6 ms·
Should the richest 1% – who gained $42T/decade – be taxed more?
- MrGilbert 2y agoI‘d argue that we could question how they were able to acquire this amount of money in the first place.
- nielsbot 2y agoThe answer I hear in lefty circles is ever lower taxation on them. (Since WWII?)
- to11mtm 2y agoWealth, especially generational wealth, is a complicated problem in many aspects. The biggest 'challenge' is once you get to various echelons... of all places, I heard it best described on reddit; It's like the reverse of MMO mechanics; Rather than low levels giving you lots of growth and higher levels requiring a lot of 'grind', the farther you get the easier it is to make more money, even 'doing nothing'. A -huge- factor nowadays is property values as well, which doesn't help. ---- There is also the concern of 'other ways' people get into that echelon. I think of those who exploit labor, flount the law, and honestly in some cases (maybe they aren't the 1% but) those who use their power of 'celebrity' to get people to spend waaaaaay too much money on 'signature' goods or whatever else they endorse (Air Jordans come to mind as an example.) It's all kinda gross to me tbh.
- hasbot 2y agoWhy? Each billionaire has a unique origin story so I'm not sure what's there to gain by your question.
- consteval 2y agoThis seems awfully confident. I mean, have you interviewed every single billionaire? I doubt it. I'm sure there's many patterns or things linking them together. All I know is that I, and also everyone else I know, would never let themselves have a billion dollars. That money would be long gone before they reach 1 billion. Impulsively spent on whatever they think is good for other people. Could money be an addiction, like alcohol? Where some are predispositioned to want more and more and some don't care for it?
- hasbot 2y agoI didn't have to interview them; it's all here: https://www.forbes.com/sites/chasewithorn/2024/04/02/forbes-worlds-billionaires-list-2024-the-top-200 https://www.forbes.com/sites/chasewithorn/2024/04/02/forbes-... What patterns do you see and, more importantly, what actions would you take?
- consteval 2y agoI don't think a forbes article is enough to claim with 100% certainty that every billionaire is completely different from the others. It's such a wild and obviously incorrect claim I don't know how you could possibly make it. I mean, even me - there are things in common between me and random people. > what actions would you take Nice try, but if I tell you you'll just use that to discredit anything I say. That's not relevant to the conversation so I won't be answering that. Feel free to speculate.
- hasbot 2y agoSure it is. Just scroll through the list and you see very few similarities. If anything might be in common, is that many of them were from rich families to begin with (e.g. Gates, Zuckerberg, Donald Trump) but there's many that weren't (e.g. Phil Knight). > I'm sure there's many patterns or things linking them together. That's awfully confident. What knowledge do you have that inspires such confidence?
- dubcanada 2y agoThe answer is obvious, we put up gates to prevent competition. Every industry has so much red tape and list of approved products that it is impossible. Have a new product to solve house building in a timely fashion, hopefully you have hundred of thousands to pay for certification and then wait years for some government agency to approve your product for building. It's rather disgusting how we grid locked ourselves with regulations. There used to be thousands of ISPs, banks, grocery stores, etc and we added red tape after red tape to restrict and allowed them to be all bought by the company that did the best. Now we got like 3 banks, 3 ISPs, and 3 grocery stores with different names.
- stanleykm 2y agoA bearded german guy wrote about this at length a while ago
- femto 2y agoThomas Piketty's book, "Capital in the Twenty-First Century", has a bit to say on this. It argues that historically, and increasingly so today, the return on capital exceeds the return on labour. This means wealth is a positive feedback cycle: wealth earns more wealth, at the expense of those who only have their labour. Once someone hits a net worth threshold it snowballs from there. Agree with it or not, the book is quite readable.
- antisthenes 2y agoIf we're talking about US specifically, if you go back several generations, the answer would be slavery and Native american genocide (then taking their land and natural resources) The new money is mostly from tech/oil and exploiting globalization in smart ways.
- Ekaros 2y agoIt is not money in first place... Wealth is kinda imaginary, a dream that most people believe in. Whole financial system is set up so that as long as numbers keep going up there is more money appearing... Unrealized gains. Commercial real-estate and home values. All of these are wealth. Most of them still go up in value thus in "wealth".
- Havoc 2y agoIt's less a question of should or shouldn't but rather can we. Not convinced there is either the collective willpower or ability to enforce this, never mind both in sufficient quantities spread across the globe in a manner to ensure coverage to prevent the wealth simply moving
- gizajob 2y agoYes
- aamargulies 2y agoGary Stevenson, former top Citibank London trader, has a YouTube channel centered on taxing the rich as a solution to wealth inequality. Highly recommended. https://youtu.be/jFHGiq063rA?si=N64KIhk8ezl7tEEm https://youtu.be/jFHGiq063rA?si=N64KIhk8ezl7tEEm
- hollerith 2y agoDoes he explain how to do it so that it works better than the last time (1960s and 70s in the US and Western Europe) it was tried?
- Havoc 2y agoHe seems quite pessimistic on outlook frankly
- aamargulies 2y agoYes. His most important point though is that things will not get better until a sufficient mass of public political pressure is brought to bear on the issue.
- aamargulies 2y agoA common objection is that the rich will 'just move' to avoid taxes. However, he goes in depth in his response, pointing out that the source of the wealth can't move, you tax that at the source. https://youtu.be/t9l7AYl0jUE?si=LUU_8mUpxw0upPk4 https://youtu.be/t9l7AYl0jUE?si=LUU_8mUpxw0upPk4
- hollerith 2y agoThat only works if taxes aren't so high as to kill the incentive to create the source.
- aamargulies 2y agoHere's perhaps a better link: Robert Reich refutes the top 12 myths about taxing the rich: https://youtu.be/pnoLAMHwf2I?si=SApa_u3PGUZ-Y150 https://youtu.be/pnoLAMHwf2I?si=SApa_u3PGUZ-Y150
- redleggedfrog 2y ago[flagged]
- getnormality 2y agoSeems to be more when the low end isn't getting enough to live on. The element that gets violent just because someone else is doing well doesn't seem that large.
- fhdsgbbcaA 2y agoThere are people in the SF Bay Area who have full time service jobs and can only afford to live in their cars. It should worry everybody when there is a large - and growing - segment of society that follows the rules and can’t scrape by. That doesn’t last for long. You don’t need to worry about the crack heads, worry about the people who can hold a 9-5 and aren’t getting a living wage. All they need is a charismatic leader to organize them, and they’ll actually get shit done.
- Straw 2y agoThis has very little to do with income or wealth inequality, and everything to do with bad local government policy leading to insanely expensive housing. Anyone on a full time service job in the Bay Area is very rich on a global standard! What's a "living wage"? Its easy to shift the goalpost! I'd bet even those service workers who can't afford absurd Bay Area housing still have a living wage by the standards of 1900!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- rachofsunshine 2y agoDoes it not? The entire developed world seems extremely destabilized right now. Old-line Conservative, Labour, and Liberal parties have either been defeated by, or are under serious threat from, populist-nationalist and leftist parties throughout the West [1]. The only thing these latter groups have in common is populist rhetoric and a sense of "I'm not getting my fair piece of the pie". The existence of the modern welfare state owes its genesis to this idea, courtesy of (amazingly) Otto von Bismarck of all people, probably the most consummate and effective conservative of his time. Bismarck was not at all subtle about his reasoning: > Give the working-man the right to work as long as he is healthy, assure him care when he is sick; assure him maintenance when he is old. If you do that, and do not fear the sacrifice, or cry out at State Socialism directly the words “provision for old age” are uttered,—if the State will show a little more Christian solicitude for the working-man, then I believe that the gentlemen of the Wyden (Social-Democratic) programme will sound their bird-call in vain, and that the thronging to them will cease as soon as working-men see that the Government and legislative bodies are earnestly concerned for their welfare. I might not think this is the right reason to be concerned about inequality, but he's right about the realpolitik: a state whose subjects feel the state does not act in their interest have little reason to defend or support the state and all the reason in the world to attack it, or at least that is going to be their perception. ----- [1] Yes, even the recent UK and French elections are an example. Labour's vote share was not very high - but the Conservatives, in the process of being supplanted by the more-nationalist Reform, split the right-wing vote such that Labour could win a share of seats far exceeding what you'd expect for its minimal vote share. In France, Macron's centrists still lost to a left-wing party, and that was after an extraordinary alliance of parties to block Le Pen's RN, which would likely have been the largest party without such maneuvering.
- nullorempty 2y agoYes, but what will the government do with the money. We could already build Eden on earth if it weren't for wars. Governments keep spending money on wars, so what's the point of taking more in taxes. It will all go to shits anyways. And by the way, if you think that governments are accountable to the public you are sadly mistaken. They are accountable to that 1%.
- drdo 2y agoThey can start by taxing the poor less.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pb7 2y agoFrom 0% to 0.0%? Bottom 50% of taxpayers pay 2% of all taxes. The “poor” not only pay nothing, they’re given money via credits.
- rpdillon 2y ago> We could already build Eden on earth if it weren't for wars. Not true. National defense is about 13% of our federal budget. Medicare, Medicaid, healthcare, and Social Security are 50%. https://www.federalbudgetinpictures.com/where-does-all-the-money-go/ https://www.federalbudgetinpictures.com/where-does-all-the-m... The 1% earn 26% of all income, but pay 46% of all income taxes. The bottom 50% of earners pay 2% of income taxes. https://www.federalbudgetinpictures.com/do-the-rich-pay-their-fair-share/ https://www.federalbudgetinpictures.com/do-the-rich-pay-thei... But our system has a serious problem. We've increased the debt by $11 trillion in the past four years, which was our total debt for the first 200 years the country was around. The only point here is the problem is significantly harder than you're making it sound, and that's if we had a straightforward way to just stop all the wars. Unfortunately, no one's been able to come up with a way to do this yet.
- nullorempty 2y agoBecause the goal is to have and endless war. Think about that. https://www.youtube.com/shorts/_IGU_7alJ80 https://www.youtube.com/shorts/_IGU_7alJ80
- JoeAltmaier 2y agoMaybe there's something disfunctional about an economic system that lets ordinary people set up complex product and distributions systems, and then take all the money from them forever. There's something in Europe called VAT that addresses this. It's important to come up with some kind of solution. When the current system reduces to a single purveyor for every product sector, which we're heading for at breakneck speed right now, there will be only a few people owning the whole shebang, and nobody to buy the products because nobody else is needed/has a job at all.
- gopher_space 2y agoI’d like a discussion around hard caps well beneath the “teens on a private island” level. It seems like we could determine the curve of corrosion that the idea of increasing wealth has on the brain with a few really unkind experiments.
- fsckboy 2y agoVAT is Value Added Tax. What is value-add? Selling something for more than it cost you to make it, "adding value" as measured by revenues minus costs. What are other words for that? profit, income What are taxes on that? income taxes. from the point of view of the govt, the VAT is just an ordinary income tax. but instead of being paid by the businesses, it's paid by the consumers, discouraging them from buying high margin items, encouraging them to buy low margin items.
- rich_sasha 2y agoWhat is nice about VAT is that you can tax different goods differently. You can have low VAT on essentials, which everyone - poor or rich - needs, but have higher tax on luxury items. In that respect, it is similar to a progressive tax, except harder to avoid - even an ultra rich who has "no income" buys stuff. Except of course there are gaping loopholes, for example businesses are effectively exempt from VAT, also you can buy stuff abroad where VAT is lower.
- Ekaros 2y agoVAT is essentially flat-tax. Which like all consumption tax works against those that spend higher proportion of their income on buying things necessary for living...
- exabrial 2y agoNobody. The answer is nobody should be taxed more.
- 7e 2y agoDo you want a fairer society, or a society in which the poor are better off in absolute terms? Your choice.
- marci 2y agoNeither. I reject your question.
- hungie 2y agoThat there's a classic example of a false dichotomy.
- 7e 2y agoUSA vs USSR is the classic counterexample. Or even USA vs. Europe, if you want closer political and economic systems for comparison: https://fee.org/articles/the-poorest-20-of-americans-are-richer-than-most-nations-of-europe/ https://fee.org/articles/the-poorest-20-of-americans-are-ric....
- BobaFloutist 2y agoI think a society in which the poor are better off in absolute terms is a fairer society.
- MattPalmer1086 2y agoI'll take the fairer one please. After all, we can't know how many extra doodads and shiny things we might have had, in an unfairer world. So we won't really miss them. On the other hand, I'd like to live in a society where more people feel bought in and live less stressful lives.
- laststrawman 2y agoWhy we believe that the government is the most efficient capital allocator when evidence tells us otherwise? Put the incentives to increase entrepreneurship and education in poor areas, like lower taxes and lower barriers of entry.
- exabrial 2y agoThe goal isn't to eliminate poverty, the goal is to buy votes.
- ericjmorey 2y agoThe Government doesn't need to be the most efficient allocator of resources, it just needs to step in where markets are failing.
- jmyeet 2y agoThere are three major reasons why, with very few exceptions, wealth doesn't last centuries: 1. Descendants of really successful people tend to fritter away that wealth, thinking they're as gifted as their forebears. Look no further than the Vanderbilts; 2. Families have a tendency to die out over generations. The Roman Republican originally had 45 patrician families. By the time of Gaius Julius Caesar (who was from a patrician family), there were 15 IIRC; and 3. The ultimate form of wealth redistribution is war and revolution. Most long-lasting family wealth tends to be monarchies of some kind. Therea are a bunch of arguments you'll hear why taxing the rich more can't or shouldn't happen. They're all lies. 1. Capital flight. The rich will leave. Great. You lose the ability to sell to customers in our country then; 2. Taxing unrealized stock gains is impossible and/or unfair. We do this to property just fine. Companies produce tax statements of unrealized gains just fine; 3. The dreaded slippery slope arguments. "If they go after Bezos, next they'll come after me with my $42,000 a year job and 2011 Camry". A stable society and political climate is completely necessary for this wealth to exist. Having the wealthy pay for the society that makes their wealth possible while avoiding their heads ending up on pikes or in guillotines is entirely just, possible and moral.
- doctorpangloss 2y ago> 2. Taxing unrealized stock gains is impossible and/or unfair. We do this to property just fine. Companies produce tax statements of unrealized gains just fine. Wait till you find out what someone with a home nominally valued $2m in San Francisco pays on his property taxes compared to you.
- dmitrygr 2y agoYou conveniently forgot to make an argument against your second point #3. That is understandable, since there is none. USA income tax started by attacking only those making over $3000 when median yearly pay was $670, but over time it grew to afflict everyone. It will expand and it will one day hurt you.. Everyone thinks that redistribution is great, because they look at the wallets of those better off and cannot wait to get a slice, forgetting that below them there are many looking at their wallets...
- 2y ago
- hungie 2y agoI make 750k a year, give or take. I think I paid 150k in taxes, more or less, last year. I would gladly pay 600k a year in taxes if it meant healthcare, education, housing, and food were secured for all. Let me keep 20% of my work for luxuries I like, but the fact that I'm only paying like 20% is fucking criminal while people are starving in this country. I recognize I'm differently wired and have different values than most, but like, there has to be a line between 20% and 80% tax rate that we can live with.
- antimora 2y agoWhich means you are not willing to pay taxes because your preconditions are almost impossible to achieve judging how the government operates.
- hungie 2y agoI recognize no system is perfect. If there was an attempt to achieve those things, crank my taxes up. I don't need perfect to be the enemy of good.
- stouset 2y agoI’m generally with you, though I live in CA so my effective tax rate is around 50%. I am very troubled when people who proclaim to be liberal move here—an area with high potential—to “strike it rich”, do so, and then immediately fuck off to another state where they can sell their vested shares without paying CA tax rates. CA does try to claw back avoided taxes from the worst offenders of this, but mostly they only go after people who move out on paper but still lead lives here. One of the biggest problems though is that bumping marginal rates doesn’t affect the ultra-rich, who use tax-avoidance schemes like loans against invested assets to live off extreme wealth with nearly zero taxable income.
- andreilys 2y agoProbably because CA politicians want to spend tax money on things like providing $150k of housing loans to undocumented migrants Losing out on a house bid as an American citizen to an undocumented migrant thanks to this policy, truly the type of stuff only a CA politician could come up with. https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/california-democrats-propose-state-bill-to-help-illegal-immigrants-secure-first-home-loans/ar-AA1ptQXZ?ocid=sf https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/california-democrats...
- alberth 2y agoWhat's often ignored is whether or not these are Realized Gains I wouldn't be surprised if a huge majority of that $42T wasn't realized gains (sold and attributed as a Capital Gain). It's hugely unfair to tax non-Realized Gains ... because that would be like you having the pay Income taxes on the appreciation of your home - even though you still live in your home and haven't "realized" those gains (to pay the capital gain taxes)
- etchalon 2y agoI think it's fair to leave "unrealized" gains tax so long as the "gains" are never utilized or borrowed against.
- egman_ekki 2y agothen make sure you don’t move to Denmark where you pay tax on unrealized gains (for some asset classes)
- wbj 2y agoDoesn’t property tax already do this but even more so? Taxing cost basis + gains
- alberth 2y agoThey do, but the financial impact to you is much less. Example - Let's say you bough a home for $100k - Property taxes are 1% of home value In Year 1, you owe $1k in property taxes. Let's say (dramatically) that property values double in Year 2. - Now, you're $100k home is worth $200k So your property taxes in Year 2 are now $2k. ----- With taxing your unrealized gains at the nominal Federal & State income tax bracket. - Your Federal Income tax rate might be 30% (dependent upon your earnings) - Your State Income tax rate might be 10% So you have a combined 40% tax rate on "earnings" Now in that example of your home going from $100k to $200k in Unrealized gains, you'd have to cut a check for $40K! That's huge and most people wouldn't even have that kind of cash to pay.
- rtsil 2y agoIsn't that the very principle of property taxes? And it has no relation to income, it's the very possession of property (or in this case, financial assets) that triggers it.
- kevmoo1 2y agoYes. Next question.
- unstatusthequo 2y agoI think taxing corporations and removing loopholes will make a much more immediate impact. Tax code is too complex and too many business have ways to dodge.
- exabrial 2y ago[flagged]
- thesuavefactor 2y agoCommunism is not the same socialism. In communism everyone gets the same pay. In socialism, everyone pays the same percentage of their income to help the people who are worst off and pay for the conveniences everyone can beneft from like healthcare, Infrastructure and housing.
- rich_sasha 2y agoUK top marginal tax rate right now is 45%. Many people pay it: doctors, lawyers, architects, not just greedy evil bankers with their big bad bonuses. I don't want the ultra rich to have some special mega-tax to tax them for their obscene wealth. I want their effective income to be taxed the same as all these middle class people pay. As it keeps cropping up, they pay much less, via offshore wealth, accounting tricks etc. I don't know enough about accounting to suggest how this should be done, but to me this ought to be the objective, not some punitive tax, referring to starving children in poor countries.
- Gud 2y agoThe point should be to reduce what doctors and carpenters alike to what the billionaires pay to “the crown”. A 42% tax rate is obscene. A 32% tax rate too. 10% should be the target. I have moved from a high tax society(Sweden) to a low tax society and I prefer it.
- rich_sasha 2y agoI'm not defending the tax rate. I don't like tax, would happy pay less, equally someone has to pay the bill. My point is rather that I want the millionaires to pay the same tax, not some special different one. We already have a social contract saying what people are supposed to pay.
- timbit42 2y agoWhere does the UK top marginal rate start?
- rich_sasha 2y ago125k GBP: https://www.gov.uk/income-tax-rates https://www.gov.uk/income-tax-rates (It's a bit more complicated, but this table is a baseline)
- deepfriedchokes 2y agoBecause capitalism is unbalanced, it was inevitable that it would eventually destroy itself and corrupt our public institutions in the process. The problem is, the people who capital has power over, labor, which is most people on the planet, will be the ones who get hurt the most in the process. And that’s not even considering the cost to earth and its nonhuman inhabitants.
- legitster 2y agoI mean, obviously. But the question is "how?". A lot of the proposals like unearned capital gains taxes or wealth taxes all come with a lot of downsides. Including not actually generating much revenue in practice. The countries are at something of at a Nash Equilibrium. Everyone wants the golden eggs, nobody wants to kill the gooses. Nobody wants their billionaires' money to flight.
- rdtsc 2y ago> Oxfam described the summit as a ‘real litmus test for G20 governments’, urging them to implement an annual net wealth tax of at least eight per cent on the ultra-wealthy. All the governments should agree and play along. As soon a few don't, the wealth will flow there. It's seems trivial, to just increase the tax from 7% to 8%, what's the big deal, just 1% more. But there is a country which for some reason thinks it can profit more from the wealthy moving their money there so they set their rate at 7.5%. The critical part is that wealthy lobby (i.e. bribe) politicians and have enough resources to drum up support from the public via various interest groups and so on. In public they'll agree with the need for more taxes, and more environment protections, all the feel-good topics. But behind the scenes, they'll put the finger on the scale in their favor.
- wonderwonder 2y agoReal question is why are countries cooperating on tax rates? I’m glad the US is not cooperating. Each country is free to implement whatever rules they want as long as they are willing to deal with citizens leaving for other countries. It’s a great way to prevent poor countries from enticing rich people to move there
- wonderwonder 2y agoGovernment has proven over and over they are not equipped to spend the money in an effective manner. Why take money from people who employ others and build businesses to waste on nothing? $7.5 billion to build 8 ev charging stations? (Edit: I accidentally said 8 billion charging stations originally) Billions to build a few miles of rail in California. How many billions on wars? And every year government spending just goes up with almost nothing to show for the average citizen
- fsckboy 2y ago>$7.5 billion to build 8 billion ev charging stations? ev charging stations are under a dollar each? where can i get one?
- wonderwonder 2y ago:) thanks for catching that. I noted the edit
- lostmsu 2y agoMaybe we should diversify, and have 20 separately elected governments each getting to spend 1/20 of the current budget.
- thesuavefactor 2y agoYou're generalizing all governments of all times. Surely there are people in governments that do spend money to benefit the majority? In a democracy, you get to vote for the people you trust most to do so, and vote out the people that don't. In the U.S. there's only two options on a national level, but that is a different problem.
- consteval 2y ago> Billions to build a few miles of rail in California Literally no private company will do it though because trains are too efficient. You make MUCH more money selling cars and gasoline, and then sprawling cities over decades. Trains make no sense if you're trying to make money. So the gov has to do it or it will never be done. > How many billions on wars Straight to defense contractors, who are purposefully lazy and incentivized to suck as much as possible. But they hire a lot of people. > almost nothing to show for the average citizen Yeah, besides your education that is the only reason you can even write this comment. Or the roads. Or the internet you're writing this on. But no, I'm sure if you were illiterate and banging rocks together that's fine. I'm being a little hyperbolic but you get the point.
- throwawa14223 2y agoNo, this is just social engineering.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jacknews 2y agoThe problem should be addressed at source - prevent excessive accumulation of wealth in the first place.
- sershe 2y ago[flagged]
- skmurphy 2y agoThe imputed tax rate is misleading since it conflates unrealized capital gains--assets that have appreciated in value but have not been sold--with income. I would be cautious about imposing "cures" that may cause more problems than the current level of income inequality.
- deafpolygon 2y agoClose the tax loopholes and we should benefit. As it stands, the vast majority of the rich pay very little effective tax. Collectively, the low-income bracket pays more tax.
- Simulacra 2y agoA dilemma perhaps would be if the wealthy are taxed more it will only lead to greater budget deficit spending. I would support higher taxes for specific programs, but want to see a balance budget first.
- ruicraveiro 2y agoHow does that work? If you tax the wealthy more, you actually reduce the budget deficit. Read this: https://flaglerlive.com/gc-fdr-and-taxes/ https://flaglerlive.com/gc-fdr-and-taxes/
- snapplebobapple 2y agoTLDR: No, of course not, that's stupid because taxes are already way too high on income and taxes on assets are extremely bad. We really should break up the monopolies/oligopolies feeding a significant portion of that wealth though. These articles are always extremely obnoxious because they routinely mix up assets and income and have no idea how taxes actually work ignoring that dividends are already taxed once at the corporate level so it is extremely unfair to compare income tax paid on a dividend to income tax paid on income without looking at income tax paid by the corporation on those earnings and when you do that the total income tax is almost always higher than just earning the dollar as income. Further, these initiatives distract from policy action that would actually improve the world, substituting policy action that will only grow government and make it even more wasteful without accomplishing much of anything beyond that. We need to stop talking about stealing more from the winners and instead look at how to ensure they are only winning up to the point where market power abuse becomes obvious and then are mitigated (likely through breaking up the company). We should be starting now with breaking up the myriad obvious oligopolies operating today (looking at you fang stocks, various agricultural conglomerates, various retail operations, etc. with large market shares)
- matthewfelgate 2y agoThe slogan "Tax the rich" is one of those ideas that seems straightforward and appealing at first glance, but it quickly falls apart under closer scrutiny. It's a simplistic solution often promoted by those who lack a deeper understanding of politics and economics. The notion that all of a country's problems can be solved by simply taking more money from "the rich" is fundamentally flawed. First of all, the revenue generated from taxing the wealthy would be surprisingly small in comparison to the overall government budget. While some might argue that "every little bit helps," this ignores the negative consequences of increased taxes on high earners, a reality that many prefer to overlook. History has repeatedly shown that societies leaning too heavily on state control, as seen in failed communist experiments, suffer when individual initiative and enterprise are stifled. Moreover, societal problems are complex, and simply throwing more money at them rarely yields meaningful results. Effective politics is about making informed choices and sound decisions, not resorting to oversimplified slogans. The hard left's reflexive call to "Tax the rich more!" as a catch-all solution is not just naïve—it's intellectually bankrupt.
- ruicraveiro 2y agoOf course they should. Even Nixon charged a marginal tax rate of above 70%. Roosevelt charged 94%. It is not only a matter of fairness, but not doing so is also very dangerous. Billionaires shouldn't exist. A few had a ton of merit. Many inherited. All of them were very lucky, regardless of their merit and effort. But none of the billionaires was elected by the people to have the completely disproportionate power they have over society. So, while I am completely for capitalism and low taxes for everyone, including the wealthy, billionaires should be taxed out of existence. Basically, I think the tax rate curve should be like a hockey stick. Very flat and then suddenly all the way up to almost 100%. The old billionaires would still be able to live very comfortable lifes as millionaires. No single country should be doing this by itself, though. It should be a coordinated effort.