3 ms·
This ruling isn't about making thousands of digital copies. They're no longer able to offer even 1 digital copy. The CDL is where they would buy N physical cop
by squeaky-clean 2y ago
This ruling isn't about making thousands of digital copies. They're no longer able to offer even 1 digital copy.
The CDL is where they would buy N physical copies of a book, and then allow N active rentals of the digitally scanned version of that book with a waiting list for when people "return" them. Can't do that anymore.
- pie_flavor 2y agoThe bytes were copied thousands of times. That means they made thousands of copies. It doesn't matter if the UX describes a concept of 'a digital copy' which requires that a new copy not be made until the old copy is deleted; copyright law does not say that this exempts you from the usual rule against making unlicensed copies. What you are thinking of, where you own 'a digital copy' of a book, is owning a license (as you have checked an 'I understand' box about a dozen times), not owning a copy. IA does not have permission to sublicense copies it legally owns (and didn't legally own the digital copies to start with, as their purposes weren't within the §108 carveout).