2 ms·
Your comment is projecting quite heavily. Took me a while to even understand what you're — I'd describe that style as "ranting" — about, but I think I see the c
by ben_w 2y ago
Your comment is projecting quite heavily. Took me a while to even understand what you're — I'd describe that style as "ranting" — about, but I think I see the core of your mistake:
> This is of course why you want "alignment".
There's around 700 different kinds of AI risk: https://airisk.mit.edu/ https://airisk.mit.edu/
I want alignment so the robots don't literally kill everyone.
I want alignment so the chatbots don't convince us to cultivate botulism toxin in our home-made food.
I want alignment so the search engines are not corrupted by advertising.
I want alignment so random people on the street don't spontaneously assault me because their AI "friend" convinced them that my T-shirt is The Mark of The Beast as foretold in Revelations.
I want alignment with the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. Not my beliefs, the actual real truth. Even the hard truths, the ones we may not want to be told but which we are nevertheless better off for knowing — and if that isn't possible, at least to aim for that rather than to throw up our hands and say that because someone else is lying that makes it OK for us to do so as well.
> You want to maintain the ability to mass social engineer while the "normal people" as you call them, lack this power. Same old neoliberal crap.
I count myself as a "normal person" for these purposes.
I'm closer to fully "fully automated luxury space communism" than anything else. Can only get that if the AI is the angel of our better nature, not the exploit optimiser of capitalism (amongst other things). The word "neoliberal" is as much of a buzzword as "woke", with the people using it as an insult counting it as everything they don't like rather than it having a common consensus definition.