo Comorbidity Index were also associated with higher PD risk.
- m463 2y agodoesn't parkinsons cause dysphagia? (difficulty swallowing?)
- ThaDood 2y agoIt can in advanced caseas - from my personal experience: My gran had it for as long as I could remember. As she got older and her condition worsened she would have difficulty swallowing just about anything and we had to add thickening agents (even to her water) so she could. This also might have been a side affect of her medication but I don't recall it happening earlier on the same meds. Take this for what it's worth. Happy to be wrong, I know someone on HN will tell me lol
- ngcazz 2y agoChecks out for my old man, but then again his disease's progression has been so wildly aggressive - at 64 his stage of the disease is more akin to what I'd always imagined for an 84-year-old - I suspect it's not even PD
- apwell23 2y agoI have it in my 30s due to LPR :/. Its my life's mission atm to resolve my LPR.
- canadiantim 2y agoThey do call the gut the second brain. I know candida in the gut has been implicated in causing symptoms like alzheimers/dementia via breaking down blood brain barrier, even leads to accumulation of plaques like in alzheimers, e.g.: https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/how-a-candida-infection-could-trigger-mechanisms-tied-to-alzheimers https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/how-a-candida-infe... Another vector that I've encountered through personal experience with family members is mold toxins, which transit through the gut and basically keep getting recycled through the gut, so while diseases may begin in the gut, that could also just be pointing to some sort of toxic load that transits through the gut too, e.g. Ochratoxin A if it's mold exposure, etc.
- esafak 2y agoIf so, what are you supposed to do about it?
- lm28469 2y agoEat real food instead of the slop "food" megacorps are trying to sell you
- dazzawazza 2y agoTo be honest even if there is no link that's not a bad rule to follow.
- pragma_x 2y agoFor me, I have a "nothing in a box or a bag" rule. Or more succinctly: "shop sparingly from the grocery store center." The idea is to avoid processed foods as much as possible and stick to staples, which are usually more nutritive for the dollar. Yes, rice and potatoes also come in bags, but you get the gist.
- MrOwen 2y agoIt's unfortunate so many people "fight" or argue the importance of this. Anyone, and I mean anyone, who's taken a week to eat clean, locally sourced, minimally processed food will notice a marked difference in behavior, energy level, and whole host of other benefits. It's unfortunate that access to this type of food is often limited, however, and cost or time prevents many from taking advantage of this kind of diet. Food is such an amazing aspect to human life and I thoroughly enjoy taking full advantage of what good food can provide for my body.
- pragma_x 2y agoExactly. What really gets me down is that our shopping options are often steered towards processed foods. Take a basic cost-benefit analysis of processed foods, for example. These are an obscenely good value in terms of calories per dollar. The alternative, raw foods, take time and energy (heat/fuel) to cook before you can eat them. This puts highly processed and nutritionally poor food on the table a lot of the time if you're lacking in time, money, or both; it's the only option that makes sense in that situation. Granted, we're discounting future costs of health from a diet like this, but that's not an immediate concern when you're hungry.
- photochemsyn 2y agoParkinson's probably has several causes, including genetic factors, but the clearest link is to exposure to environmental neurotoxins, especially organophosphate pesticides. Studies on the incidence of Parkinson's in agricultural areas where organophosphates, e.g. paraquat, maneb, were heavily used had a significantly higher risk of developing PD. The study showed a strong correlation between long-term pesticide exposure and PD onset. See: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-38215-z https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-023-38215-z
- alphazard 2y agoSomething I don't hear talked about enough is the fraction of the immune system that lives in the gut. It's something like 75% depending on what kinds of cells you include. It seems obvious that immune related problems in the periphery would be caused by what the majority of the immune system is dealing with (which is in the gut). Immune cells have state, if they get all fired up in one place and then move somewhere else they can coordinate an inflammatory response elsewhere too. They also send chemical messages called cytokines which can circulate much more quickly and broadly, so that's another mechanism for gut inflammation to transfer to the periphery. That's just the immune cells themselves. There's also chemicals like endotoxin that can leak through the gut barrier into circulation, the immune system creates an inflammatory response to that too, where ever it ends up. This has been called "leaky gut" and was dismissed by the medical community, despite circulating endotoxin and its origin being well understood by researchers.
- badlibrarian 2y agoSomewhere deep inside the bowels of this site there's a text file that makes things gently disappear. And I can't wait for "gut flora" to become a key value pair there.
- bongodongobob 2y agoFor real. I don't get the obsession.
- tiahura 2y ago[flagged]
- FollowingTheDao 2y agoI study purines and I think Parkison's and gut disorders arise with each other and neither is the root cause. Understanding how purines (like GTP) effect neurology will lead to a more universal understanding on several neurological disorders. Low GTP leads to Parkinson's in those with other genetic risks, primarily in the Dopamine receptors. Basically Parkinson's is a low GTP disorder. (Just FYI, I have a purine disorder called Partial PNP Deficiency.) https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0378111923005905 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03781... https://academic.oup.com/hmg/article/26/14/2747/3768438 https://academic.oup.com/hmg/article/26/14/2747/3768438 https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/bi061960m https://pubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021/bi061960m
- thenerdhead 2y agoMajority of the immune system is in the gut. It is also one of the main culprits that Long COVID researchers are finding RNA in causing immune dysfunction. > High uptake in the gut was observed in people with persistent post-COVID-19 symptoms, as was single and double-stranded SARS-CoV-2 RNA in gut lamina propria, as measured directly by ISH in a subset of participants With modern day technology, we are now able to scan the whole body before and after a treatment. This can be applied to many diseases like Parkinson's, but largely being used in Long COVID trials today: > The ability to quantify pathogen and immune responses across the whole body before and after a therapeutic intervention could provide unparalleled information on infections that primarily persist in specific tissues outside the systemic circulation Finally, we really are entering a renaissance of being able to see our immune system in action for the first time. This will hopefully bring a cure to many diseases that are now thought to be driven by immune dysfunction / viral persistence / autoimmunity / etc. > Nonetheless, we are just entering a renaissance of specific noninvasive nuclear imaging developments to determine immune responses to pathogens and malignancies. For these to be realized, significant resources must be provided to develop, implement and improve these emerging noninvasive technologies and facilitate their implementation into clinical trial infrastructure. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41590-024-01948-0 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41590-024-01948-0 (may be paywalled, but is a great article) Beyond the nuclear imaging technologies, new tools like single-cell RNA sequencing, CRISPR screens, 5′-VDJ repertoire analysis, spatial transcriptomics, dual RNA sequencing and metagenomic sequencing, etc will help in unraveling the complexities of these complex diseases. Bonus: Here's a video of a friend who did this experimental imaging for Long COVID: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QPwXRZFhGOM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QPwXRZFhGOM Hippocrates said all disease begins in it, so maybe we should've listened.
- AStonesThrow 2y ago[flagged]
- drak0n1c 2y agoMy grandfather developed both Parkinson's and Diabetes in the last ~10 years of his life. He walked regularly as a lifelong NYC resident and was not overweight. The same upper gastrointestinal mucosal damage described in this study is associated with Diabetes. https://www.xiahepublishing.com/2472-0712/ERHM-2019-00014 https://www.xiahepublishing.com/2472-0712/ERHM-2019-00014 https://www.gastrojournal.org/article/S0016-5085(97)00124-8/fulltext https://www.gastrojournal.org/article/S0016-5085(97)00124-8/... https://cureparkinsons.org.uk/parkinsons-and-diabetes/ https://cureparkinsons.org.uk/parkinsons-and-diabetes/
- DrBazza 2y agoI wonder whether this is a side effect of degreaser, that is recognised as a cause of Parkinsons. The degreaser somehow affects the gut. That then causes Parkinsons. [*] https://www.healthline.com/health-news/parkinsons-disease-may-be-caused-by-common-dry-cleaning-chemical https://www.healthline.com/health-news/parkinsons-disease-ma...
- hinkley 2y agoThere’s a surfactant in Roundup that’s nastier than glyphosate and may be causing a lot of problems. There a few cranks out there that have been insisting for decades that organophosphates are part of a trigger that causes Parkinson’s. I’ve always suspected they may be vindicated in the end.
- zingababba 2y agoFunny because caffeine gives me pretty bad constipation and that is always touted as a preventative, f*ck caffeine.
- arcticbull 2y agoThere's actually really strong evidence that coffee is associated with lower risk of cardiovascular disease. There's a dose-response relationship with optimal cardiovascular health at 3-5 cups per day. This is a meta-analysis that covered 1.29 million people over decades and found a statistically significant non-linear dose-response relationship. [1] This is about as good as nutrition studies get. [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24201300/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24201300/
- senectus1 2y agocoffee != Caffeine I cant drink coffee anymore which makes me very sad, i really like it. I causes constipation for a few days then i get unplugged in a disguting way.. it stinks and its messy. caffeine however.. no issue. I can drink tea no issues, I can dring / consume guarana or nodoze "keep awake" tablets no issues... for some reason after decades of drinking coffe with no ill effects I can no longer drink it specifically (decaf or not)
- coding123 2y agoCombine coffee with Jack's Spicy Chicken and I have the opposite for 4 days. Hope that helps.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- coding123 2y agoH Pylori, Strep, etc.. We assume that because we've named and noted the existence of these, that the limits of their bodily harm is a stomach ache, ulcers, bloating, etc...
- mkapoor26 2y agoThe question is not where it begins, I have a friend who's father is diagnosed with Parkinson, can't really walk properly or talk and it's sad to see. But what's the cure? and where's the cure. I remember that it's been questioned for so long like 5 years ago I heard that Parkinson might be a disease that begins from gut....yet we are still figuring out how it begins and not how it cures. Is it not better to solve issues like these than AGI?
- timbit42 2y agoIf we can prevent it, it won't be as important to be able to cure it.
- AbstractH24 2y agoWhats the prevention strategy? As someone in their mid-30s with neurological and psychiatric conditions who also experiences regular constipation, I read this and felt, "ok, now what?"
- timbit42 2y agoWell, knowing something in the gut is causing it means they are one step closer to finding the cause. Eliminating the cause can prevent it, even if it doesn't aid in curing existing cases.
- Anitalawson 2y ago[flagged]