24 ms·
Given that ICEs are produced in the millions and are quite reliable with very low maintenance requirements, I'd say you are overstating the complexity concerns.
by SoftTalker 2y ago
Given that ICEs are produced in the millions and are quite reliable with very low maintenance requirements, I'd say you are overstating the complexity concerns.
Yes they are complex mechanical things by some measures, but really not more so than say, a mechanical clock. Intermeshed gears, cams, cranks and that sort of thing. The materials and durability demands are different sure, but these problems have been solved.
Many of the other things that are complicated in modern cars are the same in an EV: automatic climate controls with flaps and dampers, the air conditioning system itself, which is even more complex on a battery EV that has to manage battery temperatures, antilock braking systems, automated suspensions that adapt to road conditions, lane-keeping, automatic parking, variable power steering, etc.
- fnordpiglet 2y agoI’d note that mechanical clocks have almost entirely been replaced with solid state clocks for effectively all the same reasons. I’d also note you’re only considering the manufacturers perspective. As a consumer of cars, the complexity of the machine results in a long list of expensive regular maintenance, of which almost none of applies to EVs. Finally I’d note that saying both have a basis of complexity that’s unchanging doesn’t in any way change the point that ICE then have a ton of additional complexity. Just because at our current scale and research the unit cost of the complexity is about as small as it can help doesn’t mean it has a better future. The complexity of EVs will drop as well, and faster, since it’s still an immature technology and supply chain. I think BYD demonstrates clearly that EVs are already cheaper end to end than ICE, and it’s mostly political and infrastructural work. The political side falls apart in face of economics, and the infrastructure side resolves over time just as oil infrastructure did. I think the real inflection point will be when gas stations start installing fast EV chargers that captures convenience store traffic and conversion better than the pumps, which are already basically break even or worse margins.
- dzhiurgis 2y ago> Many of the other things that are complicated in modern cars are the same in an EV Yet, when you buy used car - do you look at climate system or make sure engine works well?
- SoftTalker 2y agoI look at the climate system. If it works, it’s a good clue the rest of the car has been taken care of.
- JohnFen 2y agoInteresting. I maintain my car conscientiously, but I pay almost zero attention to the climate system because given the climate in my part of the US, a working climate system isn't actually important enough to me to spend time or money on maintaining.