6 ms·
Mother's gut microbiome during pregnancy shapes baby's brain development
- Vinnl 2y agoin mice.
- brightball 2y agoMakes perfect sense to me.
- moomin 2y agoI feel like just linking to the article that explained why gut microbiome research is so difficult.
- pazimzadeh 2y agoWhy?
- zug_zug 2y agoI read that article, but this article cleverly circumvents the challenges that article raised. By not needing measure the microbiome the testing pains are avoided. And though mouse models aren't human, they are effectively blinded. Seems like a very worthy finding that adds to the legitimacy of microbiome's significance.
- tlb 2y agoHowever, they're comparing against no gut bacteria at all, a condition never found in nature. Gut bacteria are necessary for mammals to digest some foods. "Eliminating all gut bacteria harms fetal development" could be another title. It'd be more interesting to compare different plausible microbiomes.
- kulahan 2y agoI think there is a problem with defining what a plausible microbiome even is!
- CoastalCoder 2y ago> However, they're comparing against no gut bacteria at all, a condition never found in nature. Maybe not in nature, but I wonder if it's a similar situation to human mothers who have recently taken a heavy course of antibiotics. IIUC, that can somewhat nuke one's gut flora.
- rPlayer6554 2y agoYes please post it.
- whycome 2y ago[flagged]
- kylehotchkiss 2y agoMy first curiosity was not satisfied by CMD-F "kombucha".
- DataDive 2y agoHaving no bacteria in the gut leads to worse development ... I mean ... duh ... what is the discovery here? It is well known that bacteria are necessary to digest food.
- j_bum 2y agoIn mice [0] What translational value was gained from this study? This is lost on me. We take germ-free pregnant female mice, with no gut microbiome. We then add B. breve UCC2003 to the experimental group. We observe that the metabolic profiles of the fetal brains from the experimental group are altered relative to the controls. Great. Now we can say, with slightly more confidence, “A fetus in a pregnant biological female human with only B. breve UCC2003 in their gut microbiome may exhibit altered brain metabolic profiles.” Did we need to euthanize 11 pregnant mice (at least) to determine this? I commend the authors on their reporting and transparency, but truly I do not understand this study. Clearly I am cynical from my time in academic biomedical research, so perhaps my perception of this study is biased. Happy to hear opposing opinions. [0] https://x.com/justsaysinmice https://x.com/justsaysinmice
- jncfhnb 2y agoWell perhaps you could try reading the paper and drawing from the author’s words about their intentions? It’s very clear. 1) a significant problem for humans is the placenta doesn’t grow enough which makes the babies not get enough nutrients 2) this specific genus of gut bacteria is supposed to become common in pregnant women And mice 3) they took pregnant mice that were specifically lacking this bacteria and tested if reintroducing it would have positive effects, and it did. 4) a couple direct quotes > Additionally, our approach could potentially align with supplementation studies in pregnant women, as we started the experiments after pregnancy was confirmed. > Our results have potential translational implications, as around 14% of pregnant women use probiotics during pregnancy in European countries like the Netherlands [ 62 ]. However, the utilization of probiotics in clinical and nutritional contexts, particularly during pregnancy, remains a topic of continual debate. Thus, to comprehensively understand their influence on the developing offspring, it is essential to define the mechanisms supporting their beneficial effects. Biomed academia is a shitshow but your effort here seems particularly bad faith and lame
- j_bum 2y agoWell, I read the intro, results, and methods prior to making my comment. Have you read the limitations? 1. & 2. Great. I agree. How does this research address those needs? 3. No, they didn’t. They took germ free mice without a gut microbiome and added probiotics with vs. without colonies of the supplemental bacteria. In my opinion, this bludgeons away translational value. They did no compositional analysis either via RNA seq, likely due to a lack of funding. 4. The authors can say lots about what their study could mean. Authors say lots of things all of the time. I, and anecdotally many others, put very little into author over-interpretation of data. The data can speak for themselves. Frankly I’m not sure how my critique of this research is bad faith. Lame? Maybe, I’m not to judge that. But I appreciate the discussion.
- flobosg 2y agoThe original press release: https://www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/mothers-gut-microbiome-during-pregnancy-shapes-babys-brain-development https://www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/mothers-gut-microbiome-d...
- interactivecode 2y agoWe need to know way more about our gut and bowel microbes. it's wild how little we actually understand outside of good gut health is good. It will take a lot of big and small research to slowly get reliable science and results.