3 ms·
I really dislike these non-sequitur arguments of "LLMs do not reason, because <detail on how they work>", as if a detail on how they work unequivocally proves t
by stavros 2y ago
I really dislike these non-sequitur arguments of "LLMs do not reason, because <detail on how they work>", as if a detail on how they work unequivocally proves the impossibility of reasoning.
- quantadev 2y agoI've noticed that on HackerNews about 80% of all debates or discussions where people disagree, boils down to a disagreement about the definition of a word.
- theknocker 2y ago[dead]
- fedeb95 2y agofeel free to extend to other contexts. It was basically Socrates' argument.
- throwawaytemp29 2y agoThat is certainly true, for some definition of 80%.
- slashdave 2y agoI see. Well, I claim my pet rock can think. What do you mean it doesn't have brain cells, what kind of argument is that?
- fragmede 2y agoMy pet silicon rock was processed by TSMC in a design by Nvidia, and does this trick called inference that very much does look like thinking. Who made yours?
- Y_Y 2y agoI deem your rock to be disqualified on the basis of its performance clearly having been enhanced by doping.
- Quiark 2y ago"This alien super-computer made from entangled iron atoms clearly is not thinking because it doesn't have neurons" you mean like this?
- desumeku 2y agoChatGPT - Our very own alien super-computer!