4 ms·
"Device-tracking services rely on location pings and other personal data pulled from smartphones, usually via in-app advertisers. Surveillance tech companies th
by dylan604 2y ago
"Device-tracking services rely on location pings and other personal data pulled from smartphones, usually via in-app advertisers. Surveillance tech companies then buy this information from data brokers and sell access to it as part of their products."
It's these type of examples that show just how bad tracking and data harvesting is being used beyond the described use by whatever is doing the hoovering of data. The fact this is something that can be sold is beyond ridiculous. If you collect it for internal use is totally different from collecting for the explicit purpose of selling to others.
- advael 2y agoI don't think it's possible to craft regulation such that companies collecting data for "internal use" can't abuse it. It's so easy to create plausibly deniable ways to move data around. In ML research we get a lot of "anonymized" data for example, which is ridiculous because even pretty primitive statistical methods can usually use such data to uniquely identify people, let alone the inference techniques in widespread usage in industry today In theory it could be different, in practice it simply isn't. If we want any kind of privacy law, "internal use" or "legitimate interest" or whatever nonsense the data brokers deploy to pretend there's some way to do this that isn't unethical is a smokescreen and a loophole in every context, and we should ban the harvesting of that data regardless of its intended use
- dylan604 2y agoI'm much less concerned about if 'you collect it, you use it' situations. It's the companies that build an app with a psuedo purpose whose real purpose is to collect data for reselling later. Collecting data for the sole purpose of selling to others should be regulated into oblivion.
- advael 2y agoOkay, so we ban selling data and then people who want it will buy or even fund breaches instead. Massive breaches will likely become more common, because that's how driving valuable stuff into a black market always works, and companies who aggregate data already do a shit job protecting said data and face negligible consequences from regulators or markets for this. Even the press will happily blame the constant stream of leaked data on unnamed "hackers" every single time I also expect to see a shift to buying more "data-driven insights" from big data aggregators, which in practice will mean the same thing as buying the data means now, just with the middlemen rearranged slightly Governments will still be able to subpeona the data in ways that route around human rights and on the rare occasions where this comes to light, "national security" and the need to fight whatever war - whether against a concrete nation or organization or an abstract concept - they believe will most muddy the waters to cite
- MetaWhirledPeas 2y ago> I don't think it's possible to craft regulation such that companies collecting data for "internal use" can't abuse it. Actually, the regulatory language is easy. "You may not buy or sell user data." The friction comes from the fact that a large part of our economy is highly dependent on the ability to buy and sell user data.
- WhyNotHugo 2y ago> Actually, the regulatory language is easy. "You may not buy or sell user data." I believe the easy workaround is to designate the other party a "data processor" or something of that sort. "We're not selling data, we merely allow partners to access it to generate reports for us."
- A4ET8a8uTh0 2y agoThis AND liability on the data being part of an inevitable breach. Both working in tandem would limit data collected to a minimum required to operate and remove incentive to collect. But as you note.. surveillance economy will not be happy about it and likely fight back. Amusingly, the people who understand the risks and take precautions are also least likely to put a spotlight on them, which privacy-conscious tend to avoid.
- dylan604 2y ago> The friction comes from the fact that a large part of our economy is highly dependent on the ability to buy and sell user data. This is only a recent part of the economy that the world would not collapse if we went back to a time of it not being part of the economy. Just because something is does not mean that it should. There are plenty of historical example of where something was that was not right that took time so that eventually what is is now no more.
- advael 2y agoI don't think any such regulation can have teeth or actually protect anyone. The mechanism by which data is abused is a moving target that will shift with any regulation you throw at it. It will go to black markets, be reshaped through loopholes, or done in plausibly deniable ways by entities that can bog any legal challenge down in technicalities indefinitely, while still probably making more doing it than they'll be fined for, and every loophole will require new regulation to close it. The only way to regulate data collection with teeth is to make the collection itself illegal, and actually enforce those laws
- CuriousSkeptic 2y agoGDPR is pretty clear on anonymisation requirements https://www.edps.europa.eu/system/files/2021-04/21-04-27_aepd-edps_anonymisation_en_5.pdf https://www.edps.europa.eu/system/files/2021-04/21-04-27_aep... So somewhat possible?
- michaelmrose 2y agoThere is no point in leaving a loophole when we can forbid selling data entirely.
- ideashower 2y agoHow do you anonymize a person's location? It just isn't possible. https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/3038912.3052620 https://dl.acm.org/doi/abs/10.1145/3038912.3052620
- CuriousSkeptic 2y agoThe law doesn’t really care if its possible. It just states that it is your responsibility when you fail.
- cokeandpepsi 2y ago[dead]
- throwaway48476 2y agoThis data is also used by cartels to kill people. Mass surveillance has a blood price.
- notduncansmith 2y agoThis certainly seems within the realm of possibility but can you link to a source?
- throwaway48476 2y agohttps://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/dec/07/mexico-cartels-drugs-spying-corruption https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/dec/07/mexico-cartels... https://youtube.com/watch?v=q1p94mLE3Aw https://youtube.com/watch?v=q1p94mLE3Aw Mass surveillance is used to kill journalists and politicians. https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/mexico-councilwoman-killed-after-bloodiest-ever-elections-2024-06-08/ https://www.reuters.com/world/americas/mexico-councilwoman-k...
- notduncansmith 2y agoThanks for the references
- kurthr 2y agoDon't collect any large scale data on your public (customer?) you don't want adversaries to have. You quickly become the weakest link.
- whatnotests2 2y agoOr arrested, convicted, imprisoned. Cite the Telegram CEO's current status.
- kurthr 2y agoI'm not sure I follow, but yes, if he has collected personal/(un)encrypted data, then he and the infrastructure he controls would be one of the weakest links wherever he is. I do think the Russian response is quite a bit of projection, because they know what they would do to get the keys to Telegram's kingdom. It's interesting though that I haven't heard Elon opine on how weak Telegram's end-end security is since the arrest. You'd think he would warn everyone to avoid it?
- tmpz22 2y agoThis is how Astrology Apps and similar genres work. They prey on a gullible demographic and then extract as much data as possible: contact lists, location, and more. Apple is complicit because even the dumbest reviewer knows an Astrology App doesn't need constant location access (but we need to lookup their star signs! We couldn't possibly just ask for a one-off zip code!).
- dylan604 2y agoHaha, and why would my contacts be necessary to tell me my reading? The fact that the walled garden isn't preventing this type of behavior is pretty good evidence of why it's no where near as safe as they tout it.
- tmpz22 2y agoSo you can share your readings with your friends! Duh! (\s) Thanks Apple for keeping the App Store safe!
- ideashower 2y agoIt's actually travel apps (non-navigation/maps) that collect the most. Maybe astrology apps fit under "lifestyle" which is #2. It's much more widespread than we think. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/12/20/opinion/location-tracking-smartphone-marketing.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/12/20/opinion/locat...
- TheCleric 2y agoHonestly surprised weather is so low. I’ve seen a few that seem shady and they don’t even have to make up a lame excuse as to why they need location.
- qingcharles 2y agoThe frustrating thing with this is, that if you have naive friends, family, and professional associates your contact info is getting harvested from their phones without you having to do anything. They just install one of these scummy apps and click OK to it vacuuming up all their contacts, which includes everything they know about you.