3 ms·
I had a very frustrating relationship with a manager once, where it seemed every conversation went like this: Manager: [Situation] is happening. What is your p
by ryandrake 2y ago
I had a very frustrating relationship with a manager once, where it seemed every conversation went like this:
Manager: [Situation] is happening. What is your plan for dealing with it?
Me: I'm thinking I should do A, B, and C, for reasons X and Y.
Manager: No, that's not right. I think you should do D.
Me: OK, I will do D.
Annoyed looking Manager: Don't do D just because I told you to. I want you to understand why you should do D so next time this happens, you can reason yourself into D without me suggesting it.
Me: <shrugging> OK, help me to understand why we're doing D.
Manager: No, that's not what I want. I need you to get to the reason by yourself!
Me: OK, I don't know what you want me to do at this point. Should I leave this 1:1 and do D or not?
I wish I could read [Manager's] mind. We could just never get past this merry-go-round, and I eventually just left the job. I think this was [Manager's] attempt at career development for me but we just couldn't see eye to eye on any decision I made.
- airstrike 2y agoThat... sounds like a terrible manager.
- saghm 2y ago> Manager: No, that's not what I want. I need you to get to the reason by yourself! Honestly, this just sounds like a manager who isn't very good at their job. A good manager doesn't just blindly send you off to learn skills they think are necessary; they either teach you themselves (if they have the necessary expertise and spare time) or help you find resources where you can learn what you need (mentorship, suggested reading, etc.). If you describe to someone where where they need to end up without giving directions, it shouldn't be surprising if they get lost!
- hinkley 2y agoManager watched too many kung fu movies. And the wrong ones at that.
- crazygringo 2y ago> I think this was [Manager's] attempt at career development for me Just from what you've told, it doesn't sound like it was. Sadly, some people just have to prove that they're smarter. Whatever you suggest, they will insist that the correct answer is something else. They won't give you a reason for that supposed correct answer because there isn't one. It's an ego thing. "I need you to get to the reason by yourself!" is not something any competent manager is going to say. That's not how learning works. I'm glad you were able to leave. That sounds horrible.
- makeitdouble 2y ago> Manager: No, that's not right. I think you should do D. Manager or not, coming up with a solution without explaining why the other solutions don't cut it, and why it better solves the problem is plain toxic.
- hinkley 2y agoseems this situation was missing some questions, but not yours - his. Asking questions that show why the other solutions don’t work - carving out the problem space until all that’s left is the solution D. The alternative is to describe all the motivations for D. Which it’s clear your manager wasn’t capable of doing.