7 ms·
The readme says it is aiming for a “web look”, with no intention to make it look — and, presumably, behave — native. As a user, that’s not what I expect and hop
by layer8 2y ago
The readme says it is aiming for a “web look”, with no intention to make it look — and, presumably, behave — native. As a user, that’s not what I expect and hope for from a desktop application.
- giancarlostoro 2y agoIsn't this the case with a lot of desktop GUIs that are cross platform?
- layer8 2y agoCross-platform desktop UI toolkits generally try to replicate a native look&feel as much as possible.
- giancarlostoro 2y agoDo they? I can usually tell... Most cross-platform GUI stacks I've looked at, the app maybe tweaks the style slightly, but the behavior and look is mostly whatever its own interpretation is, or whatever the developer bothered to do.
- user432678 2y agoFollowing the author for some time and his main point is that “electron” won already, even despite the fact that the author himself doesn’t like it. And he’s not wrong. Majority of desktop users probably don’t care already if it’s native look or not (don’t cite me on that). The goal of the project to provide a way creating quite performant desktop apps with a DX of Clojure. And it’s a nice goal.
- pelagicAustral 2y agoI can relate (I think). I mean, I don't care what the general look of the app is, even if gimmicky of what native desktop looks, as long as the design, general aesthetic, and cohesion are kept well defined, structured and organized. I do not like Electron, I hate to have "little chromes" just so I can do X and Y. I crave true native apps, even if they still look kind of web'ish.
- miroljub 2y agoThere's no native app, even on desktops. There are a bazillion of different UI frameworks with different look & feel on Windows alone, even within Microsoft products. On Linux or macOS, the situation is no better. Native is what doesn't run in an emulator, in this case everything non-Electron fits the definition.
- pxc 2y agoThere are native apps, but appa are native to a desktop environment rather than to an operating system. Unfortunately desktop environments on some proprietary operating systems are themselves comprised of apps written with different toolkits and bearing different looks and feels. But that's just a problem specific to them. KDE apps are all maybe to Plasma, GNOME apps are all native to GNOME.
- alternatex 2y agoWinUI 3 aims to be native, but of course Windows is a tapestry of many eras of Microsoft UI styles. If Microsoft doesn't again change their mind on how Windows should look, then WinUI 3 is indeed the look and behaviour that people will be expecting on a Windows machine.
- rafaelmn 2y agoAt this point it feels like this argument is dead an buried. So many non-native apps on every platform, most platforms even have multiple official GUI toolkits/widget styles so even first party apps are inconsistent.
- nine_k 2y agoThe most consistently-looking desktop I have runs under Linux. With a few settings and a right theme, all GTK2, GTK3, Qt, and Java apps look and feel pretty much the same, in a pleasant way. MacOS is a close second, with a few native apps that can't decide exactly what a checkbox or a button should look like. And Win10 on my wife's machine is a salad, reminding me of Linux desktop experience from 1998.
- diggan 2y ago> And Win10 on my wife's machine is a salad, reminding me of Linux desktop experience from 1998. This is pretty funny, because if you just use Gnome apps + desktop environment, you have a consistent experience. But if you only use Microsoft/Windows GUIs, panels and applications, it nowhere near as consistent. So even the Gnome team can build better UI and UX than Windows themselves can, pretty telling.
- chrisldgk 2y ago> even the Gnome team People like to hate on them, but their design is actually really good, innovative and the applications running on GTK are incredibly fast and stable.
- mixmastamyk 2y agoAs long as you don’t use title bars, menus, or scrollbars you’re golden.
- nine_k 2y agoI'm not a fan of some of their UX design decisions, but I must admit that they seemingly know what they're doing, and their execution / implementation is pretty good. I also hope that, unlike MS, they have no infighting between departments, and no stack ranking.
- diggan 2y agoProfessional software (think Clip Studio Art, 3DS Max, Autodesk Fusion and alike) are almost exclusively disconnected from "native" looks, behavior and theming, which is perfectly fine, better than having a different experience depending on your OS. I feel like it's mostly consumers who ask for native look, and particular users on macOS, as almost all other professional-oriented software doesn't offer that. But yet it comes up for every GUI toolkit that lands on the HN frontpage.
- hombre_fatal 2y agoI doubt most consumers ask for a native look. It's more like an HN meme. I don't even think native macOS UI is so great cross-plat programs should target it. It's full of its own weird conventions like a "New item" button being a tiny "+" at the bottom of the left sidebar, the last place I always look. Safari is an example of UX that has stuck to hard macOS conventions and was always worse off for it. Not until recently did it begin relenting, and now it's bearable to use as a daily driver. Xcode is another classic example of hostile native macOS UX conventions. Finder.app is another. I'd rather software ask "what's the UX that makes the most sense?" rather than "how can I make my UI look native?" On HN people seem to think by solving the latter, you solve the former. But that isn't the case.
- Bjartr 2y ago> I doubt most consumers ask for a native look. It's more like an HN meme. The preference for native look was once about the impact of familiarity on usability. When 95% of people's interactions with computers was a single OS and native apps, they would expect controls to look a particular way. They could figure out other variants, sure, but from a UX design perspective, there's little reason to add that minor cognitive overhead needlessly. Today, people's experiences are less likely to be monoculture like they once were, which dilutes one of the values of native controls. That's not to say designing with familiarity of controls in mind doesn't have value, just that it's less about, for example, buttons looking like buttons native to the OS, and more about visually reading as "this is a button" more generally.
- ducktective 2y ago
- tonsky 2y agoIt’s a tradeoff. You either make your app native but only for one platform, or you make it look “universal” and run on all three.
- layer8 2y agoThat’s not accurate, there are cross-platform toolkits that achieve at least a close-to-native look&feel. This is very different from giving up on it entirely and going web-style UI.
- tonsky 2y agoIf they use native widgets, they usually look really bad If they just “imitate” look and feel, they usually fall very short of the real thing Either way, it’s bad experience for the end user
- cess11 2y agoI don't know, I think the Racket GUI toolkit and JavaFX work fine for building cross platform standalone applications.
- tonsky 2y agoThat’s two perfect examples! Racket seems to try to use native widgets, and looks horrible as a result, at least on macOS JavaFX uses the same approach as Humble UI: they draw all the widgets themselves and have custom cross-platform look and feel. We aim to be better quality version of JavaFX
- kaba0 2y agoDo you mean the state of the art java AWT and/or Eclipse toolkit?