8 ms·
Show HN: The Bastards Book of Photography
- hopeless 14y agoAs an introduction, I like it. It's reasonably non-technical and generally errs on the right side of practicality vs theory
- thenomad 14y agoI've just started reading this, and it appears to be excellent. Thank you. Is there a way within the site to give you some kind of renumeration (monetary or otherwise) for all the effort you've put in?
- danso 14y agoWell don't get out the wallet yet, the later chapters were hastily produced as I kept rethinking how things should be presented... :) But thank you...that's extremely kind of you...I had thought it could be a side platform to sell prints but haven't gotten around to implementing that. At this point, I don't feel like it merits payment yet or that I've gotten nothing out of it, it's been a great learning lesson for me as I'd never really used Jekyll or SaSS before, and all of the photos were lying around anyway.
- iuguy 14y agoThis is brilliant. Far better and more accessible than most photography books I've seen.
- johnx123-up 14y agoGood work. Would love a kindle version.
- DannoHung 14y agoPretty nice for beginners! I'd put more mundane shots in (like in the fourth chapter) so that people don't get discouraged because they don't have the eye for finding good subjects yet.
- danso 14y agoThat's a great point...my inclination was to do "interesting" photos even if they were mundane (most of them were taken during walks or sites that I frequent)...but I think taking photos in new York gives you a huge advantage over most other plans, and that's not really fair of me to exploit that so much
- lusr 14y agoI've seen some of Dan's great photos before and it's awesome to be able to learn from him. Some of the advice he gives are things I've learned myself and explained to people before, and much of it is also new so I'm pretty excited to get through this properly. One thing I would add, having been through this before myself and seeing my girlfriend going through it now as she takes up photography, is dealing with how people respond to your photos. It can be disheartening when you take what you think is a great shot and nobody else (on Facebook, reddit/r/itookapicture, Flickr, etc.) seems to be interested. These feelings can be exaggerated when you see the photo that everybody is talking about is a simple cat photo or of some exotic location or event you're unlikely to find yourself in. It's important not to allow yourself to feel discouraged.You have to just stick to your hobby for the original reason you picked up the camera in the first place and not to allow yourself to side-tracked by a lack of validation. It's important to seek out the opportunities leading to photos that you treasure and to remember that if others also enjoy your output that's a bonus, but not a healthy goal. I'm not sure if Dan has experienced this (he may not have been concerned by what others think), but I believe it could be greatly beneficial to bring this mindset to the attention of readers so that if they find themselves feeling discouraged that they are aware of what's going on and how to deal with it constructively.
- danso 14y agoThat's a great point...I don't really know what the best mindset to have is. I've benefited from being in the photojournalistic mindset so that, if anything, photos serve a purpose, such as illustrating a news event. That alone can make it "good" (as many Pulitzer/World Press photos may seem average in the technical department). More importantly, I think having this sensibility makes you think of an audience, not just what you think is aesthetically appealing. So I definitely do care what others think. But I think I lucked out by getting enough validation to get past the apathy. At least I've realized it's not just skill or technical merit in terms of getting noticed: much of it is just plain luck. On a sidenote, participating in photosharing across Flickr and Tumblr has really helped destroy any solipsism I might have had...If attention/validation is something you care about, you have to work to get it like any other of the anonymous people on the Internet. This is not a mindset that most journalists realize when they try striking it on their own, without a masthead to tie their name to.
- aw3c2 14y agowebsite feedback: The text is way too big for me and the centered layout could use some differentiation of "content pane" to "left and right emptiness". The photos are huge too and somehow make me completely lose place and orientation. I have no idea how to fix it though. It could work on wide screens (would work on 1680x1050 already) if you placed images and text side by side.
- danso 14y agoThanks, that's helpful to know and something I had been concerned about... My challenge has been that I want to keep the paragraphs of text short, which makes it difficult to place floating-elements since there isn't much text to float them against. The images I've wanted to keep large. I like the aesthetic of the Big Picture type of blogs, but you may still be right that it's not appropriate for what's supposed to be a learning guide.
- aw3c2 14y agoMaybe decide for one or two images per "small thing" you want to explain and move the text really close to it, eg in the box below? Right now the scrolling is so much.
- dugmartin 14y agoMore feedback - you have a utf-8 encoding problem in the first paragraph within "for learning your camera’s manual controls". It looks like the single quote was encoded by Word and doesn't translate to utf-8 - I see it as an accented "i". Just replace the ’ with ’ in the html.
- danso 14y agoThanks! I'll check it out
- cocoflunchy 14y agoGood to see a book about something else than programming! Be careful about night shots of the Eiffel tower though: there are some copyright issues. See http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eiffel_Tower http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eiffel_Tower for more info.
- danso 14y agoThanks, I had that in the back of mind but not when I was putting this together: (tl:dr the lighting apparatus of the Eiffel Tower, not the Tower itself, has been upheld as a copyrightable image by France's highest court)
- lemming 14y agoThis looks great! I also liked Bernie Sumption's guides: http://berniesumption.com/photography/beginners-guide-for-geeks/ http://berniesumption.com/photography/beginners-guide-for-ge... http://berniesumption.com/photography/depth-of-field-for-geeks/ http://berniesumption.com/photography/depth-of-field-for-gee...
- danso 14y agoYeah, he was the first person I thought to link to in my resources section. I don't remember when I first bookmarked him...at least 3 to 4 years ago, but I still refer to it from time to time, and pass it along to all other beginners.
- tomazstolfa 14y agoGreat!
- lickerswill 14y agoWell f*#kn done. I'm a photog and I get a lot of questions. I will definitely point people to this awesome resource. Kudos.
- dr42 14y agoAs someone with 25 years of photography, I cannot recommend this "book". Starting with the very first photo, a typical photojournalist shot, super wide angle shooting into the sun photo. This just continues into the book with cliched subjects (sunsets, cats) and advice like "take lots of photos" The section in aperture starts out with a photo that's hard to look at its so badly exposed. The section on metering is just plain wrong, true only for spot metering, which most of the people who read this beginners guide are not going to be using. For the people it actually targets its misleading to talk about which spot the camera is metering on. There are many many better books than this which will give beginners a grounding in the mechanics of photography.
- hk_kh 14y agoIf you know of better books it would be a nice idea to put them on your comment (bashing is good, but giving alternatives is better). For instance, I dived in the technical basics of my old SLR with this book I found at my parent's house: Photography - the guide to technique by Andrew Hawkins, Dennis Avon [1]. This is probably an outdated and now useless guide, but answered me many questions I had when I started. [1] http://www.amazon.co.uk/Photography-Guide-Technique-Andrew-Hawkins/dp/071370909X http://www.amazon.co.uk/Photography-Guide-Technique-Andrew-H...
- dr42 14y agoI deliberately avoided suggesting alternatives because I think the best advice for a beginner is to stop with all the pretentious 'arty' photo techniques and take snapshots. But, if pressed, I would suggest this book. http://www.amazon.com/Photography-Very-Short-Introduction-Introductions/dp/0192801643 http://www.amazon.com/Photography-Very-Short-Introduction-In... Most colleges have continuing education classes in photography. Stanford for example, I know does.
- danso 14y agoHeh, I think it's funny you and I are in disagreement...I see myself as being on the opposite end of the "artsy" spectrum since that wasn't highly valued at the newspaper. Obviously, photos I take on my own are loosened up but I lean towards realism. Not using a flash is a deliberate decision to preserve as much of the lighting in a dark scene, even at the risk of underexposure or excess ambient light from a slow shutter speed. Anyway, the book you recommend is not a bad one, but on a brief skim, it's more about the history and place of photography than snapshot technique. I don't disagree that that has worth, it's just not what I'm aiming for in my admittedly brief guide.
- pooriaazimi 14y agoI'm no photographer, but enjoyed these stunning photos nevertheless and shared this link with some friends. One thing I noticed though (and as you posted it on HN, I think it's not nitpicking for pointing it out): why are you hijacking mouse clicks?! I really, really hate it when I command-click (open in a new tab) on a link, and the site decides that, no, you really should view the content in the same tab...
- danso 14y agoOoh, hadn't thoughht of that. You must be talking about the table of contents, in which I use some quick JS to listen for clicks on the box to call a load actions with _self as the target. I didn't even think that would effect those who explicitly do new tabs. (if you meant for ulterior purposes, no...I don't even explicitly load in jquery, hence the sloppy inline JS)
- calinet6 14y agoI just read the article, "Why even buy a camera?" because it's a subject near and dear to my heart, one I've debated with many photographer friends. Many insist that you should learn on a camera with manual controls, and some insist that it's all in the light and any camera will do. You handled this question perfectly. Not even kidding. Down to every finer point of debate, you nailed the balance and gave the best, most helpful possible answers, including visual backup to express the true differences. Absolutely fantastic. I'll be sharing this with other photographer friends and those interested in learning more. Great work. Thanks for posting.
- danso 14y agoThanks...I honestly question how much reliable advice I could give, as I've arguably overspent, even as I'm not caught up in the arms race. Someone did point out that iOS has special apps that do allow shutter speed control, so I'll have to come up with a few other different usecases.
- calinet6 14y agoCertainly, but the point is still very good and balanced either way. Good advice. My example comes from using a point-and-shoot pocket camera, not my phone. Very little control over shutter speed and aperture and such, but I've used it with great success for landscapes in good-to-low light. I've probably sold more prints from the P&S than my SLR, all because I had it in my pocket when the light was right.
- rimantas 14y ago> and some insist that it's all in the light and any camera > will do. This is really simple: given favourable conditions pretty much any camera will give you decent results. The point of having decent camere is that it expands the boundaries of "favourable conditions" immensely.
- statictype 14y agoGreat work. Do you have any plans on releasing this as a nicely packaged ebook? I'd probably pay for that instead of having to individually instapaper each page.
- danso 14y agoThanks...not at this point...one of my main motivations was to get used to doing things with Jekyll/octopress and markdown,mso I haven't figured out the workflow from that to other formats. But I guess this would be a great chance to try that out. If I were to ever charge, I'd rather it be for a print book, but who knows
- aeturnum 14y agoWhy list the EV adjustment of the photos? The effective EV is apparent from the capture settings and listing how much you adjusted the photo based on your camera's meter isn't that useful. Each camera meter has its own quirks and it seems strange to include such a subjective setting. On the other hand, I dig that you include lens and focal length. Both are nice to know when viewing photos.
- Lio 14y agoI would guess that the author is trying to show when they've deliberately overruled the cameras exposures settings. So in the section on under exposure the exposure compensation gives an idea by how much the image was under exposed. Which IMHO is useful to know.
- danso 14y agoYeah...that was what I was going for but the parent comment has a point, one which I did t really think about until I started collecting photos and noticing that some of the photos didn't match expected EV...I had thought that the EV reflected what the camera registered, no matter what mode I was in...but of course, it only measures compensation, which will be wrong if the photo is taken and the EV doesn't match the EC. And since I've just confused myself trying to explain this I doubt it's clear to the average reader. It would be pretty easy to generate histiograms with Imagemagick...that is probably more useful
- rorrr 14y agoWARNING: negative feedback ahead. Disclaimer: I'm a pro photographer (as in I get paid for taking photos), and I had a few exhibitions. A few important points, if you want to become a good photographer: 1) My philosophy with most art teachers/book writers is - unless your art makes me say "wow", you can't teach me much. There are many truly great photographers out there. Dan Nguyen is not one of them. I look at his photos, and most of them are properly exposed, somewhat properly framed, sometimes they have something interesting, but most of the time they are mind-numbingly boring and mediocre. 2) His idea of posting technical details next to a photo is not new, but, most importantly, it's completely useless. I remember when I just got into photography, I was looking at all the cool photos and I really wanted to know the f-stop, the exposure, the ISO that the author used. It took me about a year to figure out it didn't matter. Main reason being - you will never encounter that exact scene with that exact lighting. Even if you magically come to that same exact spot, same time, same date of the year, magically frame the shot the same way, set all the exact settings, you will NOT end up with the same picture. 3) Photography is art - don't be a fucking robot. Play with the camera settings, they are really trivial. It shouldn't take you more than a day to figure out how aperture, exposure and ISO work. 4) Trying to replicate some cool photo online is a good learning technique, but you don't simply do it by replicating the camera settings. 5) Now the most important point of learning how to photograph well: STOP READING TECHNICAL GARBAGE. Sites like dpreview are full of "photographers" who endlessly discuss their gear, their camera settings, and then you look at their photographs, and they are fucking boring and lack any taste (just to be fair, there are good photographers on dpreview). Stop it, and look at photos instead. You should look at hundreds of photos a day, that's the only way to develop your photographic taste. And try not to get stuck on user-submitted websites like photo.net or flickr, there's a ton of crap there. Instead seek the best photographers in whatever area interests you - street, portraiture, landscape, etc. Go to your local store and look at the photo books (not the technical ones, art ones). You will be pleasantly surprised with the quality of photos.
- keithpeter 14y agoI agree with looking at photographs, especially curated collections (published books, exhibitions). "It shouldn't take you more than a day to figure out how aperture, exposure and ISO work." I disagree with this from the perspective of teaching this stuff to teenagers (some decades ago now I admit). Probably easier with digital cameras.
- mkanemoto 14y agoI really enjoy "the Bastards Book of Photography". There are a few reasons: 1) The sequence feels right. Everyone can start with photography, you don't need the fancy equipment, and you can start with what you have. 2) The text starts people on the road to manual settings, i.e. learning the camera. The mechanics are not what photography as art is all about, that's composition and creativity. But, without practice and understanding the mechanics until they are second nature it's very hard to realize your composition and vision efficiently. 3) This is a starting point with some help to novices. If this helps someone take a slightly better vacation or family photograph, great. The text straight off the about page sums it up. There are concerns: 1) "Wow" is what teaches? There seem to be two major paths to learning from experts: If they are dead there are books. Review: The Camera, The Negative, and The Print by Ansel Adams. Highly technical from a master who had a nervous breakdown after putting everything into his art to for a showing. Still not a great starting point for the novice. They are fantastic books for someone who's more advanced and ready to get into the minutia. This is contrary to the message that people should just go look at compositions and dive in. Expert workshops: If wow is what teaches, than there are many expert photographers who conduct workshops. For the majority of novice to curious photographers my advice has always been to save the money and go out with a photo club or some photo friends. None of the people in these clubs are probably "wow" experts, but it's a bit like learning a sport by matching up with someone of equal skill rather than paying to be taught by a pro before you know what you are getting into. 2) Technical Details: These are common practice. The body of the site directs people to learn their own settings and exposure. I'd read more into the text and intent than the photo details. 3) Photography is art? Not to the majority of people who just want to take photos on vacation or of the family. The most common questions I get are: What camera to buy (well addressed here), what do those settings on my camera dial mean (addressed fairly well here), and how do I take better pictures (good starting points to think about composition). 4) Go look at good photos. Agree. Fair? No. The big investment for most people is time. From point #1, there are a lot of good books at the library... if you are of the willing. As for disclaimer about skill, &c: People have paid for my photos as well. I have an art degree. Look, I'm not great but I'm handy with a camera. http://www.flickr.com/photos/kanemoto/sets/72157621724362081/ http://www.flickr.com/photos/kanemoto/sets/72157621724362081...