6 ms·
So, it seems like the architect died in 2018, and Sainsbury in 2022. This could all have been extremely awkward if they'd done the work a few years earlier...
by rsynnott 2y ago
So, it seems like the architect died in 2018, and Sainsbury in 2022. This could all have been extremely awkward if they'd done the work a few years earlier...
- Retr0id 2y agoI'd like to think they'd have just had a laugh about it.
- debo_ 2y agoPerhaps they'd use it as the foundation to support a new friendship with each other /weak architecture joke
- bee_rider 2y agoOr maybe it would turn out that the false columns were actually structurally significant to their friendship, which would subsequently fall apart.
- cmcaleer 2y agoYeah, I can't imagine an argument where this was the compromise was a particularly bitter one.
- shepherdjerred 2y agoI'm sure that the donor made his opinion known given that he went to the trouble of leaving a letter.
- brudgers 2y agoLearning from Las Vegas is Robert Venturi and Denise Scott Brown's seminal work and the ideas drove their work. In a nutshell, buildings are either ducks or decorated sheds. [0] Their clients hired them to design decorated sheds and that is why there were non-structural columns. That doesn't mean the columns did not have a purpose. Columns can create points that organize spatial experience. Columns are cultural iconography (e.g. the Parthenon vs Johnson Wax). There are certain ironies in the fine article: 1. The criticism of the non-structural columns for non-functionality in the context of an art museum. 2. If Venturi and Scott Brown had designed a duck (very common among museum commissions) removing the columns would have been difficult or impossible [1]. For context, Charles Windsor's architectural opinions are contrary not just to the ideas of Venturi and Scott Brown but to the aesthetics of the last 150 years. [0]: https://99percentinvisible.org/article/lessons-sin-city-architecture-ducks-versus-decorated-sheds/ https://99percentinvisible.org/article/lessons-sin-city-arch... [1]: Architects with functional dogma will incorporate structural columns into their designs to achieve iconography and spatial organization because structural use justifies their inclusion.
- fluoridation 2y agoSurely that's an inherent false dichotomy. The mere utterance of "decorated shed" implies the existence of an undecorated shed, where nothing lacks structural purpose. >The criticism of the non-structural columns for non-functionality in the context of an art museum. The letter reads as if the columns are criticized not for lacking structural purpose, but rather for being unnecessary obstructions. "We [will] live to regret our accepting this detail of his design." That would have to be because the columns are either ugly or a hindrance.
- brudgers 2y agoBecause they are sheds, most sheds are undecorated. They are unremaked upon for the same reason. But to be clear, Venturi and Scott Brown’s distinction is in the context of architectural practice. Learning from Las Vegas started as a studio in Harvard’s GSD. The radical idea was looking at actual buildings built for ordinary reasons in ordinary ways…the radical idea was valuing the study from contemporary vernacular architecture.
- milksoup 2y agoIt seems, then, that Venturi and Scott turned out to be like the torpedo fish. That the columns should confuse and disorient the visitor as if entering a crypt.
- hinkley 2y agoWright had the reverse problem. He didn’t want structural elements where nature and physics demanded them. So his stuff sort of falls apart. The last factoid in the tour of his house was how he removed a load bearing wall from his sister’s house and did not replace it. That whole tour was supposed to be for Wright fans but it just made me loathe him with every fiber of my core. Can you tell I’m an applied sciences person?
- brudgers 2y agoThere are lots of reasons to dislike Wright and though his house has historical significance, it is not among the works I find interesting enough to recommend…for me, his houses don’t resonate because they reflect lifestyles I dont identify with. His more public work is another matter. I was struck by the color of the sky against the blue roof the first time I passed Marin County Civic Center from the highway. And Florida Southern in Lakeland is spectacularly good.
- dwighttk 2y agoI bet the architect knew