3 ms·
SPOILER (Note that the article gives the answer, and discusses arriving at the answer. So go read it first.) Article opens with a puzzle. This is commenting
by Terretta 2y ago
SPOILER
(Note that the article gives the answer, and discusses arriving at the answer. So go read it first.)
Article opens with a puzzle. This is commenting on the article's explanation .. avoiding some words in the comment just so this spoiler doesn't spoil at a glance, you'd have to think about the following before reading:
Curiously, this article doesn't touch on an instantaneous and no-maths intuition about what can (or what cannot) come up as the set after all draws including your first. There are a finite set of possible sets in the container. One interesting set is ruled out by the first draw: there is a set it cannot be. With that set ruled out, you're at least (sets/(sets-1)) more likely the next draw isn't from the missing and interesting set that is intuitively known to you.
Further, if one did do this in the real world, it's intuitively evident that the missing set and its inverse would be more likely chosen for the container due to their interestingness. (The article alludes to this when it points out the sets are not coin flips, they are deliberately selected by a human.) That tips the odds even more in your intuition's favor of how the probabilities must balance.
So I'd argue this one is solvable by psychology as an alternative to math.
- lupire 2y agoYpur first argument is interstellar but doesn't help solving, because the set ruled out is exactly balanced (cancelled) by the first red ball being removed from al the other sets. The second paragraph just says that guesses can sometimes be right, which of course is true, but doesn't tell us which guesses are likely to be correct. Wha y you claim as intuitively obvious at all, and I think most people would avoid those sets. And it's not the same problem anyway, because in the problem the sets are chosen randomly according to a stated rule, not based on a personal bias.
- Terretta 2y agoExactly right, I'd missed: "number of red balls by picking a number between zero and 100 from a hat." Or, rather, when they talked about this being different from a coin flip, I misremembered that the set was a human choice.