4 ms·
I wonder what accuracy would human get if you trained him/her only with 10 million static 200x200 px images in complete silence.
by scotty79 14y ago
I wonder what accuracy would human get if you trained him/her only with 10 million static 200x200 px images in complete silence.
- ekianjo 14y agoI don't think this was "complete silence" in this case. They actually trained the computer (meaning they provided data as input).
- ehsanu1 14y agoscotty79 means to showing a human only the 10 million 200x200 images. We probably see a lot more than that, in 3D from different perspectives with continuity in motion, and in a lot more detail and possibilities for filtering.
- ekianjo 14y ago> scotty79 means to showing a human only the 10 million 200x200 images Then, what kind of thing are you measuring? Recognizing patterns ? We know humans are very good at that. We can see thousands of different people everyday but we can recognize in the blink of an eye a familiar face. A computer or computer network is very, very, very far from being able to do that yet.
- kalleboo 14y agoBut why are humans are very good at that? Could it be because humans have gotten tons of high-resolution, 3D imagery with binaural audio? Whereas this computer got a handful of low-res still images. Is the solution to just throw more horsepower at the problem, or is there really some inherent quality of the brain that's different? edit: this quote puts things into perspective a bit "It is worth noting that our network is still tiny compared to the human visual cortex, which is 1,000,000 times larger in terms of the number of neurons and synapses."
- ehsanu1 14y agoAlso, consider training time. I doubt babies are recognizing 20k objects at 15% success rate after just a few days. Though to really compare that, the speed of the brain vs the speed of the supercomputer has to be normalized for, and training data and network size has to be similar as well of course for any real comparison.
- scotty79 14y agoBy "silence" I meant only image, no other input for example no labeling images in any way.
- shriphani 14y agoBabies can outperform any CV model with less data than that.
- scotty79 14y agoI strongly doubt that. I think babies have much richer input than any CV system up to date. In my opinion movement is crucial for understanding image.
- Dn_Ab 14y agoA human baby learns in a very interesting way. By using an overcomplete basis to sparsely code data. This method has only recently started getting attention in ML. A human baby learns from uncleaned raw data using far less energy with better generalization than a computer and fuses large amount of data without suffering from dimensionality curses. I think it is safe to say that human babies are still ahead. for now.
- scotty79 14y agoI agree that CV is currently behind human sight. I just argue that this is more due to lacking input processing than to actual classification engine. The reason they used 200x200 px images, I think, was that bigger images couldn't be analysed in sufficient quantity. In a way their first input processing of the real images was pixelisation filter. If you feed pixelised image to a person you see how much information is lost. If you make single pixels occupy significant portion of view person might loose ability to recognize the image at all. Feeding so little information to CV system is like trying to teach nearly blind man to see. To improve CV we should focus on finding best ways of converting full resolution visual data to something of smaller volume in such way that important features are preserved. This input data IMO should also include time. I, thanks to crappy eyesight often recognize people, actions, objects relying more on how they move not how they look to me. Even with sharp eysight sometime your vision just gets stuck and can't recognize what is in the scene you are currently looking at. You can't understand what you see until something in the scene moves or you move a bit.