3 ms·
> I don't think you actually read that link. Or maybe you're hoping I don't.... The first part is just true - it's not up for debate. You asked me to demonstra
by zahlman 2y ago
> I don't think you actually read that link. Or maybe you're hoping I don't.... The first part is just true - it's not up for debate.
You asked me to demonstrate that people make the argument, because you claimed that people don't make the argument. I showed you someone making the argument, and you have responded by reinforcing that argument.
The claim is that this "powerful implication[s] of racial supremacy" is harmful - we know this because the author is arguing that the change affirmatively should be made, and there is no reason to make the change without an appeal to such harm. But there is no attempt to explain how such harm would actually arise from simply using the terms as technical jargon. One might reasonably infer that the author is somehow claiming that such terminology justifies or advocates for racial supremacy; but there is no attempt to reason through that claim.
There is also no attempt to consider other potential implications of the term, nor the mindset which leads to this interpretation. Implication is only relevant in conjunction with inference, and these inferences are being drawn by clearly politically motivated people.
> Personally I think if you're a die-hard master-slave fan that's weird
Please stop coming back to this strawman. Again, a higher standard of discourse is expected here.
> Okay, and this bothers you why?
For reasons explicitly stated in my comment.
> Um, YOU do. Clearly you are
Again, a higher standard of discourse is expected here.
> YOU'RE an outsider asking python to change for YOU.
I did not ask for any change. I in fact criticized a change. Please stop trying to present change as non-change and vice-versa.
I am also not an outsider. I have been writing code in Python for about 20 years.
> "Doing nothing" IS NOT an apolitical stance.
Yes, it is. This, in your words, is "just true" and "not up for debate". But the fact that you would propose such a thing, perfectly betrays your agenda in posting here.
> the reason why master is used in the first place is inherently political
To be clear, are you asserting that the person who originally chose the term, had the explicit goal of expressing "powerful implications of racial supremacy and oppression" in version control software?
If you are not claiming that, then it is very obvious that "the reason why [the term] is used" is not political.
If you are, then you are, in fact, calling people monsters for sticking with it, and you are also making an inflammatory claim without evidence.
- consteval 2y ago[flagged]
- zahlman 2y ago> One might not reasonably infer this because that's the most insane thing I've ever read. Do you just assume everyone else is this insane? They're really not. Again, a higher standard of discourse is expected here. But I infer this because it is the only way that any sense could possibly be made of the argument. If we claim anything other than "this terminology somehow justifies or advocates for racial supremacy", then it is immediately clear that nothing the author says about the terminology actually counts against using the terminology. But the author insists that it is problematic to use the terminology. Therefore that must be the argument. > But whenever I open up GIMP, I can't help but think about some sexual things. This is your fault, bluntly. > inaction CAN BE political. This is a different claim from what you initially presented. > Was this act of inaction political? Yes, yes it was. So yes, inaction can be political. The police officers in your example were demonstrating action, not inaction. They made a conscious choice to ignore a legal duty. That is clearly different from failing to rename something in your code because an activist says you should. Nothing ordinarily obligates me to accept pull requests. > I'm not asserting that, it seems you're having hallucinations. Again, a higher standard of discourse is expected here. But I asked a question. > And, it was known and understood because of... wait for it... slavery. The only reason it's in our lexicon is because of slavery. First off, no, that is simply untrue: https://www.etymonline.com/word/master https://www.etymonline.com/word/master . The word is attested in other uses going back to at least the 12th century. Second, I already addressed the possibility that you were not making such an assertion. In this case your argument also fails. You cede that the term is not used for a political reason, even if it were inseparable from a particular connotation (which isn't the case anyway). Simply having an effect is not the same thing as doing something for the reason of creating that effect. > I understand it's very easy to win arguments against insane people but you'll have to try harder. Again, a higher standard of discourse is expected here.
- consteval 2y ago[flagged]