4 ms·
The problem is to isolate the box enough. If you can heard the cat meow, then it counts as a "measurement" and the superposition disappears. If you can hear the
by gus_massa 2y ago
The problem is to isolate the box enough. If you can heard the cat meow, then it counts as a "measurement" and the superposition disappears. If you can hear there is no heartbeat of the cat, then it counts as a "measurement" and the superposition disappears. If the cats move and the box wags, then it counts as a "measurement" and the superposition disappears...
So in practice the experiment only works with very small systems with a few atoms. Each year there are experiments with bigger systems, but they are usually frozen and very small. Perhaps one day we will be able to do the experiment with tardigrades.
- Vampiero 2y agoHearing at all implies sound waves. If there are soundwaves there is air inside the box. If there is air inside the box the system can't be in a superposition because it has long since decohered. In other words it's not the act of "listening" that collapses the wave function but the interaction of air molecules that creates the sound in the first place, even if no one is there to listen. A "measurement" or an "observation" doesn't actually require a human, or a living thing. It's just a physical interaction.
- rvbissell 2y agoCatch 22: and if there is no air inside the box, then you are certain the cat is dead.
- Maxatar 2y agoThis isn't quite right, wave function collapse is relative so while within the box an observer's wave function of the box will be in a definite eigenstate, the wavefunction of the box for an observer isolated from the box will still be in a superposition of its states. In other words, the fact that an observation takes place from within the box and collapses the wave function for an observer in the box does not mean that the wave function for every observer also collapses. A wave function collapse for one observer does not imply a wave function collapse for any other observer.
- Jensson 2y ago> wave function collapse is relative No it isn't, why do you think this? If it was we wouldn't be able to see it in our experiments, as where the particle ends up would depend on which observer is looking, which would get absurd consequences.
- Maxatar 2y agoI provided my explanation for why this is the case. A measurement device only collapses the wave function for itself, it does not collapse the wave function for every other observer/measurement device. Of course, a second measurement device that's completely isolated from the first measurement device can eventually interact with the first measurement device and the two will converge and share the same wave function. However, until the second measurement device interacts with the first one or with the original quantum system being observed, then from the point of view of the second measurement device, the first measurement device is in a superposition of all the possible states that it could have observed. This can continue on and on, with a third measurement device which is entirely isolated from the second measurement device having a wavefunction that's a superposition of all the possible observations that the second measurement device will observer...
- Jensson 2y ago> A measurement device only collapses the wave function for itself, it does not collapse the wave function for every other observer/measurement device. Wave function collapse is a real measurable phenomena, what you describe is not measurable so just a belief, don't mix in your beliefs with actual results.
- Maxatar 2y agoWave function collapse is one of many equivalent (so far as we know) interpretations of quantum mechanics and not all interpretations have wave function collapse whatsoever. With that said even in the Copenhagen interpretation which is the most popular interpretation of quantum mechanics, the moment in time when the wave function collapses is relative to each measurement device. It is not the case that just because some measurement device that has been entirely isolated from me happens to perform a measurement on a quantum system, that my wave function of that quantum system will also collapse. On the contrary my wave function remains exactly as is until the moment I perform a measurement on the quantum system which collapses my wave function of said system.
- danbruc 2y agoThis does not help at all, quantum systems - even messy complex ones, boxes containing cats and air - evolve unitarily and do not destroy a superposition. The box and the air and the cat can interact all they want, you will still have a superposition of cat dead - and box and air in some state - and cat alive - and box and air in some other state. And no point are we addressing how we get rid of one half of the entangled state. And even if I see the box wiggle a bit, we only declare that me watching the box somehow was an measurement and that collapsed the wave function without answering the question why I did not simply get entangled with the box, too.
- Jensson 2y ago> quantum systems - even messy complex ones, boxes containing cats and air - evolve unitarily and do not destroy a superposition This is wrong, they do collapse, you can test this using the double slit experiment. No human has to be there for the wavefunction to collapse and thus break entanglement. If what you said was true then this wouldn't be a part of physics, physics is only about stuff we can measure not nonsense that has no meaning.
- tsimionescu 2y agoIt's not at all clear how, when, and why wave function collapse happens. The only known quantity there, decoherence, is related to interaction between a coherent quantum system and a noisy decohered environment, which causes the original system to decohere itself. Theoretically, as far as it is known today, it is possible for a quantum system of any size, and at any temperature, to remain in a coherent state, if it could be perfectly isolated from the rest of the world. Any limits to this process, where a perfectly isolated system would undergo wave function collapse without any outside interference, would be a Nobel-prize worthy discovery and would constitute a new theory of physics: quantum mechanics and QFT allow no such process. Edit: and the double slit experiment is unrelated - the screen and the slit are noisy classical systems that are not in any way isolated from the rest of the classical world. In principle, if you performed the experiment using a screen and slits made entirely of atoms entangled with the emitter, and isolated perfectly from the rest of the world and the CMB and everything, you'd get a different result: this is what QM predicts.
- passion__desire 2y ago(somewhat related) There are two infinities operating in QM when systems get big. https://youtu.be/FrTq_m1pLz8?t=2188 https://youtu.be/FrTq_m1pLz8?t=2188 Quantum mechanics forces two infinities upon us when attempting to make precise observations. The first is the need for infinitely many measurements, stemming from the probabilistic nature of quantum predictions. To obtain a sharp notion of probability, we must perform an experiment infinitely often, converging to the true probability in the limit. The second infinity involves an infinitely large measuring apparatus. This arises because any finite measuring device is itself subject to quantum fluctuations, introducing an intrinsic imprecision to measurements. The degree of imprecision scales as e^(-n), where n is the number of particles composing the measuring device. While the first infinity is often discussed and practically relevant in experimental settings, the second is less commonly addressed but conceptually significant. These infinities highlight fundamental limitations in our ability to make precise quantum measurements and become particularly problematic when gravity is introduced into the picture.
- Obscurity4340 2y agoThis seems to predicate what does or doesnt happen on the awareness of sentient observers. What is the evidence for that and why would the cats fate depend on whether anyone (or itself) is monitoring it in any sense of that word?