4 ms·
The majority of auditory hallucinations are negative, for example voices telling you to kill yourself or someone else. The violence and homicide rates (includin
by commonsensearts 2y ago
The majority of auditory hallucinations are negative, for example voices telling you to kill yourself or someone else. The violence and homicide rates (including stranger homicide) is dramatically higher among those diagnosed with schizophrenia.
The idea that it's only "stigma" that is the problem is counterproductive. I've heard it a thousand times that "They are no more dangerous than someone without the disease," which is a lie.
We should put more effort into determining underlying causes and definitive therapies rather than massaging away the unpleasant reality.
This is not an uneducated opinion, I work in the field.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- svnt 2y agoPresumably you work in the field in North America, and not South India or Africa.
- AStonesThrow 2y ago[flagged]
- cogman10 2y agoI came from a religious upbringing where hearing positive voices would be somewhat of a welcome event (revelation/communicating with deceased loved ones). I hate to say it, but in my church while there were a few individuals that talked about these sorts hallucinations the vast majority did not. (I myself do not hear voices other than my own internal monolog). I appreciate that not all that hear voices are in danger/a danger, but I don't think it's nearly as normal as you are suggesting.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- cogman10 2y agoThis study [1] suggests that a prime cause of violence among schizophrenic individuals is linked to drug/alcohol abuse and/or lack of treatment. > Almost all (94%) of homicides were committed by patients who had a history of alcohol or drug misuse and/or who were not in receipt of planned treatment. Does that ring true? [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7745241/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7745241/
- lupusreal 2y agoDrug/alcohol addicts are far more common than people with psychosis, so if you're suggesting this statistic contradicts his claim then I'm not seeing it. It can easily be true that most murderers are alcoholics/addicts and that psychosis makes people more likely to become murderers. There's really no contradiction here unless you think hearing voices is anywhere near as common as people with drinking problems.
- yunohn 2y agoI often find that the drug/alcohol condition is also caused by having a voice in your head that is telling you to do insane things.
- talldayo 2y agoAre you speaking from personal experience, or are you making a generalized assumption? Either way, it's not much of a response to their study.
- autoexec 2y agoSelf medicating with drugs and alcohol is very common in people with all types of psychiatric disorders. I would expect that a bunch of schizophrenics who have never committed a homicide would have high rates of drug and alcohol abuse in their history. People with less severe symptoms and those getting treatment would be less likely to self medicate. Finding that a bunch of schizophrenics who have committed a homicide have high rates of drug and alcohol abuse isn't surprising either. Because drug/alcohol use can impair people's judgement/inhibitions in the best of circumstances it could be a factor in attacks by schizophrenics, but considering that there are vast numbers of people with who take drugs to excess and very few of them commit homicide I wouldn't jump to putting all the blame on the booze and weed. I'd think that it has a lot more to do with severe cases self-medicating and the lack of treatment.
- ameliaquining 2y agoDo you have sources you can cite? In particular, how do we know that this isn't a selection effect, where the people who experience auditory hallucinations that don't cause problems in their lives don't tell anyone about them? I sure wouldn't, if I were in that situation.
- mandmandam 2y ago> The majority of auditory hallucinations are negative This is only true for us WEIRDos, I believe. There are many cultures where hearing voices doesn't have such negative connotations. Studies have shown that in ie parts of Africa, India, and South America they have much higher neutral and positive experiences than we do. For this reason I believe the underlying causes are strongly cultural, rather than inherent. I'd even go as far as suggesting it's an Abrahamic religion thing - if someone is talking to you in your head, it's kinda bad whether it's God or the Devil.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]