3 ms·
An annoying reminder to people: Reason is making this a national news story, but it's more meaningfully a local news story. For residents in much of the country
by tptacek 2y ago
An annoying reminder to people: Reason is making this a national news story, but it's more meaningfully a local news story. For residents in much of the country, if you simply engage in local politics --- in most places, very few people seriously do this! --- you can get policing officials fired for saying ridiculous stuff like this. Residents probably have more say in how policing functions than they do in almost any other public policy matter (maybe, depending on your state, excepting public schooling).
Our PD wanted to roll out Flock cameras villagewide, and citizen involvement commissions ratcheted down the deployment to a handful of cameras, which are not authorized for use for stopping even stolen vehicles, just violent crime suspects and stolen license plates. The PD wanted it to be otherwise, but it does not take a lot of public pressure to rein them in: the ABQ city council is the boss, not the police chief.
I'm not saying Reason is wrong; they're clearly right, and this person is a moron. But I'm strongly urging people to engage locally on stuff like this, rather than bloodying their foreheads on national politics. Or, worse, convincing themselves that there's nothing at all to be done about it; that's what people like this ABQ Chief are counting on.
- ipaddr 2y agoEvery place is different and has different pressure points. The police in other places that have stronger political positions will have more leeway.
- tptacek 2y agoI was going to write a guarantee that engaging in local politics will be more effective than writing about it on a message board, but engaging with local politics often is exactly that: message board discussions with your neighbors. So a first step I'd offer to finding those pressure points: figure out where your neighbors talk about policy (and other stuff), and post.
- heavyset_go 2y agoAgree with your point, but do want to point out I've lived in places where not toeing the local party line results in real life harassment, even stalking of people's kids, from friends of elected and non-elected officials. Sometimes that local party line is that police are infallible, and if you ever disagree with what they want to do, that must mean you're criminal and hate police, and are made a local pariah when you're personally called out by the police chief. People have been driven out of town for voicing support for BLM, for example, not to mention the harassment that comes from participating in school board meetings if you disagree with the board. Not even sure what my point is here, other than saying that sometimes engaging in local politics isn't safe for everyone. I made a post about it here on HN in the past, but I watched a single mother get doxxed and harassed because she disagreed with the mayor on policy. The mayor did the doxxing. YMMV of course.
- aaomidi 2y agoThere is a non-zero percent chance that a cop in that situation will retaliate. With Guns.
- tptacek 2y agoI didn't realize I was such a daredevil!
- aaomidi 2y agoI'm glad nothing has happened to you. And I hope it never does. However that does not negate what I said earlier. If a cop is willing to say that they don't have to have body cams on, then they're also probably willing to exact revenge on you if you fuck with them too much.
- ein0p 2y agoYou’re making it sound easier and more certain than it really is. “Engaging with local government” is very often ineffective. Case in point: our municipal government bought a hotel right across the road from a high school and converted it for housing the homeless. That wouldn’t necessarily be a problem, but in this case there are no prerequisites, and sex offenders and drug addicts are OK, right next to the school. There was a “public comment” meeting, lots of people (myself included) came and protested, only to be told in the end: “fuck off, the decision has already been made and there’s no recourse”. Which is to say, complaining seems to only work if you can play different parts of the government against one another, or if they’re already looking for a justification to do what you’re proposing. If that is not the case, you’re SOL.
- jfengel 2y agoThere's a reason they say "you can't fight city hall"
- tptacek 2y agoPublic comment isn't engagement. I know hearing that will piss you off. But apart from putting up giant numbers, numbers way out of norm of what contentious issues pull into meetings, it's just about the least effective way to influence your local government. Everybody knows the score: public comment is canvassed before the meeting, and (again, unless you're putting up huge numbers) represents attempts by tiny minorities of the community to override the will of the voters, by paying more attention than ordinary voters and showing up on a random Tuesday night to complain. The irony is, there are plenty of ways for tiny minorities to exert outsized influence in most communities. Here's a really basic one: instead of showing up and giving tedious public comment, reach out directly to your council members (or, better yet, the relevant commissioners, if they exist, who probably never get any kind of public comment) and do private comment. That's not much more effective than public comment, but it is more effective. There are better things to do than that! (Having said all this: I'm glad your muni made the decision it did. The high schoolers will be fine. Building housing for homeless people is good for the community. Every time a muni does it, people come out of hte woodwork with stories about sex offenders and drug addicts. Sounds like your council has its head screwed on right; good for them.)
- HaZeust 2y agoIn terms of being active in my local public policy, and building community power - are there any prominent pieces on how-to?
- sidewndr46 2y agoWhat exactly are you suggesting here? That we write a strongly worded letter to city council about the police?
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> write a strongly worded letter to city council about the police? Just show up and speak. Even if unofficially. Most people can’t be bothered to, and that gives the move power. I’ve literally helped insert language into legislation at the state level because I was the only one who called on a niche bill and my state Assemblyman didn’t have the staff to go through it.
- tptacek 2y agoHow about: "join a citizens commission, any of them, and familiarize yourself with your police oversight commission".
- knowaveragejoe 2y agoEven the slightest level of effort to be involved as a citizen would be a good start.