5 ms·
A Massachusetts town closes its parks to stop a mosquito-borne disease
- Workaccount2 2y agoWe have been investigating (and even implementing) ways to kill off mosquito populations for years now. I don't know why we are dragging our feet on scaling this up. Are we too hung up on potentially erasing 10% of a bats diet?
- dylan604 2y agoTaking into account all of human history of attempting to be smarter than we are and looking at all of the unforeseen results from humans meddling with things, I'm kind of okay dragging our feet. One species trying to wipe out another species should be something that should be asked "is that what really needs to be done" before just doing it. Look at the buffalo for example. A group of humans were willing to wipe out an animal species to control a different group of humans. I don't care if it is "just" a mosquito. I do not think we full understand the repercussions of wiping out an entire species.
- lupusreal 2y agoWhat about all the times it went well and therefore never gets brought up in these conversations? Like eradicating cave lions in Europe.
- mikeocool 2y agoCave lions went extinct 13,000 years ago, and it’s generally thought that was due to change in climate, not humans.
- card_zero 2y agoHow about the species Mycobacterium tuberculosis?
- jajko 2y agoI am all for being loving and respecting towards nature, but mosquitos and ticks should be erased from face of this planet for good. Food chains would absorb this change without breaking a sweat, compared to what humans are causing daily. Every effin' year around 700k people (mostly children and old) die only from mosquito-borne ones, I presume ticks don't add that much on top of that. It cripples entire economies to halt, feeding massive disparities in the world set up by colonialism. Its a typical western privilege talking this style about matters not directly threatening lives of you and your closest ones. I guess you would have a different opinion when say your mother would die during your childhood from it, or saw your sibling being disabled for life from early age by it. Do similar people feel same sympathies towards syphilis or bubonic plague? Whether something is single celled or multicellular organism shouldn't make much difference.
- card_zero 2y agoOr Pthirus pubis (the pubic louse), if you want an insect. Outbreaks are not exactly a major issue, but it's not clear to me why it would be a cause for regret if it went extinct in the wild. (Now I'm wondering which scientist or zookeeper would preserve the last remaining specimens in captivity, and how, but that's a sidetrack.)
- dylan604 2y ago> but it's not clear to me why it would be a cause for regret if it went extinct in the wild. This is precisely the point. Just because you can't doesn't meant it isn't there. The hubris to think that just because the reason can't be seen right now with the limited information available at the time of decision means everything will be fine is exactly my point of hesitation on any of these decisions.
- lupusreal 2y agoIf eradicating pubic lice is excessive hubris, then refusing to eradicate pubic lice for fear of some unknown consequence is cowardice.
- bankcust08385 2y ago> I do not think we full understand the repercussions of wiping out an entire species. But think of the children of mosquitoes! In this case, I'm willing to take that chance given the fact that malaria has killed around 5 billion people cumulatively over history.
- slowmovintarget 2y agoThere are four species of mosquito that feed on humans. Taking them out would eliminate Malaria, West Nile, EEE, Dengue Fever, Zika, and many other life threatening diseases in humans without seriously impacting the food chain (there are many other types of mosquitos for birds, wasps, and dragon flies to nosh on). None of these four species serve a useful or irreplaceable purpose... None of them. We actually have studied this. We should do this. Not with pesticide. With large populations of sterile males.
- SeehHause 2y ago[flagged]
- dlivingston 2y agoCan you share some details? I would unironically _love_ to see mosquitos made extinct, but I have no idea how that would affect the broader ecosystem and food chain.
- ygjb 2y agoIf you don't know why society is dragging it's feet on wiping out, you should probably educate yourself before making such a suggestion. Mosquitos suck, literally, and I despise them, but they are a critical link in the ecosystems they live in. Everybody wants to save the bees because they make honey and aren't assholes like Wasps, but bees are far from the only pollinators. Without Mosquitos, a lot of animals a few steps up the food chain suffer, including bats, birds, larger insect predators like dragonflys, but also frogs and fish. Female mosquitos are the ones that are most problematic, since they need to consume blood for nutrition for reproduction, but mosquitos also consume nectar and are pollinators. Wiping out mosquitos would probably be achievable, but it would also kick the ladder out from under ecosystems that are already extremely fragile at a time when we are in the middle of the largest extinction event in human history (and potentially mammalian history, depends how far the holocene extinction proceeds).
- autokad 2y agomosquitos are also valuable pollinators, they drink nectar most of their lives. I believe they are also an important food source for dragonflies. I am also unfamiliar with how they are planning on taking them out. we need to make sure there isn't collateral damage or hardening the genetic strength of mosquitos
- coryrc 2y agoPeople aren't proposing eliminating all mosquitos (well, I am, but the professionals aren't), they're proposing to eliminate only the ones that carry human diseases, which is only a few and several being non-native.
- mbrubeck 2y agoMosquito elimination has been a common public health measure for a long time, mainly by draining swamps and spraying pesticides. (The Massachusetts town in the article will be spraying pesticides.) And many countries have more recently been releasing millions of sterilized mosquitoes, which can quickly drive down populations. You may be thinking of the relatively new gene-drive experiments. I believe these are mainly focused on Aedes aegypti, which is the biggest vector for many human diseases. Aedes aegypti is a non-native invasive species in the Americas (and many other parts of the world). But the disease discussed in this article (Eastern equine encephalitis) is spread by native mosquitoes including Culiseta melanura. I expect that many people who are okay with eliminating invasive species will be more hesitant about eliminating native ones, even harmful ones. On the other hand, we’ve long been eliminating mosquitoes in populated areas with the lower-tech methods discussed above. (Not to mention killing off countless other plant and animal species every year unintentionally/neglectfully.)
- bankcust08385 2y agoAmerica eliminated malaria endemic to the South through dedicated and systematic control measures. While they weren't able to eliminate mosquitoes, I'm confident we could if we really wanted to. We've eliminated smallpox, passenger pigeons, emu, dodo, and likely dozens of late Pleistocene American megafauna herbivores.
- Modified3019 2y agoWe need to eradicate human biting mosquito species (which are only a tiny fraction of mosquito species) with release of sterile mates like we do with some other pests.
- SoftTalker 2y agoLife finds a way.
- beached_whale 2y agoThey are doing something similar in central/south american to keep livestock from getting infected with screwworms
- jncfhnb 2y agoThe experiments trying to do that failed
- Eric_WVGG 2y agoHm. That's a bummer. https://biosafety-info.net/articles/agriculture-organisms/insectsmicroorganisms/cayman-islands-abandons-failed-gm-mosquito-project/ https://biosafety-info.net/articles/agriculture-organisms/in... https://theprint.in/science/gm-mosquito-experiment-to-reduce-dengue-causing-species-in-brazil-fails/292943/ https://theprint.in/science/gm-mosquito-experiment-to-reduce...
- coryrc 2y agoThose ones aren't the "males only have male children" ones I've heard about before. The strategy these employ seems to require regular infusions like the screwfly to be effective and they didn't plan that.
- neilv 2y agoEvery time I see the advice to wear insect-repellent every time going outdoors, I wonder whether that's actually good advice, and what the health pros&cons are. Like "Murray Gell-Man Amnesia", usually when I see public advice in MSM about something I know (e.g., computers), it's mostly wrong, and to the exclusion of good advice. And this smells like that. Also suspicious is that protocol is missing. For example, how do you use bug spray, where on body, do you really need it every time you go outside, when do you wash it off and how, what about clothing, why do only sometimes they say not to use such-and-such spray on children and pregnant/nursing women (but other times they don't), does advice differ for urban vs. rural, what are the side effects or adverse interactions to know, etc. Do they think people will read all the 6pt narrow speckled white on orange fine print on the package of whatever they buy? Do they not think that people will end up believing whatever essential oils MLM dropshipping influencer quackery and snake essential-oil they see on the Web?
- javagram 2y ago> Also suspicious is that protocol is missing. For example, how do you use bug spray Realistically, the people who do not read the instructions literally on the side of the bottle they are applying to themselves are certainly not going to go back and pull up a news article they saw a day, week or month ago and try to get the instructions from there. Never mind how error prone that would be as each "repellent" chemical has different instructions and warnings (permethrin goes on clothes, while DEET goes on your skin for instance).
- jncfhnb 2y agoIt seems awfully paranoid to leap from “the protocol isn’t totally clear” to “do they think I believe everything on the internet?!”. Read the bottle. Put it on. If you’re in an area prone to Lyme disease it’ll be far worse than any tiny degree of poison from bug spray.
- neilv 2y agoFor example: You just instructed people to put on bug repellent, without qualifying that. Then you appended a supporting rationale that applies only to some people, in support of your advice. So it's unclear whether you're speaking from a public health strategy, informed by expert knowledge on pertinent topics, and trying to minimize net harm over a large population, when you can use only a few broadcast words. Or whether you have almost no idea what you're talking about, but are simply parroting your own interpretation of those few words you heard. I'm speaking as the kind of person who was fine getting Covid vaccine, as soon as I heard doctors in general were giving it to their own families. I'm asking why I keep seeing this particular blanket advice about bug repellent, and what does it actually mean. For example, if we take some of the uses of this soundbite advice literally, it would imply that the situation is so dire that even incurring a population percentage of known adverse effects from people who will follow these instructions without reading the back of the bottle and second-guessing, is worthwhile. I think I need a straight answer about what it means, from someone who knows what they're talking about, including about any public health and communications calculus involved.
- yinser 2y agoI predict it will be difficult for people to reason about this without their biases around COVID, one way or another. Personally EEE sounds terrifying.
- krunck 2y agoSo there is a vaccine for horses. It's made of dead EEE virus material. Why isn't there one for people? How much harder can it be?
- bastawhiz 2y agoThe development probably isn't hard, but going through trials to get it approved isn't very fast or cheap.
- subsubzero 2y agoSo is the 30% fatality rate for humans or horses? The article does not make this clear at all. On a side note for the past few years we have been spraying for mosquitos(using a pest control firm to handle this) from mid spring to late summer and have had zero issues with being outside in backyard. I think alot of people do not know about this option and think the only option for summer months is a hellscape of mosquitos and bites.