4 ms·
I think it depends on how the tool is used. If a student is just plugging in the problem and asking for the answer, there is clearly no long term benefit to thi
by mym1990 2y ago
I think it depends on how the tool is used. If a student is just plugging in the problem and asking for the answer, there is clearly no long term benefit to this. If the student is trying to understand a concept, and uses GPT to bounce ideas around or to ask for alternate ways of thinking about something, it can be very helpful.
How spacing is utilized can be helpful too. Struggle with the problem for 20-30 minutes. Ask for a nudge. Struggle some more. Repeat many times.
Some concepts also just have to be thought about differently to get to the aha moment, especially in math. AI may have an opportunity to present many instances of “think about it this way instead”.
- me_me_me 2y agochildren using calculators to solve multiplication exercises do worse in multiplication exams Ai is a tool. Use it as a tool - get benefits, use it to cheat...
- xigoi 2y ago> If the student is trying to understand a concept, and uses GPT to bounce ideas around or to ask for alternate ways of thinking about something, it can be very helpful. The article said that even using the AI this way did not improve results.
- mym1990 2y agoAll we know is the tools that were given to the students, not how they used them, and it’s a fairly limited study on top of that, without knowing anything about how other variables were controlled. That being said, I wouldn’t be surprised if the payoff from AI learning isn’t as good as people might think, there still has to be a good process in place and I don’t think it can replace a good teacher and some quality struggle.