2 ms·
> You can't write software code without the ability to think. You can't tactfully respond to emotional expression without the ability to think. Of course you c
by latexr 2y ago
> You can't write software code without the ability to think. You can't tactfully respond to emotional expression without the ability to think.
Of course you can.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room
They’re not responding “tactfully”, you’re projecting emotion to a bunch of words written coldly.
It’s like writing a program that has a number of fixed strings like “I feel sad” or “I’m depressed” and when it sees those it outputs “I’m sorry to hear that. I’m here for you and love you”. The words may be comforting and come at the right time, but there’s no feeling or thought put into them.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 2y ago>but there’s no feeling or thought put into them. How do you empirically measure this?
- consteval 2y agoHumans can measure feelings, computers can't. Therefore I can say if ChatGPT doesn't have enough feeling but it can never do the inverse to me. That feels simplistic, but we're dealing with fundamentally human concepts. I see absolutely no reason to work under the assumption that computer programs are somehow in the same domain as human thought, which is what a lot of people (you) are saying. The goal should not be to demonstrate ChatGPT and Humans are different, because to me that is obvious and should be the starting point. Rather we should do the inverse, show that ChatGPT is indistinguishable from a person, as measured by Humans. And then, maybe, we can consider granting this computer program human rights like the right to use copyrightable media in a transformative way. Ah, but that is really hard to do. So the AI tech bros don't do it, and instead work in the opposite direction.