4 ms·
> Where x86 processors run into real battery life trouble is that modern Windows and Linux are really bad about keeping power draw low when the laptop lid is cl
by lxgr 2y ago
> Where x86 processors run into real battery life trouble is that modern Windows and Linux are really bad about keeping power draw low when the laptop lid is closed.
That power draw has nothing to do with the CPUs power efficiency, though: Laptop lid closed usually means S3, though, and the CPU is completely unpowered in that state. (CPU registers are saved to RAM.)
The biggest power draw in S3 is the RAM itself, which has to be continuously refreshed to not lose its data, but that can be avoided by doing suspend-to-disk instead.
Modern systems usually do some hybrid between the two, e.g. suspend to both RAM and disk, and power off the RAM after a few hours (or at a given battery level) to meet a compromise between resume speed and battery life.
- The_Colonel 2y agoUnfortunately, modern Windows laptops don't support S3 sleep, instead they have this Modern Standby where CPU runs in low power all the time.
- beart 2y agoIt's really bad. I've never been able to keep a dell laptop asleep. If I don't shut it down completely before putting it into my bag, it will surely be too hot to touch when I pull it back out. Super frustrating when traveling. Flabbergasting, that this issue has not been addressed.
- lxgr 2y agoWow, I had no idea! When I last used Linux and Windows on a Thinkpad, lid closed was equivalent to S3, as indicated by the little crescent moon LED on the lid, fans out, and the battery in that state would last for several days. My Mac does occasionally turn on with the lid closed to do "useful background tasks" (not actually that useful to me, except for broadcasting "Find my Mac" via Bluetooth), but except for one time when I accidentally had that option permanently flagged one via some "prevent sleep" app (I only found out when I noticed that I could SSH to my laptop while it was in my backpack!), it hasn't noticeably drained my battery.
- eigenspace 2y agoIf you read the rest of my comment, I explain that the only reason x86 is worse for this than ARM is just software recency vs legacy cruft. There is a real difference, but it’s nothing intrinsic to ARM or x86 I agree.