5 ms·
A Logo on a Prosthesis Is Like a Tattoo You Didn't Ask For
- bookofjoe 2y agohttps://archive.ph/n3Zw2 https://archive.ph/n3Zw2
- flerchin 2y agoI take the branded license-plate holders off my cars, and I'd debadge them if there was a user-serviceable way to do it. An orange branding label on my hand would be absolutely disgusting.
- overcast 2y agoThis is one of the first questions I ask when buying a car. Do you put that stupid badge on everything you sell? I make it clear no sale if they do. I bought the car, you made your money, I'm not advertising for you, end of transaction.
- klyrs 2y agoHow do you feel about branding on the bus you ride?
- dylan604 2y agoThey just told you they bought a car, so why would they take the bus? Also, you've totally missed the point. They own the car. A person riding the bus does not own the bus nor get a say in how the bus is decorated
- lupusreal 2y agoThe way city busses are crammed full of commercial advertisements is one of the reasons I hate riding them.
- Haammamajoe 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- _yb2s 2y agoHigher end German cars typically have a badge delete factory option. I have an older Porsche that came without badges from the factory. I also think it is in poor taste to have prominent logos or brands on a product… if the manufacturer is going to use me for advertising that needs to be explicitly the deal: they provide the product free, and then we can negotiate how much they will pay on top of that.
- overcast 2y agoI'm not talking about brand badges, I'm talking about the tacky dealership badges they put on aftermarket.
- _yb2s 2y agoAhhh… yeah I would not tolerate that either, but I don’t buy cars from dealerships- they are middlemen in the business of ripping you off. They already had to buy it at a market rate and added no value, so can’t make anything unless they overcharge you.
- chaostheory 2y agoIn the US, in most cases you have to go through a dealer due to lobbying.
- 3-cheese-sundae 2y agoI think that's an oversimplification. The market rates for wholesale, private sale, and retail are different. Selling a vehicle to a private party always nets the seller more cash than selling the same to a dealer. As a private buyer, you would have a very difficult time trying to buy a vehicle direct from most manufacturers. As another said, this is due to lobbying, but that doesn't change the fact that the markets are different.
- _yb2s 2y agoFair point for new cars, I neglected to state I was only talking about buying used cars. Personally, I buy used cars because the amount of depreciation makes them an incredibly good deal, it seems to be an irrational cultural thing. I find it amusing that I get comments like "I didn't know you were so rich" for driving an old Porsche Boxster I got for $8k on Craigslist... always stored indoors and looks like new- and has been as reliable as a new car in 4 years of commuting. A new low end economy car at 3x the price is way too expensive for me. Most individuals selling a used car, especially wealthier ones, aren't too interested in getting the most money from it, but just want it gone to move on with their lives. Not so with dealers, if they can't get you to pay a huge margin over what they bought it for (a price you could also buy one for) they'll wait for another buyer. I'm not fundamentally opposed to buying used cars from a dealer, but when I've researched fair market prices, I've usually not been able to talk them down to anywhere close to them... whereas I've had many times where private sellers took an incredibly low ball offer I wasn't really expecting them to take.
- qingcharles 2y agoWhen it comes time to settle up the car purchase just adjust the total for the monthly rental of advertising space on your car. Say, $200/month, 5 years in advance?
- whartung 2y agoI don’t go as far as the car, but I do strive to not have branding on most everything else, but specifically clothes. A logo on a shirt is pretty much a non-starter.
- illiac786 2y agoDepends for me. Some small company, I’m fine with supporting them. The H&M of this world, they’d have to pay me, a lot.
- LeifCarrotson 2y agoRemoving the badges is pretty easy with some dental floss, a hair dryer or heat gun, and Goo Gone. Lots of how-to videos on the Internet. They're just plastic held to the paint with some adhesive, and the adhesive deteriorates at temperatures much less than what would damage the paint.
- delichon 2y agoThe first thing I did when I drove my new Jeep Wrangler home was get out my tools and remove about six different brand labels. There are two remaining, one cut out of the rear bumper and one embossed in the metal of the rear gate. Praise to Chrysler for attaching the other labels in a way that I could remove them without damage. This is generally how I treat brand labels when bring something home. I use a thread puller to remove logos from clothing. I keep flat nail polish to paint over other cases. If I got a prosthesis with a logo I'd try the same, and at least manage to cover it up a bit. I figure if they want me to display their brand they can make an endorsement agreement with my agent. As soon as someone asks for my agent's number I'll hire one. First I'll see if Deloris Jordan is available.
- flerchin 2y agoWearing my own branded shoes would be nice. Yes I will take that deal with Nike. They can put a small swoosh on there too, for even more money.
- bookofjoe 2y agoI would bet a huge majority of ALL buyers of high-end vehicles would opt in if asked whether they wanted brand logos on their expensive purchases/leases. I would also bet that a huge majority of HN readers would opt out.
- _yb2s 2y agoLook at high end German cars on the road- Porsche, BMW, Mercedes and see what portion are missing the badges, because they all offer a "badge delete" factory option. I'd say it's roughly 10-20% that opt in. It's considered sort of a cool thing with car enthusiasts and often makes the used model slightly more desirable and unique. I suppose it means that you care more about driving and not impressing other people, or you care about trying to impress other car nerds with the implication.
- bookofjoe 2y agoI accept your challenge! From today on I'm gonna keep track and when I tally 100 or so total I will report my results here, prolly via an Ask HN post. Stay tuned. >It's considered sort of a cool thing with car enthusiasts and often makes the used model slightly more desirable and unique. I'm unclear: which option is "considered sort of cool..."?
- _yb2s 2y ago> which option is "considered sort of cool..."? badge delete If you're going to analyze which percentage of cars are ordered which badge delete, you will first need to know which can be ordered with it.
- bookofjoe 2y agoFrom Wikipedia entry on Debadging: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debadging https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Debadging >Some people driving high-end luxury cars do it so as not to flaunt the fact their car is any different from any other model and remove the badge. In Europe in particular, it is a common request for purchasers of high-end models of cars like BMW or Mercedes-Benz, etc. to have the emblems removed. Since I am in the U.S., I need to contact my local Mercedes and BMW dealers and ask if their cars can be ordered without the badge. Stay tuned.
- Joker_vD 2y agoWhat a weird analogy. Putting a logo on any product is called branding. So a logo on a prosthesis is just having a branding on oneself. Which is a much more powerful analogy, even at the cost of being a tasteless pun.
- debo_ 2y ago[flagged]
- chank 2y agoIt's actually a perfect analogy, IMO. Tattoo, is a form of (typically chosen) self-branding. A lot of companies make great products and then deminish them by thier mis/use of branding. Usually in a tactless way. This is a prime example of that.
- LargeWu 2y agoA lot of people buy products because of the branding. How many people would buy a YETI cooler if or a Coach bag if it didn't have the branding to show off that they have a YETI cooler or a Coach bag? It's conspicuous consumption.
- chank 2y agoI think those two in particular might be poor examples, since they generally do quite a bit of de-branding on their products. I know what you mean however. Supreme is a prime brand for this. Nobody is buying a Supreme t-shirt for any other reason than the logo. Whatever thoughts on people who buy things to impress others may be, those kind of people exist and to each thier own. They at least made the choice to let everyone else know what they value.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- stndef 2y agoI see where you're coming from, but a prosthetic arm is someone's arm. Mentally it very quickly can become something you identify with, like a prosthetic arm basically being YOUR arm. When you then have your prosthetic then being an advertisement, it can have an impact on your relationship with the device. I don't want someone branding my arm and I can see why others would feel the same.
- gregors 2y agoIt's interesting to me that this happens in an industry where the entire business is one of trying to aid someone who's lost something precious. Some things shouldn't have corporate branding. They definitely know better.
- lupusreal 2y agoI bet they did it without even thinking once about it, let alone thinking twice. In modern culture branding is on everything and most people see nothing wrong with it. From where I am sitting now I can look around and see hundreds of logos. I don't like this and think prosthetic manufacturers particularly shouldn't do it, but it would really surprise me if anybody in the company even had a personal unvoiced doubt about doing it.
- JohnFen 2y ago> In modern culture branding is on everything Truth. I've had a habit of removing all branding I can from the things I buy (particularly clothing) for most of my life. That got me to tune into it, and when you tune into it, you can't help but notice it's literally everywhere.
- marssaxman 2y agoLikewise! A seam ripper is helpful. For logos which are molded in, I have a collection of patches I can sew on; better a pretty ornament, or at least a symbol of something I care about, in place of some advertising.
- rickdeckard 2y agoNo doubt: If tombstones would move around in public, they would be branded for decades already... "I branded his stone with Pepsi, because he always drank Pepsi..."
- carlmr 2y agoI'm not sure they would like that branding, seeing as soda drinkers will have on average shortened lifespans.
- rickdeckard 2y ago> The first time Angel Giuffria saw the logo on her bionic hand, she felt a sense of pride. [..] > But the more she stared at the brand’s orange-and-black logo slapped across the top of the hand [..] > Not everyone minds the branding. [..] Not to nitpick, but it would be so much easier to align on the premise and get into the topic if the author would put JUST ONE picture of such a branded prosthesis somewhere in the article, at least as a reference...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Rhapso 2y agoThere is no vendor lock-in quite like prosthetic or implant vendor lock-in. BAHAs and Cochlear implants are prosthetic ears. They both involve putting company-specific hardware in your body that is incompatible with competitors. Sometimes due to insurance changes, you have to get surgery to get new compatible hardware in your body and bones. Bone integrated limb prosthetics are similarly a thing and similarly affected. Prosthetics with electronics can even be effectively remotely disabled if the user doesn't bring them in for maintenance (pay more money) Having your body part branded can at least be painted over.
- JohnFen 2y agoYeah, I've seen some of this happen to a couple of friends. I really, really hope that I never have to have any electronics embedded in me. Being so vulnerable to the whims of these companies is a scary prospect.
- illiac786 2y agoRepo Men (2010) with Jude Law and Forest Whitaker - not so far fetched.
- ThrowawayTestr 2y agoI wouldn't mind a logo on my 100k prosthetic but only if they're paying for it.
- Haammamajoe 2y agoThats a very very dominant logo on a very dominant position.
- bookofjoe 2y agoBy the same author (2022): >Go ahead and stare at my prosthetic arm. I know it’s awesome. https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/2022/09/19/prosthetic-arm-design-personalize-disability/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/lifestyle/2022/09/19/prosthet... https://archive.ph/D6WlU https://archive.ph/D6WlU
- sparrish 2y agoAwesome it is. But I don't see any logo in any of those pictures. Wonder if she received a new one.
- bookofjoe 2y agoI've just spent a half-hour looking high and low for a picture of the one she described in detail in her Atlantic article but found nothing. I wonder if the Atlantic opted not to show a picture because of the critical tone of the article and fear of igniting legal action by one or more of the four companies — BeBionic, WillowWood, Ottobock, BOA — cited. That would be my guess.
- bookofjoe 2y agoReading comments on this article it occurred to me that there is probably a huge overlap of the Venn diagrams of HN readers and Muji aficionados.
- drivingmenuts 2y agoWow. American business is just not afraid to absolutely shit all over human dignity.
- 7402 2y agoClassic New Yorker cartoon: https://condenaststore.com/featured/if-my-mother-and-father-had-wanted-to-see-yves-robert-weber.html https://condenaststore.com/featured/if-my-mother-and-father-...
- almucentaret 2y ago[dead]