5 ms·
Andrew Gelman: Is marriage associated with happiness for men or for women?
- toddmorey 2y agoI think we should ask ourselves what we hope to find in (or do with) statistical happiness scores across interpersonal relationships. Especially at such a superficial "men vs women" level. Do we have good data that one demographic is disadvantaged and we trying build a case for societal change in or laws, norms, and customs to correct the imbalance? Awesome! Are we trying to justify, defend, or promote one decision (marry, stay single, cohabitate) over another? In that case, I say ignore the noise. If you've met one married couple... you've met one married couple. How you'll do in your relationship depends on two things surveys can't answer: you and your partner.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoEven before reading the article, the inability to quantify happiness led me to assume the result will be garbage in, garbage out, which seems to be the conclusion. And there’s also the huge confounding variable that people with good financial trajectories are likelier to get married, and it’s been that way for many years.
- toddmorey 2y agoYes, these sorts of "studies" that draw insane headline conclusions from horrible data really make me embarrassed to see social science together as a word pairing.
- AStonesThrow 2y agoThe goal of the state (and the church) in promoting and supporting good marriages has historically and traditionally been to foster stable societies, strong homes, and obviously, population growth and replacement for the aging, infirm and dying. A society that encourages folks to marry, and to bear children, is a well-functioning society with a bright future. So what happens when marriage is no longer oriented toward child-bearing, marriage is ephemeral and easy to escape, and an increasing number of married people can't even physically conceive children? What happens when children can't count on a mother and father being at home for them, even before their adulthood? What happens when a child reaches maturity without any marriage prospect but must definitely become self-sufficient and enter the workforce, regardless of their sex or abilities, because there's no supportive family structure and they don't even know how to raise a child? What happens when men and women find they've reached adulthood without acquiring skills to run a household, cook and clean and do chores, and it's futile to support a spouse or depend on one, because they'll be divorcing you soon anyway, children or not?
- toomuchtodo 2y ago“Well functioning” for whom? The purpose of the system is what it does. If people are not happy in an entrenched system, it is clearly within their interest to find ways and means to escape said system. Society has proven it wishes to optimize for metrics somewhat orthogonal to those of the individual, so operate accordingly (treating society adversarially; aggressively affirming reproductive freedoms and the ability to support one’s self without a partner or org driven by a belief system). (Religions are cults to attempt to enforce conformity and monogamy, while producing as many kids as possible; capitalism ran with this to extract from the cattle in the name of aggregate productivity; it has now started to fall apart with women robustly empowered; 43% of first marriages fail, so avoiding marriage is simply prudent risk management; 64% of young women say they just don't want children, compared to 50% of men) https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2024/07/25/the-experiences-of-u-s-adults-who-dont-have-children/ https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2024/07/25/the-exp... https://www.axios.com/2024/07/25/adults-no-children-why-pew-data https://www.axios.com/2024/07/25/adults-no-children-why-pew-... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41245199 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41245199 https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/article/2024/sep/02/jd-vance-childless-women-kamala-harris https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/article/2024/sep/0... https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/why-bad-looks-good/202102/why-so-many-single-women-without-children-are-happy https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/why-bad-looks-good/2... https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate#what-explains-the-declining-fertility-rate https://ourworldindata.org/fertility-rate#what-explains-the-...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- AStonesThrow 2y agoIf a 43% failure rate is an unacceptable risk, and ceasing attempts is preferable to failing a second time, what does that say about taking tests in school, filling out job applications, scientific research and advancements, or compiling that code your boss told you to write?
- 2y ago
- sameoldtune 2y agoThis happens all the time. People take statistical data about a population and then try to apply it to individual members of that population. If 30% of men are less happy in a marriage, that doesn’t mean you’ll be 30% less happy or even that you will have a 30% chance of being less happy. Because you are not an “average man” (no one is).
- AStonesThrow 2y agoFatally flawed methodology and metrics. What is "happiness"? Did the survey define it or attempt to measure it, or just rely on subjective attestations? Is happiness really a goal of marriage? I mean, "happily married" is certainly a common phrase, and at least someone who's "happily married" isn't party to abuse, neglect, infidelity, we hope. But is "happiness" the goal? What about enjoyment of companionship (joy and pleasure are less based in emotion than concrete experience, and less subjective) and what about stability, security, and indeed the other things mentioned there, such as wealth, longevity, and good children -- are those a recipe for the elusive "happiness"? Our Constitution guarantees the right to the "pursuit of happiness", yet can't guarantee happiness itself. Is the pursuit easier, more enjoyable, more fulfilling than happiness itself? Happiness can be a fleeting emotion. I'd prefer joy and contentment, freedom from suffering, a secure future, instead of the nebulous "happiness", and I'd rather attest to those in a survey than say, I guess I'm happy for now. Furthermore, how shall we measure the impact of marriage on happiness? We can't exactly do A/B tests with the same subjects. You can't be married and not married at the same time and place. So did marriage increase their happiness, or was it due to aging, experience, childbearing, home ownership? Can science isolate marriage and measure its effects in a vacuum? Can science dissect a marriage to find out how a good one works? Should science work to develop something better than marriage, that's guaranteed to increase happiness or double your money back?
- spankalee 2y agoWhat methodology? The article references a lot of studies. Which are you referring to?
- AStonesThrow 2y agoAsking subjects to self-evaluate and define "happiness" for their own purposes? What is the value of having test subjects self-report on an ephemeral emotion? Is this an empirical scientific method, or a marketing campaign?
- Qem 2y agoI'd like to see a study about this, but age-adjusted. I think marriage pays mainly in the long term. It's easier to report you're better single when you still young, healthy, and socializes a lot outside immediate family. As one ages, the balance probably changes. In the extreme case you risk becoming one of these: https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwyx6wwp5d5o https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwyx6wwp5d5o I wonder if any differences found by sex are due to age, as it seems men tend to marry older than women, on average.
- TheEzEzz 2y agoI could easily see this going the other way. Life long single people develop strong social networks that they keep investing in into old age. Married (and with children especially!) couples invest less time in their social network, in old age they then have many fewer friends when their children leave and their spouse passes. (I'm not sure this is true or not, but seems plausible. I agree with the author that we should get better data to resolve these questions).
- AStonesThrow 2y agoMarriage is sort of like adoption because you're given a new family. It's different from adoption because you get to keep your existing family. Successful married couples are investing in an internal social network: offspring and extended family. If this network can meet their needs then they have less reason to go outside of it. Childbearing families are going to encounter other parents and their social network will change accordingly. Play dates, day care, school parents and extracurricular groups will be in their orbit now. Conversely, single people may rely on their own families for social support, and they may not need to go outside of that, either. Woe betide the single person whose family is unsupportive, because friends and acquaintances are a faint substitute. Such a person could develop ties with their employer, professional orgs, non-profits and community to stay sane and healthy. Or they don't--there are plenty of dysfunctional singles who don't need a marriage in order to suffer and fail at life.
- AtlasBarfed 2y agoWhat I got out of this is that this is a very understudied area considering it's hotly debated by everybody and influences a vast section of the population. Data also appears weak for cohabitation versus marriage, although there is some, and I don't see a distinction in data between one of the key things with children and without which is a whole different ball game. The characterization of marriage as a prison for the male is likely tied to marriage being aspect of monogamy and the outlawing of polygamy in our society. Dating app data has shown that women will throw themselves at the top 10% of males. Marriage being an institution that curiously benefits the non-elite of men who would otherwise engage in polygamist marriages to match their often multiple dating partner lifestyle in single life. It's not because of some great sympathy towards "loser" males that marriage exists: it's for societal stability and for the ye children.
- joemazerino 2y agoInvestigate deeper regarding religious marriages vs nonreligious and you will find a vast disparity of contentment leaning towards religious married couples.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mensetmanusman 2y agoWe do know boys struggle more from unstable families. Nearly 90% of the homeless and prison population(when accounting for at-home absenteeism) experienced a high degree of absent fathers. https://olis.oregonlegislature.gov/liz/2019R1/Downloads/CommitteeMeetingDocument/169072 https://olis.oregonlegislature.gov/liz/2019R1/Downloads/Comm...
- jameshart 2y agoThis whole write up seems to fall into the ‘average man’ fallacy, where it is trying to look at the average rate of happiness of men and women in marriages to determine if marriage is on average a good or bad thing. This seems fatally flawed, because there’s no such thing as an average marriage. There will exist all four of these kinds of (heterosexual) marriage: those where both people are happy, those where neither is happy, those where only the man is happy, and those where only the woman is happy. The distribution is far more interesting than the ‘average’ happiness across all these discrete cases.
- danenania 2y agoFrom a quoted article in this piece[1]: > unmarried and childless women are the happiest subgroup in the population Isn't this kind of scary from a sociological and demographic perspective? It would seem to indicate that we've built a socioeconomic system with self-terminating incentives. I consider myself very liberal/libertarian and individualist vs. collectivist, and I have a daughter, so I'm (angrily) unsympathetic to ideas that even hint at restricting women's freedom on this basis. I'd easily prefer the gradual dissolution of western civilization to my daughter being trapped in an abusive marriage with no right to divorce, being forced to give birth to a child she doesn't want, and so on. However, all that aside, it does seem like a serious bug in our system. I wonder how we can we flip this statistic without restricting anyone's freedom? 1 - https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/may/25/women-happier-without-children-or-a-spouse-happiness-expert https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2019/may/25/women-h...
- ninkendo 2y agoIt’ll probably solve itself, if there’s any genetic component to the desire for childrearing. If all women have complete choice in the matter, then only the women who do want children will actually pass their genes onto the next generation, and it won’t take very long for the other alleles to be extinct.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoWhat evidence is there that alleles are causing women to not want children? I would guess watching a video and learning about the effects and risks of pregnancy/childbirth/breastfeeding/infant rearing is capable of convincing someone to not want children.
- ninkendo 2y agoNo idea, I’m just guessing. But I don’t think the number of people who want children after learning about the details is zero, right? There’s still a healthy contingent of the population who see all that and say “yeah but I still want children”. And I don’t think it’s a huge stretch to assume that desire is driven by genetics… especially because childrearing is so costly and difficult, there’s gotta be some explanation for why people keep doing it, and I don’t think it’s because every woman in history has just had it forced on her non-consensually. Another way of thinking about: the desire to reproduce (and ensure your offspring survive enough to reproduce) is one of the most basic and important things a genome can code for, and we have billions of years of evolution ensuring that we keep wanting to do it. I don’t think it’s as simple as people just wanting to have sex… the desire for childrearing is a lot more robust than any one thing, or anything you can thwart by just showing someone a video of childbirth. Sure, there are some women who would see the negative sides and decide it’s not for them, but they’re selecting themselves out of future gene pools by doing this, so the system will rapidly reach equilibrium again.
- aaron695 2y ago[dead]
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoI'm surprised that none of the studies mentioned in this article (and there were a lot) talk about potential differences by age. I think this is pretty critically important for 2 main reasons: 1. People want different things at different stages of life, and a situation that could be a boon at one stage could be a burden at another. E.g. one hypothesis is that raising kids by a married couple can be exhausting and stressful while single people are going out and having fun, but then once those kids are out of the nest that the married couple is more fulfilled and happy than their single counterparts. Obviously that's a somewhat stereotypical hypothesis - my only point is that life stage matters, and it's possible that married couples may be happier than singles at some life stages but not at others. 2. Age matters because societal attitudes have changed over time. My parents grew up in an era where the expectation was that everyone got married, and if you didn't, something was "wrong" with you. So it's possible that single people from older cohorts really are outliers compared to their peers. As times have changed, societal attitudes have allowed being long-term single to be more of a choice, and especially in countries like Sweden you see marriage as no longer being the "default" option.
- LorenPechtel 2y agoSuch a study is inherently observational and very well might be looking at a confounder. Do people who X do better at Y? Or do people who *can* do X do better at Y? Are married people happier, or are some people who were dealt bad hands in life both unhappy and unable to find someone that would marry them? An awful lot of longevity-related stuff appears to be of this sort.