5 ms·
Real education is the path out of poverty. It always has been. Real education teaches people to think more effectively. Not everything called "education" fits t
by Mz 14y ago
Real education is the path out of poverty. It always has been. Real education teaches people to think more effectively. Not everything called "education" fits that requirement. The poor are often subjected to training rather than education, which very often doesn't resolve anything. Training tends to reinforce the social trap they live in.
I suggest you not only read the article but also the book it is about. It is one of the more important books I have read.
- Tichy 14y agoIs it actionable?
- Mz 14y agoEr, sorry, is what actionable?
- dredmorbius 14y agoSomething which can be acted upon, meaningfully. Knowing that a tidal wave is headed your way when you've got safe ground that's reachable, is actionable. You can take action to change the outcome. Knowing that, say, that within the next century the sun would go nova, or a local star would go supernova, for all practical intents, is not actionable in any manner that action could be taken which would preserve civilization / the human species.
- Mz 14y agoI know what the word actionable means. I don't know what he is asking about. Is my suggestion to read the book actionable? Yes, I think so. Is the info in the book actionable? Yes, I think so, on several fronts. But I don't know what action he wants me talking to him about.
- dredmorbius 14y agoNo fears, my bad.
- Tichy 14y agoWhat you say - if you think the info in the book is actionable, you could have answered my question with "yes".
- danielweber 14y agoDid this project have good results? Have other people successfully replicated those good results running the project themselves? I suspect, like most projects, it didn't meet both of those criteria. However, if it did, I would be extremely interested.
- Ralith 14y ago> A year after graduation, ten of the first sixteen Clemente Course graduates were attending four-year colleges or going to nursing school; four of them had received full scholarships to Bard College. The other graduates were attending community college or working full-time. Except for one: she had been fired from her job in a fast-food restaurant for trying to start a union. It sounds like it was successful to me.
- Produce 14y agoSo the solution is to make everyone a nurse or an engineer or a manager? Who's going to sweep the streets and grow food?
- Ralith 14y agoWhat? The solution proposed by the article is to make quality education available.
- Produce 14y agoAnd the implication of everybody being well educated is that everyone will have white collar jobs or prestigious blue collar jobs. If everyone is well educated then who will want to take a job as a street cleaner when they've just spent $80k on their education? The solution is clearly not limited to just educating everyone, is it?
- Mz 14y agoReal education does not necessarily mean spending big bucks. There is plenty of evidence that simply throwing money at the problem doesn't really work. A better correlation is high parental involvement and a community which values education. Also, pay alone does not determine if one is poor. It is not possible to avoid having people who are "relatively poor" as measured by absolute income. But it is possible to take better care of people and reduce real problems like malnutrition, even if you have phd's waiting tables because there are too many of them.
- yummyfajitas 14y ago"Real education" sounds dangerously close to a "true Scotsman".
- Mz 14y agoSorry? I don't think so. I have seen this discussed many times over the years. Genuinely teaching people to think more effectively is real education. What goes on in some schools is more akin to brainwashing, which is the opposite of teaching people to think for themselves.
- Dove 14y agoThe "no true Scotsman" fallacy is about moving goalposts -- about changing the definition in the middle of the argument. You have to agree on a definition, and then you can argue about whether something fits. That is a completely different issue from arguing about definitions themselves. We can indeed hold opinions on what constitutes a true Scotsman, and even argue about which of those opinions is correct -- so long as it's the subject of the conversation. You can't change definitions in the middle of a discussion. But you can certainly hold, support, and defend the consistent opinion that something is not a REAL education. It's not the word "real" that makes something problem. It's changing your mind.
- lotharbot 14y ago> "The "no true Scotsman" fallacy is about moving goalposts" More specifically, NTS is moving the goalposts based on irrelevant criteria. There are times when the goalposts are in the wrong spot, and it's appropriate to stop the main argument, take the time to get your definitions straight, and then move back to the main argument with appropriate goalposts. If you realize that two parties are using different definitions, it's completely appropriate to argue about which definition is correct (possibly "the correct usage for these purposes" rather than "universally correct") before returning to the larger argument.