4 ms·
"Programmers tend to think that programming is the most important part of making software. However, managers think that managing is the most important part of m
by mgkimsal 14y ago
"Programmers tend to think that programming is the most important part of making software. However, managers think that managing is the most important part of making software, and business analysts think that defining business requirements is the most important part of making software. Asking a room of programmers about the value of business analysts is going to result in feedback that is heavily biased. As you say, we've invented a narrative of moral superiority, and it's a seductive one."
I think I thought that way about 15 years ago or so, but by 10 years ago I realized that ... almost without exception, I can get the tech stuff done. Of course, I'd like to do it myself, but I can get others smarter than me at XYZ to do the tech stuff. While the tech stuff is sometimes hard, it's almost universally doable.
Have you ever had a project fail because you didn't know how to write to a file, take data input or query a database? I bet not. But... we've all had projects that failed because none of the people involved could accurately communicate what needed to be done (and in some cases, establish reasonable timelines for those needs). Communication is key, and PM/BA types are generally better at it than typical developer types. There are always exceptions, but the PM/BA types are perceived to be better at it, often because they're controlling the communication, almost by definition of their role.
So, while everyone thinks their part is the most important, they're pretty much all equally important, but the PM/BAs tend to be more visible on projects, rightly or wrongly.
- Swizec 14y agoI've had projects fail because we couldn't get the core algorithms working ... Hell, most of my interesting failures so far have been "Okay, so computers can't do X (yet), or I'm too stupid to figure it out and don't know anyone smart enough to solve X" A lot of my projects would sell like hotcakes, once someone figures out a practical implementation, or at least an impractical one.
- mgkimsal 14y agoI'd thought about that angle, and I've known a couple of those myself over the years (mostly second hand). But even in the cases I've seen, things might have gone much smoother had there been stronger communication about the specifics and what was (and was not) possible much earlier. As soon as things look to be not possible, tell someone. If you're able to pull a rabbit out of a hat later on, great, but let people know that real hard limits (algorithm, processing speed, etc) are being hit. sometimes what someone was indicating was a hard requirement turns out to be a 'oh, it'd be nice to have that, let's move on' sort of thing. So, while I get your point, I think overall there's still things people can do wrt communication even when there are fundamentally tech issues at stake.
- Swizec 14y agoThat depends. Most of the projects I'm thinking about had Solve A Hard Problem at their core. Granted, there might be a better way to solve it than devise some technology to do so that I never thought of.
- Morg 14y agoSounds good to me, when do we start ?
- vorg 14y ago> Have you ever had a project fail because you didn't know how to write to a file, take data input or query a database? [...] 10 years ago I realized that ... almost without exception, I can get the tech stuff done. The examples of "tech stuff" you mentioned are very junior programming tasks. The "programming" the article talks about is all the non-PM/BA stuff: the overall technical design of the system, not just the file writing and database queries; the testing process from individual components to integration to customer involvement; the build and deployment processes, including impacts on existing systems and addressing security/privacy concerns, etc. > I can get the tech stuff done. Of course, I'd like to do it myself, but I can get others smarter than me [...] to do the tech stuff. Project managers and business analysts usually try to add technical skills to their resume by dabbling in some of the "tech stuff" of the projects they're managing. Usually this is the highest level stuff like architecture design or programming language selection or programmer analysis/selection: generally the stuff with the greatest impact on the success or failure of a project. You write "Of course, I'd like to do it myself" so I guess you're one of them. But those with PM/BA experience are the least able to do this project-critical tech stuff. Project Managers get to dabble in this work because of their power in an organisation. They also try to keep their jobs by "creating" work and problems, just like middlemen everywhere. They stop technical people gaining too much power by splitting the systems into arbitrary projects. They give programming jobs to their mates in return for loyalty. Despite their talk about being accountable for their results, in reality they cover their behinds in case they fail. When the tech stuff goes wrong, they leave behind a huge mess for programmers to clean up, usually with extra hours and overnight standbies. The business users get to do unit testing as part of their change acceptance process. The PM's go into recruitment and back into management somewhere else. A recruiter once told me "if I had a job like that on my books, I'd apply for it myself".
- mgkimsal 14y ago"You write "Of course, I'd like to do it myself" so I guess you're one of them." Umm.... no, not really. I'm a developer who's gradually moved in to more business-oriented consulting over the last several years. I still do a lot of development (> 50%, certainly), but I've realized that for the majority of the projects I work on, the difficulties are not programming or tech skills/knowledge, it's making sure we all know what is to be programmed, and dealing with any changes that come up. Everyone thinks they're stuff is unique/cutting-edge/hard/impossible/ground-breaking tech marvels. In some cases it is, but I'm finding those instances to be more rare the older I get. Why? My own skills are getting better (slowly), there's far more tools and libraries to tackle much larger problems better, and my own network of people I can tap has grown to include some insanely talented people. "the testing process from individual components to integration to customer involvement; the build and deployment processes, including impacts on existing systems and addressing security/privacy concerns, etc." I would posit those are far more in the realm of "communication" issues I brought up. Yes, you need to have a technical background to do them correctly, but you don't do that stuff in a vacuum. You do those things in concert with other people (customer, team, etc). For example - the basics of build and deployment are known problems. One might even class them as 'junior' problems. How many times have you had builds fail because someone didn't know how to schedule jenkins properly? Or because an alert wasn't set up to notify someone of an issue? The mechanics aren't very hard, but deciding what the specifics of the processes should be is hard, because you have to communicate ideas/deadlines/responsibilities/etc with multiple people or teams. That's what I'm getting at.
- noonespecial 14y agoThey have failed though, because someone couldn't get security right.