3 ms·
It sounds like you're talking about Ignite talks, which are a little different. An Ignite talk is five minutes long, but as you indicated the slides are on a fi
by simonw 14y ago
It sounds like you're talking about Ignite talks, which are a little different. An Ignite talk is five minutes long, but as you indicated the slides are on a fixed timer (20 seconds per slide). I absolutely agree that this is not a good format for beginners - Ignite talks are tricky even for very experienced speakers.
I was talking about regular lightning talks where you have five minutes but the format is otherwise completely free form - you don't even need slides, you can just talk. Sure, you still have to edit your talk down to fit the available time but that's a great thing for beginners to have to do, and preparing for five minutes is still easier than preparing for an hour (where it's easy to prepare too much or too little material).
- saurik 14y agoI brought up the slides automatically advancing in te context of some kinds of lightning talks as an extra problem, not the key one (but was concerned that someone would pounce on it as if it were my openly point :(). Editing a talk down to five minutes is hard because it requires editing at all. In contrast, going off on fun-but-useless tangents to fill up a bunch of time is easy, as is using a bunch of examples or other exposition. To compare, in the world of essays, it is well known among undergraduates that there are simple tricks to make an essay as long as required. However, it requires actually knowing what you are doing to make an essay that is short but still dense. So, to now be more explicit: if the slides are not auto-advancing, it does not help the timing problem. If anything, it just lulls people into a false sense of complacency. I have thereby heard Ignite talks described as "convention over configuration" for talks. The problem is that if you screw up even once, and have to restart a thought or argument, realize your audience needs an extra example to make something clear, or simply forget a point an have to fill it in later, you are screwed. In an hour long format, there is probably something later on in your talk that you can cut or shorten to make up the time. You often don't even need to do that, as Q&A is often expected to be included in the time, so you have a massive buffer to heal mistakes (in either direction).