3 ms·
> My interview consisted of about twelve minutes with a laconic, mustachioed, middle-aged Arthur Andersen manager named Dick. (One of the services Andersen had
by Aurornis 2y ago
> My interview consisted of about twelve minutes with a laconic, mustachioed, middle-aged Arthur Andersen manager named Dick. (One of the services Andersen had been asked to provide was to help hire the Conglomerate’s Y2K team.) “On a scale of one to ten, what’s your knowledge of computer software?” he began. I paused for a moment, unsure of whether our interview would include a demonstrative component, as had so many previous interviews for jobs I had not gotten. But his office was empty. I couldn’t see how he would test me. I said eight.
On a private forum I'm part of there was an engineer who ascended into upper management at a startup. He had an entire thesis that modern tech interviews were bullshit and could be replaced with short conversations and asking candidates to self-rate their abilities.
He posted long and confident writings about how he was going to save his company so much time and attract the best talent by having the shortest interviews and trusting candidates self-ratings of their abilities.
He disappeared for a long time until one day he came back and wrote a post-mortem about his hiring experiment. The quality of their new hires had collapsed. It was so bad that some of their previous top employees were quitting because they were tired of all of the unqualified people joining the company.
As he learned, if candidates sense that their interviewers aren't going to examine their claims too closely, many of them will inflate their claims as much as they think they can get away with.
In hiring, it only takes one candidate grossly exaggerating their experience and abilities to push the truly qualified candidates into 2nd place (aka not getting the job).
We all like to think that we can separate the liars from the truth tellers, but when you're trying to do it in extremely short interviews with questions going both ways, there isn't much time to deep dive.
- datavirtue 2y agoYou need to slow the hiring process significantly to slightly decrease the chances of getting burned. When you are trying to scale up this is very painful. Hence, the common discussion about the problems that occur in a company experiencing rapid growth.