3 ms·
Even Sweden and Denmark have bus fare. If half the people are evading bus fare, then that’s a problem that needs to be fixed regardless of anything else you mig
by rayiner 2y ago
Even Sweden and Denmark have bus fare. If half the people are evading bus fare, then that’s a problem that needs to be fixed regardless of anything else you might do. It’s not likely that the people jumping the turnstiles are orderly and polite riders who help keep the system clean. You’ll just end up taxing everyone to create a system that’s unpleasant for normal people to use, which will destroy public support for those taxes.
Toxic empathy, ironically, is antithetical to building functioning transit systems. To get buy-in from the public to direct tax dollars to transit, you need to have pleasant, orderly, clean systems that people who can afford to drive want to use instead of driving. You can’t get that if half your riders are law breakers.
- fulafel 2y agoSweden and Denmark have low economic inequality and high income transfers. On the other hand nearby Estonia has less income transfers & higher inequality but free bus fares.
- OutOfHere 2y ago> Toxic empathy Do not forget that NYC charges a substantial income tax, and also a substantial sales tax. As such, the empathy is 100% justifiable.
- rayiner 2y agoSo do Sweden and Denmark, and they have bus fare on top of that. NYC uses that to subsidize 80% of the bus system and imposes user fees for the rest. The people who evade the fare are anti-social, and it’s toxic and ultimately detrimental to the goal of functional, widely used public transit to empathize with anti-social people. Even in my home country of Bangladesh, which is extremely poor and dysfunctionally anti-social, I would guess fare evasion isn’t as high as in NYC (including the people riding on top of the bus).
- OutOfHere 2y ago> NYC uses that to subsidize 80% of the bus system Don't kid yourself. No one is going to pay 5x to ride the bus. It doesn't cost that much to offer a local bus ride. I don't think you realize where the money really goes. It goes to pay huge pensions, not to benefit the rider.
- dotnet00 2y agoAgreed, a lot of this 'empathy' is largely naivete, 48% of New Yorkers aren't so poor as to be unable to pay for the bus. Most of them are anti-social or lacking in a sense of duty towards the commons, making the fare free would not make them suddenly feel a sense of duty, they'd just become even more brazen in abusing the infrastructure.
- OutOfHere 2y agoThose who make $16*8 = $128/day before taxes, and <$100 after taxes, most definitely cannot afford to pay $5.80/day on the stupid bus fare, nor should they have to. They're getting a raw deal as it is for their labor.
- pclmulqdq 2y agoAnyone making that little doesn't pay net taxes. The EITC, federal benefits, and state and city benefits all pile up on the other side.
- OutOfHere 2y ago> Anyone making that little doesn't pay net taxes. The IRS certainly taxes an annual income of ~$30k, basically anything above $11k. Any benefits require jumping through a lot of hoops. Moreover, like everyone else, they also have to pay a sales tax for every non-food item they buy. There is also a property tax that they're indirectly responsible for if they're renting. When choosing between rent and bus fare, the choice is obvious.