4 ms·
In the machine shop world, the greybeards are retiring and young workers aren't interested in being machinists. It's turning into a crisis. It's a national tre
by WalterBright 2y ago
In the machine shop world, the greybeards are retiring and young workers aren't interested in being machinists. It's turning into a crisis.
It's a national trend, and I see it specifically in the Seattle area as one can no longer get engines remachined. The shops I used in the past are all gone. Boeing is also having a lot of trouble replacing their greybeard machinists.
- trilbyglens 2y agoSounds like a problem that paying fair wages could solve
- ryandrake 2y agoYea, I do metal working as a hobby and would love to try being a professional machinist, but I'm not willing to do it for 25% of my current comp pushing bits around transistors.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoThe crisis is an inability to find workers unwilling to accept low wages as structural demographic decline continues. Great for workers, terrible for poorly constructed socioeconomic systems.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoPay a decent wage and people will do almost anything. Problem is that while the new narrative is praising blue collar work and encouaraging work in the trades, you are supposedly (love for others to chime in with experience) paid peanuts, maybe even below minimum wage, for a 2-3 years apprenticeship before you can start doing real work. So, you basically go to college with none of the college experience. You're not in debt but you also don't really have loans to live on either. It's just not feasible unless you already have a living situation, and those that can pay for that will simply send the kid to college anyway. It's a mess all around.
- xboxnolifes 2y agoEven with all that, in my area it seems like you also need to already know people to get into one of the trade unions. At least of people I know of trying to get in are having issues.
- silverquiet 2y agoThe blue collar workers I actually know do not make very good money. I was literally talking with my parents last night about my cousin's baby-daddy. He's worked in HVAC, painting, and now in warehouse door repair/maintenance (a speciality that I didn't know existed but makes sense given modern logistics). The last job is seen as a real career (with health insurance even), but he's unable to move out of his parents' house for some reason. He's had some problems, but as far as I know has worked full time for most of the last decade. My brother is one of the most skilled carpenters that I know and did some really good home reno type work, but finally put his ME degree to use and got an engineering job that's construction adjacent. He was also amazed to get health insurance and paid time off. Two examples among many that I know. I often see people on forums like this talking about how trades are a sure way to a middle class life, and I don't know what reality they're inhabiting.
- WalterBright 2y agoSkilled machinists are not like house painters. They get paid well.
- iJohnDoe 2y agoMaybe sometimes but generally not. Machine shops are a race to the bottom on competing for jobs/contracts. There are always exceptions though with everything It will truly be a crisis with the greybeards retiring and the knowledge they take with them.
- WalterBright 2y ago> Machine shops are a race to the bottom It's not a race to the bottom. It's movement towards where the Supply and Demand curves intersect. If it was a race to the bottom, skilled machinists would be paid minimum wage.
- mox1 2y agoI would say it's not that "young workers aren't interested in being machinists" it's more of "Society has not incentivized young workers enough to want to become machinists." It's probably a combination of things (high schools telling every student they need to go to college, wages too low to attract new talent, other things?), but there is a low chance in my mind that 16-25 year olds are not interested in working with their hands. The DIY / Hobbyist community has never been larger or more available. High school robotics is bigger than ever, 3D-printing and related things are very popular....
- dylan604 2y agoThe whole period of time forcing the idea that everyone must go to college has come home to roost. At the same time trade schools were panned while also filled with scam schools. Some people just do not need/want the full rounded education nor the expense of it all.
- WalterBright 2y agoThe worthless college degrees are the "gee, math is hard" ones. At Caltech, you could get a soft degree, but you still had to pass 3 years of math, 2 years of physics, and 1 year of chemistry. There weren't any "weeder" versions of them, either. P.S. I could work the quantum mechanics problems, but was uncomfortable because I didn't understand QM. Years later I learned that nobody understands QM, they just know the math works :-)
- consteval 2y agoAt the same time high schools have cut a lot of this stuff out of their curriculum. I mean, no more woodshop, no more metal work. And it's not like these kids can go home and work on their car. Cars these days are too complex for that.
- Ekaros 2y agoAre they paying them more than software engineers? If not, that is the problem. Increase the pay and they will come.
- bigfatkitten 2y agoBay Area software engineers are a pretty tiny portion of the population, despite this community's outsized view of itself.
- bigfatkitten 2y agoSociety has spent the last few decades pissing on highly skilled, well paying and essential blue collar jobs. We have been actively discouraging kids who would excel in the field from pursuing it, in favour of getting them to into comparatively useless university degrees that they have no interest in or aptitude for.