3 ms·
Dotcom is being prosecuted for knowingly and deliberately directing and encouraging the unlawful behavior of his users, and it's a criminal prosecution rather t
by tptacek 2y ago
Dotcom is being prosecuted for knowingly and deliberately directing and encouraging the unlawful behavior of his users, and it's a criminal prosecution rather than a civil case because he's accused of building a (lucrative) business off the effort. You don't have to agree with the case or believe the DOJ has made it adequately (it's early to say, given the extradition drama), but it's not reasonable to say that Dotcom is being prosecuted "for what his users did", any more than it would be reasonable to say that a mafia kingpin was being prosecuted for what their street crews did at their behest.
(I have no idea what's going on with Durov, or how French and/or EU law works, except to say that legal analysis on HN tends sharply towards US norms, and people should remember that a lot of basic US legal norms, like the rules of evidence and against self-incrimination, do not generally apply in Europe.)