3 ms·
The article seems to just be a call to change how society views depression. But is there any science here? The premise that depression is not a deviation from n
by rayiner 2y ago
The article seems to just be a call to change how society views depression. But is there any science here? The premise that depression is not a deviation from normal functioning, but rather a biologically rooted response could be applied to any behavior. Indeed, it can be applied to the societal opprobrium towards depressed people, which exists across cultures. Maybe that’s just a biologically rooted response that protects society at large? That’s equally plausible if you posit that just because a psychological phenomenon exists it must serve some function.
- tim333 2y agoIt does seem pretty light on science. There's maybe a better discussion on it from a "Trying to Save Us" perspective on Wikipedia under "Evolutionary approaches to depression".
- morbicer 2y agoThere is no science in psychology, period. By nature of dealing with humans you can't really run thorough experiments like on rats. On top of of that, psychology is mired with quackery, big egos and partisanship (nature vs nurture, CBBT vs psychoanalysis, humanistic vs psychodynamic, approach to DSM,..) I totally believe in good psychologists that can help you, I just don't believe there's much rigor and objectivity. https://www.theguardian.com/science/2015/aug/27/study-delivers-bleak-verdict-on-validity-of-psychology-experiment-results https://www.theguardian.com/science/2015/aug/27/study-delive...
- acchow 2y agoYou are unfairly being downvoted. The reproducibility project attempted to reproduce the results of 97 experiments in psychology that originally had "statistically significant" results and was only able to find 37 with statistically significant results during replication. That is not to say that psychology is not helpful - it can help a great deal. But we need to stop pretending it is "science".
- jononor 2y agoStopping to consider it a science means giving up. Instead we should improve the scientific level of the field, including (but not limited to) reproducibility.
- hollerith 2y agoI didn't get that: I took it to be an outline of a line of research on how better to help depressed people.