7 ms·
Other problems with StackOverflow: - gamification problems: e.g. a race to answer instead of thinking it through, downvoting competing answers - the accept
by alecco 2y ago
Other problems with StackOverflow:
- gamification problems: e.g. a race to answer instead of thinking it through, downvoting competing answers
- the accepted answer sometimes is incorrect (but sounds good enough to OP)
- balance between repeat or vague questions and over-zealous mods blocking
- need of better mod vetting (ideally, paid)
- question quality
Some of these could be helped with tools. For example have a small repro and test answers in a VM. And have small ML helpers to fill in the spaces and link to other questions or official docs.
Maybe all answers should be wiki-style (cooperative).
Maybe questions could be first in a staging area and meta-evaluated if it's good, dupe, or too vague. And it could also be improved by the community.
And some mechanism to avoid Eternal September!
- layer8 2y ago> Maybe all answers should be wiki-style (cooperative). It’s valuable to read different perspectives, and even conflicting opinions, and have them attributed. Having only a cooperative answer would lead to edit wars and would drown out minority perspectives.
- alecco 2y agoAbsolutely. I didn't mean all answers combined into one, just that all answers are wiki. Like today in SO.