2 ms·
This definition leaves out those in a bureaucracy who are only devoted to themselves. I assume since their personal devotions may or may not have to do with the
by xnx 2y ago
This definition leaves out those in a bureaucracy who are only devoted to themselves. I assume since their personal devotions may or may not have to do with the goals of the organization or the organization itself that their impact cancels out.
- Bluestein 2y ago> This definition leaves out those in a bureaucracy who are only devoted to themselves. Indeed that's a frequent specimen, along with what I would call "devoted to nothing" - simple freeloaders, there for the ride, just getting by through the law of minimal effort ...
- virgilp 2y agoThis is a good observation but one can argue that those devoted to themselves are a subset of those devoted to the organization (to further their goals, they act as being part of the second category, since that's the most profitable)
- hammock 2y agoIf you're being paid by the organization, you're being paid for something. Either for work that accretes to the goals of the organization, work that accretes to the organization itself, or some combination of the two
- wcunning 2y agoThat's a fine interpretation, but the observable evidence lately would indicate otherwise. The two terms to look into are "institutions as platforms" from Yuval Levin at the American Enterprise Institute [0], describing congressional representatives who spend more staff budget on comms than policy and more of their time on cable news hits than on committee meetings. The second is "public choice theory" economics which is the branch of economics describing why policy doesn't align with stated goals on a regular basis. Robin Hanson had a good substack on the second one just today, in fact [1]. [0] - https://www.npr.org/2020/01/30/800922222/when-institutions-are-used-as-stages-people-lose-trust-book-argues https://www.npr.org/2020/01/30/800922222/when-institutions-a... [1] - https://www.overcomingbias.com/p/the-big-econ-error https://www.overcomingbias.com/p/the-big-econ-error
- jandrewrogers 2y agoYes, when I was doing work for the UN there were three categories of people in the organization and the lines between them were quite bright. I've described it this way to many people who are curious. You had the true believers in the mission, which was a minority. You had an army of bureaucrats, who were solely motivated by a steady paycheck and were incentivized to be paperwork and meeting maximalists to justify their lifetime appointment. And then you had a large minority -- larger than the true believers -- of grifters and sinecures, typically a nephew of the president of some undeveloped country or similar, who were openly there to collect as much free money as possible without even the pretense of work. That last group, while obviously devoted to themselves, were devoted to the organization to the extent that they are parasites and the organization is the host. But they only need the organization to exist, not the organization's mission.
- alphazard 2y agoIt should always be assumed that everyone participating in a bureaucracy is selfishly motivated. The difference is some people see a path to personal success by creating shareholder value (better product, less cost, etc.), while other people focus on fortifying their current arrangement to ensure it can't be made worse.