4 ms·
It is. But the issue is that storage systems are quite expensive and not nearly as green as what feeds them. Interestingly when you include these nuclear is mu
by godelski 2y ago
It is. But the issue is that storage systems are quite expensive and not nearly as green as what feeds them.
Interestingly when you include these nuclear is much more competitive. But this depends on the studies and you should pay very close to the assumptions those studies make. Regardless, these are always in aggregate. So even with biases the case always is made that when considering the heterogenous nature of environment that some places will favor nuclear and others will favor renewables (which is again nonhomogeneous as wind and solar aren't always strongly coupled and certainly hydro isn't available everywhere). This is true for the studies that show the best results for nuclear and the studies that show the worst. A major problem with these discussions is people are operating on aggregate assumptions and acting as if it's one or the other.
One interesting part that people might not be aware of is hydrogen production. Nuclear is often argued as a base load so the question is what to do when the sun is shining and wind is strong? You can throttle nuclear but this is not cost effective. But you can in turn produce hydrogen, which can even be used to cheapen and make renewable storage more green. One of the biggest concerns here though is that hydrogen production might be so valuable that nuclear producers might favor that over providing base load.
So as everything, the reality is much more complicated than our general conversations reveal. It's even far more complicated than what can be included in a HN reply. But I hope I gave a sufficient response than can also point to more information.
- natmaka 2y agoObtaining electricity thanks to industrial renewable (see Lazard's LCOE) is way (and more and more) cheaper than with nuclear. There are many ways to alleviate unwanted impacts of 'intermittency' (PEM membranes, central plant enabling many sites exposed to different wind regimes to feed it, batteries...) Hydrogen overproduction (from the grid perspective) isn't a challenge because various industries need huge amounts (~94 millions metric tons/an) of it. Therefore the 'hydrogen' approach favors renewable sources.
- yawaramin 2y agoMost of what you are talking about is theoretical and the real costs will become apparent only once someone tries actually doing it. Meanwhile, nuclear power is proven technology for decades, worldwide.
- natmaka 2y agoThe LCOE (total cost of production) is quite solidly established ( https://www.lazard.com/media/xemfey0k/lazards-lcoeplus-june-2024-_vf.pdf https://www.lazard.com/media/xemfey0k/lazards-lcoeplus-june-... ) and favors renewable sources over nuclear. > the real costs will become apparent It is mainly true for the hydrogen part (water electrolysis) of the system, which is common to nuclear and renewable sources.
- godelski 2y agoEstablished by make sure you know the assumptions it makes too. Don't just take data at face value, make sure you know what the data actually is telling you and importantly what it doesn't tell you.
- ViewTrick1002 2y agoIncredible how the technology that has delivered 3 reactors, all with enormous subsidies, since the late 90s now is "proven". Rather, we spent enormous subsidies on nuclear power and it was proven to not provide energy at commercially workable rates.
- yawaramin 2y agoI'm talking about nuclear power plants in general, which have been in use since the '50s. Not a specific type of reactor. If 'it was proven' then I guess France's electricity shouldn't be cheaper than Germany's? Oh wait...
- natmaka 2y agoThe point is about total cost, and considering all public money invested the French nuclearization isn't a cheaper way. Just compare tax pressure in France and Germany, and their public fundings for the grid. Moreover in case of any mishap (major accident, hot waste wandering around...) all bets are off.
- 2y ago