9 ms·
Owners of 1-Time Passcode Theft Service Plead Guilty
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 2y agoThey should go after all of their customers too.
- 101008 2y agoAs the other comment said, they should go after all their customers too. I can't believe they are thefts out there paying other thefts for theft-services... Unrelated, but at the start of the year, a lot of Payoneer customers from Argentina lost their savings in the platform* due to someone having access to the OTP codes. Payoneer said it wasn't on their side the error, and evidence suggested that it was an error in Movistar, because all the victims were customers of that particular telco. As far as I know, Payoneer didn't return the money and Movistar was never charged or anything (rumours say it was a Movistar employee who sold SMS with the OTP). And if you ask why a lot of Argentina people use Payoneer and keep their savings there, it's a bit long to explain but basically is their way to get paid in USD outside the country without paying taxes (fair and unfair ones) and without getting their payments converted automatically to ARS pesos using a bad rate.
- ensignavenger 2y agoIf Payoneer was using sms based auth codes, then it was clearly Payoneers error for doing something so incredibly stupid.
- arresin 2y agoI think it's security by popularity: You can't be blamed if it's "industry standard". Meanwhile it's 10x less hassle than trying to get people to use an authenticator. Passkeys aren't perfect privacy wise (and everything google touches is suspect), but they are easy.
- chrisweekly 2y ago> "You can't be blamed if it's "industry standard". Thankfully, that's not true. Class action lawsuits can and do successfully target widespread industry malpractice. My first job out of college was as a paralegal, helping over 90 million American plaintiffs sue nearly every major life insurance company in the country for the previously common "standard behavior" of insurance agents convincing policyholders to periodically "roll over" their accounts, to the sole benefit of the agents and their employers. The settlement payout for each participant was typically meager -- but the malpractice was stopped.
- jollyllama 2y ago>Thankfully, that's not true. We'll see how much Crowdstrike pays out.
- pixl97 2y agoDirectly or indirectly?
- miki123211 2y agoNot only that, but mandatory authenticators would also create a support (and security) nightmare the moment you stepped out of the upper-middle-class, privileged tech worker world. They work great if you assume that everybody has a smartphone (as opposed to a feature phone), that they don't have their phones stolen every other month, that they know how to set up an authenticator app, that they'll remember to reconfigure everything properly when migrating to a new phone and won't immediately throw the old one away and so on. This problem is made even worse by the notoriously bad UX of most authenticator apps, notably the lack of automatic iCloud / Google Drive backup functionality and their inability to automatically show the code on screen whenever it's needed. The nice thing about SMS is that you can outsource most of the support burden to carriers, which have to handle it anyway. Carriers have the advantage that they usually speak the user's language, have an office relatively nearby, and can verify your government ID in person if need be.
- AStonesThrow 2y ago> If Payoneer was using sms based auth codes, then it was clearly Payoneers error for doing something so incredibly stupid. It's sort of ironic that the Krebs article indicates that these dudes were specifically targeting the "most secure" OTP methods we know: authentication apps, rather than SMS or email codes. They were simply using social engineering and human trust to bypass the industry's best technical practices. SMS and email are side-channel communications, so the attacker would need to intercept them, and hopefully suppress the legitimate receipt as well. I'd get kind of worried if my bank sent me an unsolicited code. But a consumer may be more credulous when their "bank" calls in to request one from them...
- deepsun 2y agoBank Of America accepts _only_ SMS codes, nothing else.
- jalk 2y agoThat is not correct. You can use a "USB security key" - e.g. YubiKey See https://www.bankofamerica.com/security-center/online-mobile-banking-privacy/usb-security-key/ https://www.bankofamerica.com/security-center/online-mobile-...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hiatus 2y agoChase, one of the biggest banks, still does not support anything beyond SMS/phone for 2fa.
- dgoldstein0 2y agothere's a whole underground economy. I recall hearing a story of how one guy was busted who used to build an exploit kit and sell it to people for a cut of their earnings. And then there's crazier shit like https://krebsonsecurity.com/2024/03/blackcat-ransomware-group-implodes-after-apparent-22m-ransom-payment-by-change-healthcare/ https://krebsonsecurity.com/2024/03/blackcat-ransomware-grou...
- janalsncm 2y agoThe craziest one I’ve heard of was the app Anom which was supposed to be for criminals to communicate securely and secretly. Except it wasn’t, it was actually controlled by the FBI. I’m part way through a book about it now and it’s pretty incredible how the FBI took it over and essentially became world police.
- earth-adventure 2y agoWhat's the books name?
- oo0shiny 2y agoJust listened to the Search Engine podcast episode [1] where the author talked about this story. It's wild. The author (Joseph Cox) is also a founder of 404 Media[2], which is a great tech blog. [1] https://www.searchengine.show/listen/search-engine-1/what-s-the-best-phone-to-do-crimes-on https://www.searchengine.show/listen/search-engine-1/what-s-... [2] https://www.404media.co/ https://www.404media.co/
- stavros 2y agoWow, if you can't trust extortionists, who can you trust?
- mananaysiempre 2y ago> I can't believe they are thefts out there paying other thefts for theft-services... Why wouldn’t there be? It’s not like an economy needs anything more than a medium of exchange and a kind-of-functional guarantee of nonviolence to arise. If you have that, you don’t need to arrange for a market, it will just happen, more or less. (Healthy or not is another question.) Anyway, yes, there’s phishing for hire, bring-your-own-payload exploitation for hire, ransomware for hire, and of course DDoS for hire. Captcha solving for hire is legitimate enough to occasionally get posted on HN (and I don’t think it shouldn’t be). People’s residential or mobile internet connections for hire, hijacked via free VPN browser extensions and mobile ad SDKs, are legitimate enough to be sold via advertising conglomerates (but I think they shouldn’t be). A market isn’t something you build, it’s something you have to actively prevent.
- miki123211 2y agoanother example of this phenomenon are "free" markets in prisons, where the currency is usually cigarettes. Other places where freedom is limited have similar characteristics, I remember that we had a sort of food market when I was a child at a boarding school.
- 0x3444ac53 2y agoFun fact, I had a family member in prison and apparently they used postal stamps as currency
- mananaysiempre 2y agoAs a side note, France has a thing called “fiscal stamps” (timbres fiscales) which I had to use to pay a ~60€ government fee of some sort. One time I did it I paid online and got an A4 thing I needed to print out, which, OK, sure. The other time I couldn’t do that for reasons I don’t remember and paid cash at a store to get one. What I got was a tiny thing that looks exatly like a small postage stamp of the standard almost-square shape (which is itself funny because all the actual French postage stamps I used were twice as large) except it cost the aforementioned ~60€. Needless to say, I was terrified I’d lose it the whole hour or so before I handed it over to a clerk. Wikipedia tells me this was a common approach once[1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revenue_stamp https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revenue_stamp
- wileydragonfly 2y agoI tried to set up a bank account in Argentina, and I will admit it was to buy cheap digital PC and Xbox game licenses. Incredibly hard to do so as a foreigner.
- dheera 2y agoMany other countries make it super easy for foreigners to get bank accounts. It's actually kind of a stupid economic policy to make it hard. If someone wants to store money in your country that's good for you.
- lazide 2y agoThe US does tend to crack down on US citizens doing it though, if they try to hide it from the IRS.
- csomar 2y ago> Many other countries make it super easy for foreigners to get bank accounts. This is false and I challenge you to name these countries. Also, not certain about your definition of "super easy". I interpret it as say "hi" to the teller, give my ID and get my bank account.
- dheera 2y agoIt's about that easy in China. (In addition to your ID you also need an +86 mobile number, which you can get in about 5 minutes by showing your ID at a China Mobile store.)
- csomar 2y agoAre we talking about a bank account or a digital wallet. Your experience is atypical: https://wise.com/en-cn/blog/how-to-open-a-bank-account-in-china-as-a-foreigner#what-requirements-do-i-need-to-open-a-bank-account-in-china https://wise.com/en-cn/blog/how-to-open-a-bank-account-in-ch... That being said, I read about them making it easier for foreigners to open digital wallets (though that still says nothing about real bank accounts). If you do know a bank/branch that supports opening for tourist foreigners with just an ID+Phone, my email is in my account page and I'd appreciate if you pass that info.
- jerf 2y ago"I can't believe they are thefts out there paying other thefts for theft-services..." Completely seriously, you and everyone else reading this need to not just "know" this, but believe it and feel it. Too often I feel like programmers are like fat 50-year-olds talking smack on the locker room about how doomed the other team is because they know the importance of MD5-hashing passwords in the database, and they have no idea they're going out on to the field against an NFL team. Of course, where this metaphor breaks down is that these metaphorical lardasses will not be able to fail to notice them getting their asses handed to them, whereas in the security space, their real-world analogs may not even notice they were hacked. It's brutal out there. Even the open source tooling is far more sophisticated that most people reading this realize, and that constitutes the baseline, not the top end. There's an underground economy, and it is sponsored by many entities with deep pockets, including large-scale criminal enterprises, some of which can rival "real" companies in scale, and government-backed operations of all sorts. You're not up against a stray hacker bumbling into your system. If you've got assets worth anything, you're up against professional organizations. If you are responsible for anything that matters, take the threats seriously.
- kurthr 2y agoAbsolutely, if there's a moderately anonymous way to get significant sums of money out of something, sophisticated attackers will spend significant effort and even % of funds to extract it. That includes bribery, phishing, spamming, as well as the usual hacking and cracking exploits. As you mention, the other issue is that this is often invisible (or even hidden by) to those who created the system that allowed the extraction.
- 14 2y ago“If you got assists worth anything…” well finally I am in a positive position for being monetarily poor. The other great thing about being poor is I had to learn to be a backyard mechanic to fix my own broke down cars.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- fsckboy 2y ago
- Terr_ 2y ago> I can't believe they are thefts out there paying other thefts for theft-services... You might enjoy "Lying for Money: How Legendary Frauds Reveal the Workings of the World", which talks a bit about frauds as existing as a parasitic economy with its own parasites, etc.
- pixl97 2y agoI was in a call today showing scams around the world and it's insane how out in the open some of these scams are. One was showing products advertised on FB at an extremely cheap price. You think you're buying a widget but instead deep in the language you're buying a weekly service that shoots up to $100 a week. If you call to complain against the company you bought from, they tell you they won't cancel as you signed a contract. In this particular case the security researcher reached out FB (privately, reporting it did not work) and showed the vast web of accounts buying ads and promoting it, which were soon banned.
- xp84 2y agoIt’s frustrating to me how broken the (automated?) moderation system is on Facebook (though for all I know every other social media is as bad, Facebook just gives more transparency as to what happens after a report). You see tons of messages of just random new accounts, posting to strangers commenting on like a meme post, saying “I love your posts, I’d like to get to know you better, dm me on telegram…” or “I have earned $123,456 in 4 days thanks to the crypto genius Steve Bob [link to other fake profile]” - reporting them usually results in a “we didn’t take down the content” result. Any human knows this is pure fraud.
- lynx23 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thieves%27_guild https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thieves%27_guild :-)
- cynicalsecurity 2y agoThree young peope of age 19, 21 and 22. I was wondering who would do something as stupid as this and think they can get away with it in UK.
- popcalc 2y agoThey forgot to give the MPs their slice
- michaelt 2y agoA person could easily get the impression the UK didn't police crime online, simply because crimes like DDOS attacks, cryptolockers, cryptocurrency scams, identity theft, fake tech support callers and suchlike are all typically cross-border crimes where the police have basically no powers. The reality is the police are more than happy to act when the criminals involved can be identified, and are under their jurisdiction, and you can get the attention of the right department - that's just a very rare set of circumstances.
- Lio 2y agoThe UK police do have powers though, accessing computer systems without permission or committing fraud is a crime in the UK regardless of geographic location under the Computer Misuse Act 1990. The Act explicitly mentions prosecution of offences committed abroad. https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1990/18/contents https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1990/18/contents
- A4ET8a8uTh0 2y agoI am trying to think on how this could be mitigated and I am not sure there is a good way. Just before we even begin, using an unknown third party is a risk and companies have no problem using whatever providers. Just dropping OTP is not exactly ideal either so we are stuck between rock and a hard place.
- vaylian 2y agoTOTP is a simple and nice solution, but it is susceptible to real-time phishing attacks. Webauthn is a more complex alternative and it is phishing-resistant, because each credential is tied to a domain, which means that a look-alike phishing website doesn't work. But you need to use a hardware token or a special service like Windows Hello or Apple's FaceID to manage your credentials. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WebAuthn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WebAuthn
- lxgr 2y agoSeveral password managers support it at this point too, without any hardware requirements. Bitwarden's implementation works pretty well, for example.
- bigfatkitten 2y agoBut then of course you also lose one of the main security properties that made webauthn desirable in the first place. If you can copy the credentials to your own new device, an adversary can copy them to their device also.
- wongarsu 2y agoThat's true of SMS 2FA too, though, as well as many TOTP implementations. Being able to copy credentials to a new device is a major usability plus, consequently it is widely implemented. Physical webauthn tokens are obviously better, but software webauthn is the second best thing. Software TOTP is a good bit worse, and SMS OTP shouldn't even qualify as a secure method
- 2Gkashmiri 2y agoUh...how did this work ? Did they guess the key?
- yieldcrv 2y agoHackers had the banking customer’s login and phone number. When they would log in to the bank, the service otp.agency would robocall the customer saying that someone was fraudulently accessing their account which was insidiously true, but then the resolution was false, the service would ask them to enter their one time passcode that was texted to them by the actual bank. This is funny because sms could already be intercepted vis SS7 and is inherently insecure for one time passcodes that banks swear by, but this service wasn't doing that.
- alias_neo 2y agoThe funny thing is; most banks hat I've experienced will plaster warnings all over the SMS and apps not to give this information to someone who calls you etc. The issue is that people are afraid (to lose their money) and aren't educated about the risks, and who/what they should pay attention to, so they hand it over anyway. People need to learn to fail shut.
- yieldcrv 2y agoI think it works because banks have nonsensical security already Even if you are educated, you’re still confronted with insecure security measures and stonewalled by the customer service agent that’s asking you to complete a measure, until you complete it Getting a call with another nonsensical security measure would be onbrand
- alias_neo 2y agoLike when _they_ call you, and ask you to confirm who you are? Uh, how about you confirm who I am after you confirm who _YOU_ are?!
- 2y ago
- throwaway2037 2y agoWhy does the blog post show their photographs? That seems unnecessary to me.
- edent 2y agoBecause they are convicted criminals. This isn't a case of showing photographs of suspects. They've all pled guilty. Showing their faces accomplishes three main things. 1. It disambiguates them from people who share their names. You can now see that it isn't the Callum Picari you went to school with. 2. It acts as a warning to the community. You may have been a victim of these people, but not known their names. Seeing a photo might jog your memory and enable you to report further crimes. 3. It is a disincentive. If you are planning on committing a crime, you will know that your face will be in the media if caught.
- alias_neo 2y agoNothing unnecessary about putting scumbags on blast.
- immibis 2y agoUntil it's you and it's a false conviction.
- bhargav 2y agoThey are convicts
- enneff 2y agoI think having your face shown is the least of your worries if you’re convicted of a crime like this.
- pixl97 2y agoFalse convictions are a completely different problem. Now, this is a good reason not to show suspects that are not found guilty, but once found guilty that's a different story. Hence, if you're found guilty and it's false, you need an exoneration.
- EnigmaFlare 2y agoSchools really need to teach kids not to trust the identity of anyone who initiates contact them unless they can physically see them in person and already know them personally. If the general population had this skill ingrained in them, all phishing scams would poof away into uselessness.
- akira2501 2y agoSecond level of confidence scam is "Fake credentials." You wouldn't gain much.
- EnigmaFlare 2y agoCan you explain how that works and how this general phishing protection concept wouldn't help?
- bradleyjg 2y agoIn person scams don’t scale. That’s much better.
- pixl97 2y agoI mean, in person pyramid scams are pretty popular.
- EnigmaFlare 2y agoThat's less of a scam and more of a personal responsibility problem. Like gambling, it doesn't necessarily involve any dishonesty, just encouraging you to imagine you'll sign up a lot of members or sell a lot of product. Further into the less-scammy direction is you buy a toy for your kid but he doesn't like playing with it. Were you scammed into buying a useless product? In a way, yes, but also there has to be some point where people are allowed the freedom to make their own mistakes.
- bradleyjg 2y agoHow do you think the total dollars and rate of change compares for of in person pyramid schemes and online scams?
- lnxg33k1 2y agoI think the guy who stole my phone used one of these services, a couple of days later I received a notification with a temp code and then a url where to enter it, as I had to confirm that the phone was mine since it was found