3 ms·
> The single biggest problem we face as a species is dropping resource availability per capita. People keep saying this, but it’s been proven wrong over and ov
by rayiner 2y ago
> The single biggest problem we face as a species is dropping resource availability per capita.
People keep saying this, but it’s been proven wrong over and over again since the 19th century. Malthus was wrong.
> This weird effect where wealth reduces birth rate is a fantastic and unexpected reprieve that is probably not going to be permanent but there is no call to try and engineer its reversal.
It’s not “nature.” It’s the result of anti-natalist eugenics ideology created by mainline Protestants in the 20th century in response to a moral panic about rising Catholic and black populations. They exported that ideology around the world through NGOs in the form of population control ideology. (My dad started his career at a Planned Parenthood affiliate in Bangladesh figuring out how to have less Bangladeshis. Planned Parenthood, of course, was started by Margaret Sanger, an Episcopalian and eugenicist.) East Asian countries that bought that ideology are now desperately trying to reverse the effects.
> Let nature take its course and adjust for any population problems with immigration.
You can’t maintain a developed society with mass immigration. Sweden and Denmark have already reverse course on immigration and I expect the rest of Western Europe will follow.
- nkurz 2y ago1) I instinctively agree with 'roenxi', but I'd also agree that I don't have a solid basis for this belief. Could you expand on your claim that Malthus was wrong, as opposed to just too early in his prediction? 2) Have even lawyers like you dropped the 'fewer' vs 'less' distinction? I would have thought that you were old and conservative enough that 'less Bangladeshis' would be to grating to write. :)
- rayiner 2y agoMalthusians repeatedly fail to account for technological advancement. There's numerous studies estimating the carrying capacity of earth at above 10-20 billion (figures we likely will never reach): https://na.unep.net/geas/archive/pdfs/GEAS_Jun_12_Carrying_Capacity.pdf https://na.unep.net/geas/archive/pdfs/GEAS_Jun_12_Carrying_C... (see p. 3). When my dad was born in 1951, Bangladesh had a population of 38 million. People already thought it was full. Now, it has a population of 171 million. At the same time, infant mortality decreased by 7/8ths, so it is now lower in Bangladesh than it was in the U.S. in the 1960s. The country is now self-sufficient in the production of rice, fish, and vegetables. And Bangladesh hasn't even begun to maximize technology. The Netherlands is the second largest exporter of agricultural products in the world, despite being 1/3 the size of Bangladesh (which itself is only a bit bigger than Virginia): https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/interactive/2022/netherlands-agriculture-technology/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/interactive/2022/net.... Regarding "fewer" versus "lesser": I'm usually pretty pedantic about that, but I think my brain fed me "lesser" to convey, in the context of that sentence, how population control advocates tend to view Asians as an undifferentiated mass.
- roenxi 2y ago> There's numerous studies estimating the carrying capacity of earth at above 10-20 billion (figures we likely will never reach): https://na.unep.net/geas/archive/pdfs/GEAS_Jun_12_Carrying_C https://na.unep.net/geas/archive/pdfs/GEAS_Jun_12_Carrying_C... (see p. 3). But the majority [0] of studies on p. 3 suggest the carrying capacity is 8 billion or less. And I suspect that if we dig most of those studies aren't anticipating everyone lives with an overwhelming abundance of material comfort. We've already got more people on the globe than we know what to do with. [0] Technical correctness, the best type.
- rayiner 2y agoMy point is that higher ceilings are plausible given certain assumptions. And I expect technological improvement will make those more aggressive assumptions into realistic and likely ones.
- telotortium 2y agoThe url doesn’t work
- nkurz 2y agoThe one in the GP worked for me: https://na.unep.net/geas/archive/pdfs/GEAS_Jun_12_Carrying_Capacity.pdf https://na.unep.net/geas/archive/pdfs/GEAS_Jun_12_Carrying_C...
- telotortium 2y agoThanks!