7 ms·
Kids Should Be Taught to Think Logically
- spking 2y agoI don’t disagree with the premise that this is a worthy goal to strive for, but I do find it odd to tie it to the need to combat “outlandish conspiracy thinking” and linking to a three year old NPR article about Trump.
- argiopetech 2y ago"The personal is political", apparently.
- peterhadlaw 2y agoI already knew it was going to be something like this just from the title. Kids should be taught to think for themselves, not just logically. We are growing a generation of people who offload their critical thinking to authority or actors/actresses or pop culture.
- bilbo0s 2y agoTo be fair, every generations is "a generation of people who offload their critical thinking to authority or actors/actresses or pop culture." This didn't start with the generation currently under 18 years of age. I mean not to put too fine a point on it, but the outlandish conspiracy theories everyone is concerned about came from Boomers, Millennials, X'ers and older GenZ'ers. Frankly, the evidence points to all of us having questionable critical thinking skills. My suspicion is that not only those under 18, but those over 18 as well could use a bit of a refresher on symbolic logic. Also a refresher on assessing the verifiability and relative value of facts.
- graemep 2y agoI agree. Learning symbolic logic might help (in that it might make if easier to recognise fallacies), but it is a small part of what is needed. If you just teach it, it will just be another bit of theoretical knowledge from school people never apply. At the risk of sounding a bit conspiracy theorist myself I would say "authority" is quite comfortable with people not thinking themselves. People aim to be in authority because they think they know what is best for everyone - no thinking required of the hoi polloi. Edit: I think it would be rather like maths. A lot of people (not around here, but say, business people on LinkedIn) say "I never use the maths I was taught in school so its pointless teaching it" because they do not know how to apply it.
- parpfish 2y agoagreed. logical thinking is good, but i don't think logic is necessarily the problem for a lot of conspiratorial thinking. i'd argue that the more common problem is a deficiency in assessing reasonableness or plausibility of facts and claims. if you feed garbage data into your logic-machine, you'll get garbage results.
- andyjohnson0 2y agoI agree with the article. But I'd go further and say that children should be introduced to, and taught, multiple styles of thinking. And they should understand the strengths and weaknesses of those styles for different tasks and situations. But logical thought is definitely important. Judging by some people I encounter, even understanding the concepts of "necessary but not sufficient" or "X is-a Y does not mean that Y is-a X" would make a big difference.
- vaylian 2y ago> multiple styles of thinking What would be on that list?
- kqr 2y agoStatistical/empirical thinking for one: https://two-wrongs.com/statistical-literacy https://two-wrongs.com/statistical-literacy > It emphasises how logic alone might not lead us to the right conclusions, because there are more things at play in reality than in our mental models. > It suggests that we choose actions by carefully studying outcomes rather than based on what ought to yield the best outcome. > It tells us that differences in outcomes may not be a signal of differences in controllable antecedents: it is often just the natural variation of the process.
- dclowd9901 2y agoCan you give an example of something that’s logically provable but not true empirically? I tried to think of something and I admit I’m struggling to.
- kqr 2y ago"The best player will wn the game." "They have a really good startup idea so they will be successful." "We need to fire a salesperson so we'll pick the one with the lowest total contract value." "The bus trip takes 43 minutes so I will be there at 12.17." You'll note that these are not failures of logic (which is somewhat self-consistent and cannot fail) but rather of small-ish world views that don't allow for uncontrolled factors, which I think is a distinguishing factor of statistical thinking.
- slkjdlskjdklsd 2y ago[flagged]
- layer8 2y agoIllogically.
- slkjdlskjdklsd 2y agoWhat does that means?
- itronitron 2y agoI think you could describe the main alternative as 'institutionally mandated thinking' which ironically tends to be the approach used by school systems.
- llamaimperative 2y agoThe main alternative is obviously emotional thinking, or "motivated reasoning." It is a factor in every decision made by anyone about anything, and has far greater reach than whatever bugbear you're pointing to here.
- itronitron 2y agoin addition to making a good point, you also provide an excellent example
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- erehweb 2y agoI like symbolic logic, but does it actually make people better citizens / resistant to conspiracy thinking / ... as the author hopes? Is there any evidence for that?
- lucianbr 2y agoThis is my question too. Is this a proven thing, or is it just the author's opinion or intuition? How do you even measure "better citizens"? Lots of drivers will say we should build more and wider roads, more motorways, and so on. But there are some arguments for not doing that. The obvious thing or the intuitive thing is not always the right thing to do.
- throw738383838 2y ago> To combat conspiracy thinking, the most promising approach has been found to be prevention. We must either warn people ahead of time about a particular conspiracy theory or explicitly teach them how to spot shoddy evidence. Symbolic logic provides rigorous training to spot inconsistencies and flaws in reasoning. For example, many naysayers to global warming present the evidence of cold weather on a particular I like the effort. But it is done very poorly. Term "global warming" was replaced by "global climate change". There are valid scientific reasons and nuances for that change.
- byteknight 2y agoThe "term" was not changed. Who is the authority on the term? Language is defined by those that use it.
- empressplay 2y agos/logically/critically/g
- leokeba 2y agohttps://archive.is/TSRMW https://archive.is/TSRMW
- mewpmewp2 2y agoThe issue with disinformation, conspiracies and everything similar is that it's not very simple to logically prove one or the other. There are so many unknown factors, and different base truths that people would have to agree on. Usually it's the way where someone forms a belief for whatever reason. It could be because it's just beneficial for them. E.g. someone who likes gas guzzlers might want to reject climate change just because they want to keep doing what they are doing guilt free. So then whatever logic skills they have, they would only apply it to argue against climate change. Not try to figure out whether there actually is climate change. It would just make them more skilled in finding logic around areas with many unknown factors. Then - the article says to warn about potential conspiracy theories that might be arising. But if someone is prone to consider conspiracy theories, wouldn't that possibly have the counter effect, the Barbara Streisand effect. Wouldn't they think that "that's exactly what people behind the conspiracy would do, try to convince us of it not being there".
- CooCooCaCha 2y agoFrankly I think the issue is religion and other forms of spiritual/mystical/supernatural thinking. If people think it’s ok to have irrational beliefs, you give their brain an escape hatch to ignore logic and reason if it feels good. Not to mention this can and does get exploited by bad actors.
- Kenji 2y ago[dead]
- dxbydt 2y agothe way things are headed in the US, “kids should be taught” is itself an aspirational goal. “think logically” would be icing on a nonexistent cake. my state is unwilling to pay more than $21 per hour to a teacher. every attempt to add even a dollar to this figure has been overturned. first “congress should be taught” what a reasonable wage is.
- aeneasmackenzie 2y agoLook up the total expenditure on education per student in your state, then do a rough calculation of how much of it is actually going to teaching students (facilities, teacher salaries, school supplies). It's usually not that much and school districts spend it on nonsense instead. There's probably enough money already so adding more won't help.
- dclowd9901 2y agoI live in Arizona, which regularly places last in education. We also happen to place 49th in spending, at about $10k per student vs $15k on average nationally. I think you might be right in some situations but wrong in most others.
- aeneasmackenzie 2y agoAZ average students per class is 18. $21/hr for 2000 hours is $42k. Double it to overaccount for total cost of employee. Where's the $96k remaining going? I'm not going to analyze further, I don't live in AZ. But you should check out the actual answers. Teachers could make more without spending more on education. Or rather spending more on education and less on "education"
- stvltvs 2y agoTeacher salary is only one cost of educating students. You also need to have school buildings, maintenance staff, administrative staff, etc. Stingy states like Arizona are not overspending on education. They need to minimize waste AND spend more to adequately educate their children.
- _el1s7 2y agoIf "thinking logically" could be taught, we would already have monkeys as co-workers
- d3m0t3p 2y agoI don’t agree, We can learn to apply thought process. We learn by heart patterns and recognize them in new situations. Learning that a -> b doesn’t mean that b-> a. I would be able to say it for a few cases intuitively but knowing this pattern exists I’m able to apply it to all construct not a few cases I also allow me to formally prove or disprove something I have an intuition for
- glitchc 2y agoI disagree. All humans can be taught to think critically. It's a learned skill. Logic is rather rigorous i.e. just learning a few basic rules and applying them can falsify the bulk of claims made in typical discourse. Everyone can learn to sniff out bullshit without having to become a Descartes.
- _el1s7 2y agoMaybe that's true, I might've been wrong. But still I don't think that it's that straightforward, human brain and intelligence are things we don't fully understand yet.
- richrichie 2y ago> For example, many naysayers to global warming present the evidence of cold weather on a particular day as a proof that global warming is a conspiracy. This is quite rare and the opposite is in fact more common. “Hottest day since xx” is the most common claim. Even in an article about logic, they can’t help but gaslight.
- lucianbr 2y ago> “Hottest day since xx” is the most common claim. Is it the most common claim of naysayers? I very much doubt it. Do you have any proof of this?
- notjoemama 2y agoSymbolic logic is already taught as part of the common core, just not in the distinctly programatic way it exists in writing code. Logical thinking in mathematics has been pushed down to elementary school. What the author thinks ought to be already mostly is. But let's say you're an activist and expect the world to reflect your view... The National Governors Association and the Council of Chief State School Officers are the two governing bodies that pushed for it. You can either lobby them or the Department of Education to force states to teach what you want them to teach.
- tfandango 2y agoMy wife teaches second grade and for some time they had a common-core math curriculum that encouraged writing about math, how you solved this problem, and discussing that with the class. It was interesting to me to see this in person, because children often solve problems in different ways which work for them, discussing it as a class disseminated that knowledge to someone else who may find it useful. The end result is second graders who are good at math but also understand why X+Y=Z, not just that it does. It is hard to teach this and requires a lot of work from the teacher's side to become good at it and to pull the right information from the children. In a state that criminally underfunds public education, many teachers didn't want to learn this and when the time came, discontinued this curriculum for something that required no writing (also a mandate from our worthless state department of education) and did offer more color-by-numbers, which my wife describes as "pre-k stuff". Rant aside, I was astounded to watch how much 2nd graders understood about math when given the opportunity to approach problems like this.
- swayvil 2y agoLogic is a small trick. It's picking the right assumptions that's the real challenge. Do we choose the authority of the hour? An older tradition? Come up with our own ideas? Lots of options there.
- glitchc 2y agoThinking critically is in direct contradiction with the notion that everyone's opinion is equally valid. Our society does not promote critical thinking as a useful life skill, it's more about appeal to authority and belonging. Our culture would need to change to make this a life skill worth having.
- mikrl 2y ago>Thinking critically is in direct contradiction with the notion that everyone's opinion is equally valid Democratic societies tend to follow the model that truth comes out of conflict in the marketplace of ideas: the best idea wins, and everyone’s opinion is equally valid as spoken, until it is shown to be unfit through competition. Authoritarian movements tend to follow the more religious model that the truth is only knowable by a learned/privileged class in a society, and those not in this group should support them and leave them to discover it, then accept it. So, I would say critical thinking is necessary for democracy and anathema to authoritarianism, or perhaps the democratization of critical thought is necessary for healthy democracy.
- ToucanLoucan 2y ago> Democratic societies tend to follow the model that truth comes out of conflict in the marketplace of ideas: the best idea wins, and everyone’s opinion is equally valid as spoken, until it is shown to be unfit through competition. And like most ideas most people have about marketplaces, it's wrong. The marketplace of ideas is like most marketplaces in that it, by virtue of being built of people, inherits all the flaws present in those people: emotional thinking, biases (conscious and unconscious), and all the mental frailties that plague us as beings: concerns about social status, fitting in, and the desire to flex. As a result, again like any other marketplace, simply "having the best product" is a distant last place to far more effective strategies to ensure your success in the market: good branding and advertising, collusion with other participants, vertical integration and of course, bullshitting the consumers on an industrial scale. And, failing all that, litigation. That an idea succeeds in a marketplace of ideas is no different than a product which succeeds in a marketplace: it doesn't mean anything intrinsic about the idea/product, it just means that idea/product did well in this market, at this time, with these consumers, and if any of those circumstances were changed, it is entirely possible that product would then lose.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- itishappy 2y agoNot a fan of this article. I agree with the premise, but I don't think the conclusions are sound. We live in a society of imperfect information, and logic can give rise to conspiracies just as easily as dispel them. "Jet fuel can't melt steel beams," for example. I think it's a fallacy to assume the root of our political divide is a lack of logic. > For example, many naysayers to global warming present the evidence of cold weather on a particular day as a proof that global warming is a conspiracy. A logical thinker is quick to spot that weather is what happens on any given day, while climate is what is happening across the globe over decades. This is semantics, not logic.
- jfengel 2y agoI concur. Logic is rarely the problem. The problem is nearly always what you're applying the logic to. The article, and the HN discussion, conflates "logic" with "critical thinking". They are in fact quite different. Logic is a mechanical process, which can be done by computers. "Critical thinking" is how we come up with the premises to which we apply the logic. Garbage in produces garbage out. It would be nice to teach kids to recognize garbage, but you're going to have a hard time getting adults to agree on what "garbage" is. It would be nice to be able to make statements like "If effectively every single relevant scientist agrees on something, it's far more likely to be true." But even if you did get schools to teach that, many parents will loudly contradict it.
- raintrees 2y agoLogical and critical thinking would be a challenge to those in power, apparently the Trivium had been removed from a classical liberal education some time ago. I learned about the Trivium in an online school long after I left college... Charlotte Thomson Iserbyt's "The Deliberate Dumbing Down of America" may be a case in point. https://deliberatedumbingdown.com/ddd/ https://deliberatedumbingdown.com/ddd/ Conspiracy surrounds us, "conspiracy theory" seems to be a tactic first used by an "intelligence" agency to discourage those who question the "authorized" narrative. Free thinking is a gift, that can also be a challenge when it goes counter to main stream culture.
- xamde 2y agoAlso, Basic statistical reasoning is required. And some core facts about our physical world. What about an open curriculum listing the most important things in a teachable order?
- matrix87 2y ago> For example, many naysayers to global warming present the evidence of cold weather on a particular day as a proof that global warming is a conspiracy. Look, if they're trying to bring in symbolic logic to prove something about global warming, namely, that humans are causing it, that's fundamentally misguided because causality is not provable. I'm not saying that I don't believe that humans are causing it, just that talking about causal relationships is outside the scope of what logic is meant for You can have a logically consistent worldview that the author would immediately discount as conspiracy garbage. Logical inconsistency is not the issue here. The issue is that the author doesn't like the set of assumptions that other people are making As an aside, expecting people to have completely consistent and justified sets of beliefs is completely out of touch with how people actually are. Anyone who's read some dostoevsky knows this
- dclowd9901 2y agoYou’re correct that logical thinking falls short of proving human-caused global warming in and of itself, but you couple that with empirical evidence. Under all thinking roots logical thinking. Data and research only go so far: At some point, you have to try to take the evidence you have and apply it using logic. Indeed you need logic to even construct the studies in a way that they will yield useful results.
- matrix87 2y ago> Under all thinking roots logical thinking Hmm, is this something that you can prove with logic though?
- dclowd9901 2y agoYou can prove if A = B and B = C, A = C. I understand the example is contrived, but the point is you have a framework for making conclusions. All of the data in the world won’t help you if you can’t arrange its into a way to make a conclusion from it. This is how logic underpins everything. It’s sort of like physics. Everything is just physics at its basis.
- Euphorbium 2y agoReligions work real hard from day one, to make sure that no logical thinking can manifest.
- CooCooCaCha 2y agoReligion and all supernatural thinking is a huge part of it. A culture where people think it’s ok to believe in made up nonsense will always work against rational thinking. Even stuff like crystals, tarot cards, and astrology contribute to this.
- Lichtso 2y agoWhile better understanding of logic and reason are certainly not harmful, they are not the solution to the problems the article describes, because it is not the lack thereof that is causing these problems in the first place: Fighting conspiracy theories and disinformation, educating the next generation to vote more thoughtfully and independently, etc. "responsible citizenship" as the article puts it. What I observe over and over again is that people are quick to draw the conclusion that everybody who arrived at a different worldview than them must be lacking logical reasoning abilities, thus be stupid. Because, how else would you not arrive at the only "logical" worldview? And the article makes the same mistake. (For the record, I am not saying that there are multiple subjective truths, no, there is only one objective truth. However, nobody can truly claim to know knowing it.) Furthermore, this misunderstanding about the problem perpetuates the problem. It is like treating an infectious disease by draining blood from the patient. In a functional society everybody only verifies a small part of the truth, which they have expertise in. These parts then overlap and form the whole. No single individual has to be able to reason through its entirety and prove everything, as that is impossible. Instead, the system relies on trusting the partial results of others. And that is exactly the attack surface is. Conspiracy theories, disinformation and populism are nourished by completely different mechanisms independent of thought and reasoning. Attacking them on that level is futile. Even if they superficially look like manipulation of the though process, they are instead emotional manipulation. Typically the erosion of trust with fear as replacement.
- carapace 2y agoAdults should be taught to think logically first, then they can teach the children. The problem with the idea that logical thinking will dispel conspiracy thinking is that conspiracy is the norm. Of regime changes in the 21st Century more than half were the result of a coup. Crypto AG was a CIA front. Cigarettes are bad for you. (I could go on giving examples all day. All. Day.) Symbolic logic will not save us from conspiracy for the simple reason that conspiracy is everywhere. Those that think otherwise are ignoring evidence or non-rational. - - - - Application of symbolic logic to human psychology reveals that human motivations form a DAG (Directed Acyclic Graph) that tops out in deep and profound spiritual states. (E.g. I do A to achieve B which results in C that in turn engenders profound bliss.) It turns out that most human activity is yak-shaving and, strictly speaking, unnecessary. That's how you use symbolic logic to defeat misunderstanding and make life better.
- jerb 2y agoT