3 ms·
What is the value of national security and resilience in manufacturing, a supply chain, and a trained, experienced workforce? Have we learned nothing from China
by toomuchtodo 2y ago
What is the value of national security and resilience in manufacturing, a supply chain, and a trained, experienced workforce? Have we learned nothing from China and their approach?
Financial efficiency leads to system fragility. Fragile systems for discretionary systems, durable, more expensive systems for critical systems. It's operational readiness, and that requirement (guaranteed startup and throughput) has a cost. And if you are outsourcing across nation state borders, you limit control over outcomes and destiny.
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> Have we learned nothing from China and their approach? China combines protectionism with cheap labour and moderate productivity. (Korea and Japan, expensive labour with very high productivity.) We can’t change our labour costs. But without productivity enhancement, that requires either massive subsidies or a moribund industry. The unions block those productivity enhancements since they could lead to lay-offs in the short term; we see the same problem at our docks.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoI agree, but also without unions, we see the dystopian hellscape the US labor market is. So, while productivity enhancement is a necessary, desired component of a solution, unions are non negotiable. We are past the point "unions bad," no one is eating that shit sandwich anymore [1] [2]. 88% of people under 30 view unions favorably—a record-breaking level of support from young workers, for example. [1] https://www.marketplace.org/2023/01/03/gen-z-is-the-most-pro-union-generation/ https://www.marketplace.org/2023/01/03/gen-z-is-the-most-pro... [2] https://news.gallup.com/poll/510281/unions-strengthening.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/510281/unions-strengthening.asp...
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> unions are non negotiable Then we need to lower protectionism (i.e. force the unionised shipyards to compete), massively ramp up subsidies or concede we’ll be reliant on foreign shipyards in a war of attrition. Given the first and second are politically unrealistic inasmuch as they require long-term commitments, to not roll back into protectionism or cut subsidies in a budget crunch, we’re left with the third.
- toomuchtodo 2y ago> massively subsidise this set of workers I absolutely agree. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41234312 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41234312 https://www.wpr.org/economy/investigation-into-chinas-unfair-trade-practices-supports-wisconsin-shipbuilding https://www.wpr.org/economy/investigation-into-chinas-unfair...
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoMassive subsidies historically only worked in a war footing. Also, because subsidies only won’t produce commercially-competitive vessels, your only natural customer will be the DoD. The only way to sell this is by launching forever wars. We need to subsidise our production. But unless we want to return to our 2000s, we must marry that to loosened protectionism to force American shipyards to compete internationally.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoA model that achieves a desired outcome, but is suboptimal, is superior to a proposed optimal model that cannot or will not be implemented. The latter are simply thought experiments or dreams. > The only way to sell this is by launching forever wars. There will always be a need for a standing inventory of military hardware, so long as there are potential nation state adversaries. (n=1, imho, ymmv)
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> model that achieves a desired outcome, but is suboptimal, is superior to a proposed optimal model that cannot or will not be implemented I’m arguing the impossible model is the one that relies on American voters writing a blank cheque to sustain above-average lifestyles among a minority of workers doing their jobs in a demonstrably-inefficient way for the purpose of remaining employed (and cashing in those cheques). It works if we can sell it as blowing up stuff abroad. But not in peacetime. (And as a result, that production does nothing downstream, e.g. in offshore wind farm installation or domestic seaborne shipping, where, as the article notes, our high costs and the Jones Act make many projects uneconomical.) > will always be a need for a standing inventory of military hardware You’re underestimating how far behind we are. What will we do with two orders of magnitude more ships standing around every year [1]? Just keeping that many ships maintained and stored would be a challenge. Do you really think the public would support a shipyard-to-scrapyard programme for more than a few years without war? Strong unions and massive protectionism, in the long term, means we’ll from time to time ramp up subsidies, do a war, and then ramp them down thereby laying everyone off. As the article points out, that’s our strategy. We’ve been doing it for 100 years. It sort of works, even if there is a better way, because we refuse to compromise on either unions or protectionism, leaving subsidies as the only lever that can do any work.