5 ms·
> I don't think a single soul implied they were monsters. There's nothing wrong with having your branch named "master" if, coincidently, that's what you have.
by zahlman 2y ago
> I don't think a single soul implied they were monsters. There's nothing wrong with having your branch named "master" if, coincidently, that's what you have.
It takes no effort to find arguments such as https://medium.com/let-s-begin/how-to-rename-your-master-branch-to-main-or-something-else-d55a04f456c0 https://medium.com/let-s-begin/how-to-rename-your-master-bra... .
Github themselves tried to push the change on people, and reporting on the issue used phrasing describing the original choice as "no longer appropriate" as if this were some authoritative consensus (e.g. https://www.theserverside.com/feature/Why-GitHub-renamed-its-master-branch-to-main https://www.theserverside.com/feature/Why-GitHub-renamed-its... ). Github's change was disruptive because repositories created on GitHub wouldn't work properly locally in Git (depending on various details) and this was happening to users with very little technical understanding and no reason to care about the underlying political issue.
But aside from that, it's very obvious that many people think there's "something wrong with" using master as the default name. If they didn't, there never would have been an issue in the first place because nobody would have proposed to change it.
There is nobody out there advocating for the change without bringing up some strange hand-waving argument about colonialism. Not a single one of these people can demonstrate how using the name "master" actually causes harm - because it doesn't. But hordes of them are willing to argue for making the change anyway.
> However it's weird if you say master is the "one true name" and it HAS to be master.
Nobody says this. They say that they don't want others pushing (or literally pull-requesting, in many cases) changes on them for ideological reasons that have nothing to do with the business of their project.
> Like, why do you care? That's odd. That's what some people point out.
No, there's nothing strange about it at all. What is "odd" is the rhetorical strategy of trying to shame people for a benign choice, gaslight that they're the ones being insistent and ideological, and then gaslight that no such shaming is occurring.
> For some people changing master -> main isn't a nothing burger, it's actively harmful.
No, what's "actively harmful" is the idea that people should be compelled to change things because outsiders don't like them (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entryism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entryism). Also the compatibility break mentioned above.
- consteval 2y ago[flagged]
- anonfordays 2y ago>Personally I think if you're a die-hard master-slave fan that's weird. There is no concept of "slave" in git, there are no "slave" branches. That concept has never existed in git's source code. It's master like "master recording".
- consteval 2y agoOk but where do you think the term comes from? It didn't spawn into common use out of nowhere. And I'll say - I don't think it matters. It's all stupid bullshit in my eyes. But if it doesn't matter, which it doesn't, then main shouldn't be a problem. In my opinion.
- anonfordays 2y ago>Ok but where do you think the term comes from? It didn't spawn into common use out of nowhere. From mastering: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mastering_(audio) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mastering_(audio) >And I'll say - I don't think it matters. It's all stupid bullshit in my eyes. But if it doesn't matter, which it doesn't, then main shouldn't be a problem. In my opinion. And I'll say - I don't think it matters. It's all stupid bullshit in my eyes. But if it doesn't matter, which it doesn't, then master shouldn't be a problem. In my opinion.
- consteval 2y agoOkay I'm not the one who advocated to change master. That's already been done. Now we have people advocating to change BACK to master. Also really? Audio mastering? And which, pray tell, do you believe came first?
- anonfordays 2y ago