3 ms·
> The judge argues that copilot “rarely emits memorised code in benign situations”, but what happens when it does? It is bound to happen some day, and when it d
by dragonwriter 2y ago
> The judge argues that copilot “rarely emits memorised code in benign situations”, but what happens when it does? It is bound to happen some day, and when it does would I be breaching copyright if i, unknowingly, published the code copilot wrote?
That's irrelevant to the case being made against GitHub, which is why it is addressed in the decision.
> Just a few weeks ago a very similar suit for stable diffusion had its motion to dismiss copyright infringement claims denied.
The case against Midjourney, SAI, and RunwayML is based on a very different legal theory -- it is a simple direct copyright violation case ("they copied our work onto their servers and used it to train models") whereas the Copilot case (the copyright part of it) is a DMCA case claiming that Copilot removes copyright information management information.
It's not really surprising that the Copilot case was easier to dispose of without trial; it was a big stretch that had the advantage for the plaintiffs that, were it allowed to go forward, it doesn't admit a fair use defense the way a traditional direct copyright violation case does.
They aren't really "similar" except that both are lawsuits against AI service/model providers that rest some subset of their claims on some part of Title 17 of the US Code.